The Brewers have a way of making hitters look a little different.
Milwaukee sits last in baseball in pull rate at 36%, and that’s no accident. Pat Murphy’s club wants hitters to let the ball travel, react to the pitch, and put it in play instead of trying to live on the inside part of the plate and yank everything. Murphy even said he hates the word “pull” before Tuesday night’s series opener against the Seattle Mariners.
That comment came while he was talking about Joey Ortiz, whose recent spike in pull rate has lined up with a strong month and a half at the plate. Murphy’s point was simple: the improved production is coming from Ortiz’s growing confidence and stronger swing decisions, not from some sudden commitment to pulling the ball.
In Milwaukee, the mindset matters. Get too locked into pulling, and you start giving away the outer half, rolling over pitches, and pounding weak grounders to the pull side.
That philosophy has shaped the Brewers’ roster, too. The club tends to lose pull-air hitters rather than collect them, and even players acquired from elsewhere often see those numbers drop once they arrive.
David Hamilton is a clear example. With Boston in 2024 and 2025, he posted pull-air rates of 22.0% and 17.3%.
Since joining Milwaukee this year, that number has fallen to 10.6%. Brice Turang’s back-to-back quantum leaps in 2024 and 2025 also came alongside a lower pull-air rate.
Two of the few true pull-air hitters to come through the organization in recent years were Caleb Durbin and Isaac Collins, and both were traded after their rookie seasons. The message from Milwaukee has been consistent: take what the pitcher gives you.
Now Bo Naylor is getting that same treatment.
The Brewers acquired the catcher from the Cleveland Guardians two days before this year’s trade deadline, and the early signs suggest Milwaukee is already nudging him toward its preferred approach. It’s a small sample, but it’s a notable one.
Before the move, Naylor was with Cleveland’s Triple-A team after a long major league slump that stretched back to the 2025 season. He was running a 51.4% pull rate in Triple-A this year.
Over his four-year MLB career, he has carried a 42.0% pull rate and a 24.0% career pull-air rate.
That’s a pretty strong pull-heavy profile, which makes him an interesting fit for a Brewers organization that generally wants the opposite. But his first few games with the Nashville Sounds point in the direction Milwaukee likely wants.
Since joining the Sounds, Naylor’s pull rate has dropped to 36.7%, the lowest it has been over a full season in his professional career. He has just 40 at-bats in Nashville, so the sample is tiny, but the production has been there: .275/.370/.525 with an .895 OPS. He has already hit three homers in 10 games, and none of them have gone to straight-away right field for the left-handed hitter.
Naylor, 26, is under team control through the 2030 season, which gives Milwaukee plenty of time to see where this goes. If the Brewers keep building the roster the way they have and decide to trade William Contreras this offseason, Naylor could wind up being a major part of the future. And if this early offensive turn keeps holding, the deadline deal with Cleveland could start to look a lot more one-sided.
In Other News...
Red Sox Third Base Answer Just Sparked A Much Bigger Debate
The trade that sent Caleb Durbin and Kyle Harrison through a Boston-Milwaukee swap has quietly become one of those deals both clubs can point to with some satisfaction. What looked at first like a Milwaukee edge has settled into a far more balanced exchange, with Durbin helping the Red Sox in a meaningful way while Harrison and the other pieces have given the Brewers useful production of their own.
For Milwaukee, the broader question now is not whether the deal worked, but how much it changes the way the front office values this kind of multi-player swap going forward. When a transaction starts with one team appearing to land the clearer upgrade and ends with both sides getting real contributions, it complicates the usual instinct to declare a winner, especially for a Brewers club that has built plenty of its success on finding value in the margins. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Best Start Comes With One Cost Fans Cant Ignore
The Brewers have turned baseballs best record into the latest reminder that a cautious approach can still work in an era when so many contenders try to buy certainty. Milwaukee stayed relatively quiet through the offseason and again at the trade deadline, settling for additions like Dustin May and JoJo Romero while passing on the kind of splashy pursuit that had circulated around targets such as Tarik Skubal. Even so, the club has kept itself in the thick of the postseason race, continuing an eight-year run of consistent October appearances that has become the standard around here.
Brandon Woodruffs situation is the part fans cant overlook, though, because the right-handers decision to accept a $22 million qualifying offer was supposed to give the Brewers a proven arm without completely changing the rosters financial shape. Instead, a shoulder injury ended his season and cut into both the on-field payoff and the payroll flexibility the club was counting on. For a team already working with restraint, losing that kind of value in one spot only sharpens the question of how long this model can keep surviving on depth, patience and a little bit of good fortune. [Read more 🡒]