PHILADELPHIA - The Brewers came up short Tuesday night at Citizens Bank Park, but the loss didn’t stop them from locking in a first-round bye and home-field advantage in the NLDS after Atlanta fell to the Reds.
Milwaukee dropped a 6-4 decision to the Phillies, but the bigger picture still broke the Brewers’ way. They moved to 98-59 and secured the playoff positioning they were chasing.
The game itself turned into a tug-of-war between Zack Wheeler’s early dominance and a Brewers offense that kept finding small cracks to work through. Wheeler was on one from the start, striking out Milwaukee’s first seven hitters to match a Phillies franchise record.
He set down the first nine batters before Garrett Mitchell finally broke through with a flare that glanced off Alec Bohm’s glove for a hit. Mitchell later came around on William Contreras’ sacrifice fly, but Wheeler still carried a two-run lead into the sixth with 10 strikeouts.
Milwaukee’s answer in that inning fit the way Pat Murphy likes to describe his club. The Brewers kept chipping, kept pecking, and kept the pressure on.
David Hamilton singled out of the nine spot to start the frame, stole second with one out, and Jackson Chourio drew a walk. Then Hamilton and Chourio executed a double steal while Brice Turang struck out, turning the inning into a live one for the Brewers.
Dustin May’s night, though, never really settled in. He was back on short rest after being knocked out of his previous start in Baltimore on Friday, when he lasted just 2 1/3 innings and allowed six hits and three runs. The Brewers wanted one more outing before the end of the regular season, and Murphy explained the thinking before the game.
“It’s simple,” Murphy said before the game. “We want to give him as many outings as we can.
It probably won’t be an extended outing, but it’s still a chance to go back out there and pitch, and just kind of solidify how he wants to do things. He keeps adjusting to his new environment, and we’ve all got to get on the same page.
And he wants to jump back out there. It works out perfect for us.”
But May ran into trouble quickly. He walked a batter in the first inning, then issued another walk in the second before Brandon Marsh hammered a two-run homer on a 1-2 sinker. May’s response said everything; he tilted his head back and spun around after the blast, and his night was over after just two innings and 36 pitches.
That opened the door for Colton Gordon, who made his Milwaukee debut after arriving with Lance McCullers Jr. in a July trade with the Astros. Gordon gave the Brewers exactly what they needed at first, blanking the Phillies with four hitless innings and giving Milwaukee a real shot to keep climbing back.
His fifth inning, however, came apart in a hurry. Luis Arraez and Bohm singled with two outs, then Bryson Stott punched a hit to center.
Garrett Mitchell came up throwing, and it looked as though Bohm might have been out at third by plenty before the ball hit his foot and skipped away. Bohm scored on the play, and Murphy came out to the field as the Brewers appeared to think Bohm had interfered by turning his head toward the throw.
The umpires gathered, but the call stood, and Philadelphia kept pouring it on. Marsh followed with a double off the left-field wall to bring in Stott, turning the inning into a three-run burst and giving the Phillies the cushion they needed to finish off the win.
In Other News...
Brewers Suddenly Have A Playoff Pitching Decision To Make
Colton Gordons Brewers debut came at a busy moment, with the left-hander giving Milwaukee five innings and allowing two runs against the Phillies while the offense tried to claw back late. The effort wasnt enough to turn the game around, as the Brewers fell 6-4, but the result still landed in a bigger context for a club already looking ahead to October.
Because of a Braves loss elsewhere, Milwaukee also locked up a first-round bye in the playoffs, which changes the conversation around the pitching staff almost immediately. Gordons outing added one more candidate to the mix at a time when the Brewers are suddenly sorting through how they want to line up their arms for the postseason. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Are Already Hinting At A Playoff Lineup Shift
Joey Ortiz sat out the Brewers game against the Phillies because of a minor abdominal strain, but the absence did not sound like a long-term concern. Pat Murphy made it clear the move was more about the immediate moment than any bigger alarm, and he also suggested Ortiz would still be in line for a start if Milwaukee were setting its playoff card. For a player who has taken a clear step forward offensively this season, that matters, because Ortiz has become one of the more important pieces in the Brewers everyday picture.
Murphy also floated a few other October possibilities that hint at how Milwaukee could mix and match once the games start carrying more weight. Sal Frelick is a candidate to be in the lineup, while David Hamilton and Luis Lara could see more chances against right-handed pitching. It is the kind of late-season tinkering that says the Brewers are thinking beyond one regular-season game and starting to map out the shape of their best postseason version, even if the final version is still not fully settled. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Final Stretch Pitching Plan Is Starting To Take Shape
The Brewers kept adjusting their pitching board before facing the Phillies, selecting right-hander Lyon Richardsons contract and sending left-hander Colton Gordon to Double-A. It was another small but meaningful move in a season where Milwaukee has been careful about how it handles its staff, especially with the postseason coming into view.
Richardson is no stranger to changing uniforms this year, having already spent time on both the Reds roster and the Brewers roster. His major league results have been uneven, but he has shown better form in the minors, which is part of why Milwaukee continues to keep him in the conversation as the final stretch approaches and the pitching plan starts to take shape. [Read more 🡒]