Freddy Peralta’s name still carries weight in Milwaukee. That much is obvious. He built a résumé that any club would love to point to: a 75-51 career record, a 3.79 ERA, more than 1,200 strikeouts in a little over 1,000 innings, two All-Star selections, and three straight seasons with more than 200 strikeouts from 2023-2025.
But the case against bringing him back with the Brewers is just as clear, and it starts with what his 2026 season has looked like after Milwaukee dealt him to the New York Mets ahead of this year, along with Tobias Myers. In return, the Brewers received utility player Jett Williams and right-hander Brandon Sproat. Since then, Peralta has been in the middle of one of the roughest seasons of his major league career.
Now with the Tampa Bay Rays, the 30-year-old is 5-9 with a 5.37 ERA across 23 starts. He has struck out 116 batters in 117 1/3 innings, but the rest of the line tells the story: a 1.52 WHIP, 19 home runs allowed, and a batting average of .260 or better against four of his six pitches. That’s a far cry from the version Milwaukee once leaned on as an ace.
The warning signs go beyond the surface numbers. Peralta’s walk rate has climbed to 9.2 percent, and his strikeout rate sits at 21.8 percent, both of which point in the wrong direction.
His fastball has also lost some life, coming in at 94.2 miles per hour on average, his lowest mark since 2022. For a pitcher whose game is built on power, that matters.
And even if Milwaukee wanted to bank on a bounce-back, there’s no guarantee it would happen. The source points to Jake Arrieta as the cautionary tale: after winning a Cy Young with the Cubs in 2016, he had rough seasons with the Phillies, then returned to the northsiders five years later and posted a 7.39 ERA, nearly three runs worse than his 4.64 mark from a couple of years earlier. Peralta, now on the wrong side of 30 and struggling badly, does not offer much reason to expect a clean return to form just because he’d be wearing old colors again.
There’s also the workload problem. Even at his peak, Peralta was never exactly an easy five-and-done.
He has long worked in a way that pushes pitch counts up, thanks to a lower-than-average rate of pitches in the zone and a pitches-per-plate-appearance mark north of 4.1. That often leads to those 100-pitch outings that only last five innings.
It’s the kind of profile that can wear down a bullpen, even when the results are better than they are now.
Milwaukee’s current rotation makes the argument against a reunion even stronger. Jacob Misiorowski is in the mix for an NL Cy Young award, Kyle Harrison has been a strong secondary option, and controllable, affordable arms such as Coleman Crow and Logan Henderson are part of the picture as well. In that context, Peralta would almost certainly cost more than most of those arms, if not all of them, and the Brewers do not need to chase expensive uncertainty when they already have younger pitching to sort through.
With the salary cap looming, the Brewers need production and affordability to line up. Peralta’s track record is impressive, but his current form, age, workload, and price tag make a reunion look like the wrong move.
In Other News...
Brewers Suddenly Face A Brice Turang Problem They Couldn't Afford
The Brewers got a scare when Brice Turang exited with a thumb issue in the game against the Padres, and it comes at a time when Milwaukee can least afford another infield problem. Turang has become one of the clubs more important offensive pieces, and the Brewers are already trying to navigate life without Cooper Pratt, who is on the injured list.
If Turang needs any time at all, Milwaukees depth is going to be tested quickly. That would likely push more responsibility onto Jihwan Bae, David Hamilton and Joey Ortiz, a group the Brewers may soon need to trust in bigger roles while they wait to see how serious Turangs setback turns out to be. [Read more 🡒]
Jackson Chourio's Early Exit Sent Brewers Fans A Clear Message
Jackson Chourios night ended earlier than expected, but the Brewers had a larger picture in mind when they pulled him from a comfortable game. With Milwaukee in a strong spot, manager Pat Murphy chose to protect one of the clubs most important young players, a reminder that the endgame now is less about squeezing out extra innings in September and more about making sure the roster is right when the postseason arrives.
The decision also came against the backdrop of a few nagging health concerns around the clubhouse, with Brice Turang dealing with a sore thumb and William Contreras having taken a swing off the wrist. Milwaukee framed Chourios exit as a precaution, not a setback, and that kind of caution makes sense for a team trying to keep its core intact while the games start to matter more. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Suddenly Face A Depth Test They Cant Escape
The Brewers are trying to keep the lineup moving through a stretch that has turned into a real test of infield and outfield depth. Rookie shortstop Cooper Pratt is sidelined with a hamstring strain, Brice Turang is working through a sprained thumb, and the club has already had to mix and match by bringing in Ji Hwan Bae while leaning on Andrew Vaughn and Turang to cover spots around the diamond.
Sal Frelick is part of the same uneasy picture, with the outfielder on the injured list because of a right shoulder strain. Milwaukee has been able to keep patching holes for now, but the next few days should say plenty about how long that can last, especially with multiple regulars still working their way back and the club trying to avoid losing more ground while the lineup is pieced together. [Read more 🡒]