Luke Fahey didn’t look ready for the moment against Indiana, but Ohio State still trusts him to handle the offense.
That’s the tension hanging over the Buckeyes’ quarterback picture after Julian Sayin went down and Fahey was thrust into the biggest snaps of his young career. He entered with eight minutes left in Bloomington, came away 0-for-2 passing, took an intentional grounding penalty and scrambled for an 8-yard gain on his first play before Ohio State’s offense stalled out. The Buckeyes didn’t pick up another first down from there, and they escaped with a 19-15 win.
Ryan Day didn’t pretend the freshman was comfortable in that spot. In his first media availability since returning from Indiana, he said Fahey was overwhelmed, but he also pointed to the same quality that has kept him in the conversation all season: the ability to make something happen when the play breaks down.
“Obviously, he was a little overwhelmed and drinking through a fire hose a little bit during that game. It's a tough spot to be in as a true freshman in the fourth quarter like that,” Day said.
“But even just being out there, you can see him escape the pocket and make that play (on the 8-yard scramble). You can see a little bit of that in him.
Now, he's got to find the speed of the game and settle in, which we can help him do.”
Day was more guarded on Tuesday than he had been after the game. Then, he sounded locked in on Fahey as the next man up.
This week, he said Fahey and Tavien St. Clair will “get a lot of reps” during the bye week and that the Buckeyes will “play the guy that gives us the best chance to win.”
That leaves the door open for a quarterback competition as Ohio State sorts through what it saw on film from Indiana and looks ahead to USC.
Still, Fahey’s rough showing doesn’t erase the bigger picture. He won the backup job over St.
Clair earlier this season, and that wasn’t a courtesy decision. Fahey is a freshman and was a three-star recruit.
St. Clair is a sophomore and was a five-star recruit.
Even so, Day said Fahey has stayed ahead of him because of how he’s practiced over the last month.
So this isn’t just about whether Fahey can survive one difficult stretch. It’s about whether he’s ready to start, and Ohio State is asking him to prove that over the next two weeks. At the moment, he remains the likeliest option for the Trojans, even if that final call won’t come until next week.
What has impressed Day is not raw size or recruiting status, but the way Fahey carries himself. Listed at 5-foot-11 and 206 pounds, he doesn’t have the frame of St.
Clair, who is 6-foot-4 and 235 pounds. But Day sees a quarterback whose edge shows up in the building as much as it does on the field.
“He's an extremely hard worker. He puts a lot of hours in.
He's extremely competitive,” Day said. “He has a moxie about him.
He has a competitiveness about him. We're always looking for quarterbacks who are just obsessed with being great, and I think when you get around Luke, you can quickly see how important it is to him.
He puts a lot of work in. You see when he's there in the preseason or in the offseason, he's in here early with the receivers, and just going through the scripts.
And you see him in the meeting rooms, putting in a lot of work, learning the plays. When he steps in the huddle, he's got it.
And the linemen feel that.”
Arthur Smith echoed that view. The Ohio State offensive coordinator, who came to the Buckeyes after serving as an NFL offensive coordinator and head coach, said Fahey already shows a “pro mindset.”
“From the jump, what's been impressive about him, I know he wasn't a highly recruited guy, but he understands how to play the position,” Smith said. “He puts a lot of work into it. I think he operates at a high level.”
Fahey’s only other meaningful action this season came in late-game duty against Ball State, Kent State and Maryland, all in games Ohio State had already put away. Through the season, he has completed nine of 13 passes for 203 yards and two touchdowns with two interceptions.
Whether the Southern California native gets the nod in his home state is still unresolved. But the fact that he was the first quarterback off the bench in Indiana says plenty about how Ohio State views him.
The Buckeyes believe he can lead the offense. Now they want to see if he can do it when the game is really on the line.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Just Got A Tough New Bryce Underwood Reality
Michigans quarterback conversation has taken an interesting turn, and it starts with the kind of outside perspective that tends to get attention when a young talent is in the mix. Urban Meyer said during a conversation with Dan Dakich on Outkick that he believes Tommy Carr will be the starting quarterback over Bryce Underwood, pointing to Carrs performance and the fact that his game fits a similar offensive style.
Underwood, of course, remains a highly regarded and engaged player, and Meyer was careful not to close the book on his future role. Still, the note Michigan fans will take from this is simple: the path to snaps may not be as straightforward as many assumed, especially with Meyer saying he stays in regular contact with Kyle Whittingham while weighing how the room could settle. [Read more 🡒]
Bryce Underwood Just Put Michigans Quarterback Future On Edge
Michigans quarterback picture suddenly feels a lot less settled after Bryce Underwood was moved to the sideline in favor of Tommy Carr for an upcoming game. For a player whose arrival carried so much hype, the decision is a jolt on its own, and it immediately shifts attention from the depth chart to what comes next for a highly touted quarterback whose future in Ann Arbor now feels open to interpretation.
Underwood has not been confirmed to be entering the transfer portal, but the speculation is already easy to understand given the stakes around his situation and the size of his reported NIL package, which exceeds $10 million. If he does decide Michigan is no longer the right fit, schools tied to his recruitment and roster needs could all surface in the conversation, with LSU, Miami, Texas Tech, Georgia and Kentucky among the names to watch. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Offense Just Took A Turn Fans Need To Watch
Michigans offense has a new face at the controls after coaches settled on Tommy Carr as the starting quarterback on Sunday, a decision that was confirmed by sources and noticed by other coaches around the program. It gives the Wolverines a clearer direction at the games most important position, and it comes at a moment when the offense is still taking shape with new pieces arriving around him.
Jeremiah Earby is now officially on the roster after transferring in from Boise State, and he is immediately eligible to play, adding another experienced body to the mix on a defense that can use more depth. On the recruiting front, Michigan also picked up momentum for the future when three-star receiver Yuto Kawamura-Johnson flipped his commitment from Toledo to join the Wolverines 2027 class, a reminder that the program is still stacking talent even as the depth chart continues to evolve. [Read more 🡒]