On Feb. 9, the Red Sox and Brewers made a six-player swap that barely registered as a headline at the time. It didn’t come with a superstar, didn’t dominate the winter, and didn’t look like the kind of move that would reshape anything.
And yet here we are, with both clubs headed toward October and the deal standing out as one of the most consequential of the offseason. Every player involved has already appeared in the Majors this season, which is rare enough on its own.
Since 2009, there have been only 29 trades involving at least five MLB players. The last two-team deal to include six or more MLB players was the Juan Soto blockbuster that sent him from the Padres to the Yankees in December 2023.
This one is different, though, because it didn’t feature a proven star or even someone close to that level. Still, the impact has been obvious. With fewer than three weeks left in the regular season, both the Brewers and Red Sox are among baseball’s best teams, and the players from this trade have played major roles in that rise.
For Boston, the centerpiece has been Caleb Durbin. The 26-year-old was an NL Rookie of the Year Award finalist with Milwaukee in 2025 and looked like a natural answer at third base after Alex Bregman’s free-agency departure.
Durbin started slowly at the plate, but he has become one of the Red Sox’s most productive hitters over the past three-and-a-half months. Since June 1, he’s hitting .283/.366/.434 with a 125 wRC+, and a trip to a private hitting coach in mid-May helped turn things around.
He’s also in the Gold Glove conversation.
The Red Sox have gotten more than just Durbin, too. David Monasterio and Jack Seigler have provided unexpected energy during Boston’s midseason surge, especially when more established names like Trevor Story, Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Roman Anthony were on the injured list for much of the summer.
Milwaukee’s side of the trade has been just as useful. Quinn Priester spent much of last summer at Triple-A Worcester after the Red Sox acquired him in the Rafael Devers return from the Giants, and before that he had struggled to put everything together, posting a 4.39 ERA in 42 games, 37 of them starts, across his first three MLB seasons.
This year has been a different story. Even with some recent rough patches, he has a 3.66 ERA and 134 strikeouts in 110 2/3 innings.
His fastball has been a key part of the rebound, with Milwaukee encouraging him to lean into the four-seamer after Boston had pushed him more toward a cutter.
Matt Arnold said in February that Nestor Drohan was a “very big part” of the deal, and that has held true. Drohan has given the Brewers 114 1/3 innings with a 4.09 ERA in a flexible swingman and spot-starting role, using a six-pitch mix out of the bullpen.
Then there’s Nick Hamilton, who has been Milwaukee’s most valuable piece from the trade by bWAR. He fits the Brewers mold neatly: speed, edge on the bases, and a stubborn approach at the plate that helps offset his smaller frame.
The bigger story, though, is how much production has come out of this one trade. Entering Tuesday, the six players had combined for 8.4 WAR this season, according to Baseball Reference.
Milwaukee’s trio - Hamilton at 1.7 WAR, Harrison at 1.3 and Drohan at 0.6 - has done its part. Boston’s group has added even more, with Durbin at 3.6 WAR, Monasterio at 0.7 and Seigler at 0.5.
That total puts the trade in unusual company. Since 2009, only five other two-team deals involving at least five MLB players have produced that much WAR in the season immediately after the swap. With three weeks still left in the 2026 season, this deal has a real chance to finish as the third-most valuable on that list.
The standard it’s chasing starts with the December 7, 2023 deal between the Yankees and Padres, which produced 14.6 WAR. New York got Juan Soto and Trent Grisham, while San Diego received Michael King, Kyle Higashioka, Randy Vazquez, Jonny Brito and Drew Thorpe.
Next is the November 23, 2016 trade between the Mariners and Diamondbacks, which generated 11.3 WAR. Seattle landed Jean Segura, Mitch Haniger and Zac Curtis, while Arizona got Taijuan Walker and Ketel Marte.
Another five-player deal came on December 9, 2011, when the Athletics and Diamondbacks combined for 9.3 WAR. Oakland acquired Jarrod Parker, Ryan Cook and Collin Cowgill, while Arizona received Trevor Cahill and Craig Breslow.
The final comparison is the December 17, 2011 Reds-Padres trade, which produced 8.7 WAR. Cincinnati got Mat Latos, and San Diego came away with Yasmani Grandal, Yonder Alonso, Edinson Volquez and Brad Boxberger.
The Red Sox-Brewers swap doesn’t have the star power of the Soto deal, but it has something almost as unusual: six players who have all mattered, all in the same season, for two teams pushing toward the postseason.
In Other News...
Brewers Are Getting National Credit For What They've Built
The Brewers have spent the better part of the last three seasons turning division titles into something closer to a standard than a surprise, and that consistency is now drawing fresh attention beyond Milwaukee. ESPN recently placed the club second among all organizations in baseball for talent, a nod to the way the front office has stocked both the major league roster and the pipeline behind it.
What makes the ranking notable is not just the current group of contributors but the depth of players spread across the organization, from the big league club to the minors. Of course, talent rankings only tell part of the story, and the real test for Milwaukee is whether that collection of players can keep producing at the level that has made the Brewers a fixture in the NL Central race. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Have A Strange New Weakness They Can't Take Into October
The Brewers have spent much of the 2026 season showing a rare unfamiliarity with Major League Baseballs ABS challenge system, and it has become one of the more curious wrinkles in their profile. Milwaukee has challenged pitches less often than any other team, and when it has gone to the system, the results have not been especially kind. Even in a sport built on small margins, this is a phase of the game the Brewers have struggled to turn into an edge.
What makes it more notable is how the problem has shown up across the roster, not just in one spot. Milwaukees catchers have also posted below-average success with the system, which can matter most in the tight late-game moments when a well-timed challenge can change the shape of an inning. For a club with October ambitions, it is a strange weakness to be carrying into the stretch run, especially one that could keep costing them in the very situations where every call feels magnified. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Farmhand Just Delivered A Rare Performance Fans Will Love
Thomas Pannone gave the Brewers system a night it does not get often, and Triple-A Nashville had every reason to savor it. The 32-year-old left-hander was perfect against Durham, retiring all 27 batters in order while needing just 94 pitches to get through the game. He mixed in eight strikeouts and did it with a fastball that topped out at 91 miles per hour, a reminder that command and feel can still carry a pitcher a long way.
For a journeyman who has spent his career moving through multiple major league and minor league stops, it was the sort of performance that stands out even in a long baseball life. Pannone has made only limited appearances in the majors in recent years, which only adds to the appeal of a night like this for Brewers fans tracking the organization from the bottom up. It is the kind of outing that does not just fill a box score, it forces people to notice a name they may not have thought much about lately. [Read more 🡒]