A month ago, Brandon Woodruff’s future felt like it had been reduced to one brutal question: would he ever pitch for the Brewers again?
He had just told reporters at American Family Field that he was set for season-ending surgery on his throwing shoulder, a second major operation on the same part of his body after the one he underwent following the 2023 season. That earlier surgery cost him more than a full season, and the setback had already taken a toll on his velocity. At 33, with another long rehab ahead, it was fair to wonder how much baseball he had left.
Then last weekend, the conversation flipped.
Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported before the Brewers’ game against the Braves that recent scans no longer had Woodruff being recommended for surgery. Instead, he was expected to begin a throwing progression soon. Brewers manager Pat Murphy confirmed the update shortly after.
“I’ve been hearing about this for a couple weeks, and I was like, it could happen, you know,” Murphy said. “But now we also have to think of reality.
Okay, now he has to pick up the ball. Now it’s the progression back….but we’ll do anything we can to have Woody a possibility for any of this season.”
Once the news started flying around social media, the obvious follow-up came fast: could Woodruff actually make it back this year? Murphy didn’t overpromise.
“I think there’s a low possibility, you know. But I think there’s a possibility.”
That’s where things stand now, and the calendar matters. Hogg reported that Woodruff’s throwing buildup is scheduled to run five weeks before the team takes another look. With the progression expected to start on August 26, that puts the reevaluation around September 30.
By then, the postseason will already be underway. The Wild Card round would be two days old, the Division Series would begin three days later, and even that probably doesn’t leave enough runway for a return. If Woodruff is going to pitch again this season, the League Championship Series looks like the earliest realistic target.
Nothing is guaranteed, of course. But the Brewers are trying to get back to the NLCS for the second straight year after facing the Dodgers there last season, and Murphy made it clear how much that would mean.
“With the injuries we’ve had and the youth we have and some of the other things that haven’t bounced our way, like wouldn’t this be nice to have some real positive news?” Murphy asked. “Because everybody would want Woody on the mound.”
And it’s not like Woodruff had faded into irrelevance before the shoulder issue returned. In nine starts this season, he posted a 2.98 ERA, held opponents to a .174 batting average against, and struck out 47 while walking only 10.
If he does get back for October, the likeliest role is in relief. Milwaukee already has a strong starting group with Jacob Misiorowski, Kyle Harrison, and Logan Henderson, and the club added Dustin May at the deadline. That gives the Brewers options, which is why Woodruff could end up as a high-impact bullpen arm rather than a rotation piece.
Even with diminished velocity compared with his peak, he’s shown he can succeed by leaning more on craft. As a reliever, there’s also the possibility of a small velocity bump, the kind starters often find when they work in shorter bursts. That could make him even more dangerous.
And beyond the radar gun, there’s the reaction he’d get from the crowd. If Woodruff were to jog in from the bullpen at home, Brewers fans would erupt. For a player many feared they’d never see in a Milwaukee uniform again, that moment alone would change the atmosphere in the ballpark.
Even if he never throws another pitch this year, his presence around a young staff still matters. A veteran with playoff experience can be a guidepost, and the Brewers have plenty of younger arms who could use that kind of voice around them.
In Other News...
Brewers Fans May Not Like What September Means For Top Prospects
September brings the usual roster squeeze relief, with MLB clubs able to expand from 26 to 28 players for the final month. For Brewers fans, that always sparks the same hope: a chance to see some of the organizations most intriguing young talent in Milwaukee before the season ends. Shortstop Jess Made and corner infielder Andrew Fischer are among the names that get people talking, especially with the Brewers carrying a farm system that has given the front office plenty to think about.
The problem is that a September call-up is not always a true preview of what is coming next. Milwaukee is expected to be cautious with both players, and the more likely path is to keep their development on track rather than push them toward the majors too early. With roster rules also capping teams at 14 pitchers, the Brewers will have some flexibility in how they use the extra spots, but not enough to turn the month into a full-on prospect showcase. [Read more 🡒]
Pat Murphys Toughest Brewers Standard Is Sparking A Fan Debate
Pat Murphy has spent the past two seasons showing that success in Milwaukee is not just about talent, but about earning every inning and every roster spot. The Brewers manager has been praised for guiding a young group to back-to-back Manager of the Year awards, and his way of handling that group has been just as notable as the results. When Murphy has benched or demoted players such as Sal Frelick, Caleb Durbin, and Brandon Sproat, it has been less about punishment than about reinforcing the standards he wants from a team built to play clean, disciplined baseball.
Still, the approach can cut both ways, which is where the fan debate starts to get louder. Murphy has leaned into those tough calls because he believes they sharpen the roster and keep the Brewers competitive, but every move like that also tests how much patience a clubhouse and its supporters have for a manager who is willing to make an example out of even young, promising players. For a team trying to stay sharp over the long haul, the question is whether that edge becomes a strength or a source of friction. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Could Be Pulled Into MLBs Biggest Spending Debate
Milwaukees payroll picture has quietly become part of one of baseballs loudest arguments. At roughly $143.6 million, the Brewers sit below the proposed MLB salary floor of $171.2 million, a number that would matter a whole lot more if owners and players ever turned the current spending debate into an actual cap-and-floor system. For a franchise that has long made a habit of competing without spending like a big-market juggernaut, it is another reminder that its operating model could look very different in a new labor landscape.
The Brewers have built real success around efficiency, not brute-force payroll, and that is exactly why they keep showing up in these conversations. A floor would force Milwaukee to spend more just to stay in compliance, even as the larger fight around salary caps remains far from settled. For now, the club is still playing by the old rules, but the broader debate has a way of putting teams like the Brewers right in the middle of baseballs next big financial test. [Read more 🡒]