Brice Turang keeps piling up the kind of first halves that should make All-Star decisions easy. Instead, MLB has found a way to leave the Brewers second baseman out in the cold again.
Turang is in his fourth major league season, and for the third straight year he’s been part of the All-Star conversation. This time, though, there’s no clear path left for him to get into the 2026 Midsummer Classic, with just four days left for that to change. The 26-year-old looks headed for a third straight snub.
The frustration starts with how this has played out before. In 2024, Turang broke out after a rough rookie season in 2023, when he was among the worst qualified hitters in MLB.
By the end of June that year, he was hitting .292/.354/.417 and had put himself among the best second basemen in the National League. Arizona’s Ketel Marte won the fan vote and the starting job at second base, and that part made sense.
What didn’t make sense was MLB’s choice for the NL backup at the position. The league went with then-San Diego Padres infielder Luis Arraez, even though Arraez barely played second base in the first half of 2024.
Turang had the better OPS, more home runs, more RBI and more stolen bases before the break, and he was also the stronger defender. Arraez, by contrast, was a poor defender at the time.
Turang put together another solid first half in 2025, hitting .274/.345/.366 with 39 RBI and 17 stolen bases. Even then, he was barely in the All-Star picture. Marte and backup second baseman Brendan Donovan both belonged in last year’s game, but Turang still seemed to have built up enough momentum to get a fair look in 2026.
That fair look never came. Turang missed MLB’s initial All-Star roster reveal, and when Shohei Ohtani’s replacement was announced, the Brewers second baseman was passed over again.
St. Louis Cardinals catcher/designated hitter Iván Herrera got the nod instead.
The fan vote didn’t help Turang, and that part may land on Brewers fans. But the bigger issue is how the process keeps tilting toward players from big-market teams.
All nine of the National League’s initial starting position players came from one of the six biggest-market teams in the league. The only team from one of those six markets without a starter was the Chicago Cubs.
That setup helped push Turang and other NL second basemen behind Atlanta’s Ozzie Albies for the starting spot. Even after that, there was still an opening for MLB to make things right with the reserve picks. Instead, when the reserves were announced on Independence Day, Arraez got the backup second-base spot again.
Arraez is at least playing second base this year, and his defense has improved. But Turang still has the better OPS, more home runs, more doubles, more walks, more RBI and more stolen bases. The batting average is the one area where Arraez has the edge, but Turang has been the better all-around player.
Then came the Ohtani opening. When Ohtani opted out of the All-Star Game because of left knee soreness, Brewers fans had reason to think Turang might finally get his due. Instead, Herrera was chosen.
That decision stings even more because Turang’s case is stronger almost everywhere you look. He has a 3.3 fWAR, while Herrera sits at 1.5.
Turang also offers far more value defensively. After what happened in 2024, and after being passed over twice again in 2026, the Brewers have every reason to be annoyed.
Turang may still get his All-Star moment someday. For now, though, it’s hard to ignore that he could already have two selections to his name.
In Other News...
Brewers Make Late Pitching Adjustment For Suddenly Messy Pirates Series
Rain turned Friday night into a wash in Pittsburgh, and now the Brewers have to navigate a compressed weekend with a doubleheader waiting on Saturday. The makeup games will start at 11:05 a.m. CT and 3:05 p.m. CT, turning what was supposed to be a single series opener into a much busier day for a Milwaukee club that suddenly needs more arms available.
To help cover the extra innings and the uncertainty that comes with a twin bill, Milwaukee also adjusted its pitching staff and made roster moves before the games. The shuffle gives the Brewers a little more flexibility heading into a day that already looks like it could test both the bullpen and the depth chart, with the pitching matchups now set and the workload spread across two games instead of one. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Fans Know This Round 1 Pick Could Go Several Ways
With the 2026 MLB Draft underway, the Brewers are once again in the familiar spot of trying to thread a narrow needle in the first round. Milwaukee will make 20 picks over the next two days, and the early projections have pointed in several directions, from college arms to impact bats and even a few names with local ties. At this stage, the mock-draft chatter says as much about the Brewers drafting reputation as it does about any one player.
Cameron Flukey, Ace Reese, Cole Prosek and Zion Rose have all surfaced as possible first-round answers, which is a reminder that Milwaukees preferred path is rarely obvious this time of year. The Brewers have built a track record of taking calculated swings based on fit and value, and this years slot only adds to the uncertainty. For a club picking late in the round, the question is less about who fits on paper than which direction the front office decides to trust when it finally goes on the clock. [Read more 🡒]