As the August 3 trade deadline approaches, the Brewers and Guardians could wind up circling the same name for very different reasons.
Milwaukee’s ideal deadline haul would include a top-end starting pitcher and/or a third baseman, with bullpen help and a right-handed power bat in the outfield also on the table. Cleveland, tied for first in the AL Central at the All-Star Break, is looking for help in the outfield and, according to ESPN’s Jeff Passan, would love to add a hitter with more power upside. Passan identified Brewers outfielder Garrett Mitchell as the kind of fit the Guardians would want.
That kind of deal would be a tough one for Milwaukee to stomach.
The Brewers’ current outfield mix includes Mitchell, Jackson Chourio, Sal Frelick, Luis Lara and Jake Bauers, with Brandon Lockridge expected back shortly before the deadline. Even with Lara signing a long-term extension and getting off to a strong start in his first five big-league games, moving Mitchell in the middle of a postseason chase would be a risky play.
The biggest issue isn’t just the roster. It’s the room.
Milwaukee has already lived through a deadline move that hit the clubhouse hard. In 2022, the Brewers traded Josh Hader while leading the division, and the aftermath helped fuel a second-half slide that ended with the team missing the postseason. Shipping out Mitchell now could create a similar ripple effect at exactly the wrong time.
The safer move would be to keep him in Milwaukee for the playoff push and sort out his future later.
If Mitchell keeps producing and stays healthy, the offseason is the more logical window to revisit a trade. He would be entering his second year of arbitration, Lara’s rise would make the outfield picture even tighter, and the Brewers have shown they’re willing to cash in when a player’s value is high.
They did something similar last winter when they moved Isaac Collins and Caleb Durbin after both had breakout rookie seasons. Mitchell is a different case, though. As a former first-round pick, he still carries a higher ceiling than either of those players.
For now, the best answer for Milwaukee is the simplest one: keep Mitchell through the 2026 campaign. Even with the strikeout issues, his mix of power and speed gives the Brewers something they’ve often lacked in the bottom half of the lineup, and that kind of threat could matter most when the games get biggest.
In Other News...
Pirates Player Calls Out Pat Murphy After Ugly Brewers Sweep
The Brewers final series before the All-Star break left plenty of bad blood behind, and Ryan OHearn was at the center of it. Pittsburgh finished off a three-game sweep in Milwaukee, and OHearn took a pitch to the body in all three games, including both ends of Saturdays doubleheader and again on Sunday, making for a bruising few days against Brewers pitching.
OHearns frustration went beyond the hit-by-pitches themselves. He said he was upset about being plunked repeatedly and took issue with Pat Murphy after one of the incidents, adding another layer to an already ugly series between division rivals who wont have to wait long to see each other again. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Fans Wont Love How One 2022 Deadline Miss Just Aged
The Brewers 2022 deadline haul has already been judged mostly through the lens of what Milwaukee got back for Josh Hader, but the lesser-noticed move involving Tristan Peters has aged in a way that stings a little more now. Peters was one of the pieces sent out as the front office tried to reshape the roster for that stretch run, and while the returns on that deadline were mixed at best, the outfielders path since then has kept moving in the opposite direction.
Now in Chicago after a chain of trades, Peters has turned into a real big-league story, the kind that makes old deadline decisions look sharper in hindsight. He has put together a strong season and earned an All-Star nod in 2026, which is the sort of development Brewers fans cant help but notice when they look back at how that summer unfolded and how little Milwaukee ultimately got from the moves around it. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Prospects Just Made Milwaukees Infield Future Feel Very Real
The 2026 Futures Game offered a tidy reminder of why the Brewers infield future has become such a talking point. Jesus Made and Luis Pea both took part in the showcase, and each left a mark in different ways. Made went 1-for-3 with an RBI, while Pea showed the kind of all-around skill set that has made him one of the most closely watched young players in the organization.
Made also produced the hardest ball of the day at 106.9 mph, a loud swing that fit the buzz around a player already viewed as MLBs top prospect. Pea added a defensive play and three flyouts with strong bat speed, another sign that Milwaukee may have more than one answer waiting on the left side of the infield. With the trade deadline approaching, those performances only made the Brewers long-term picture feel more immediate. [Read more 🡒]