Michigan kept its quarterback plan under wraps all week, but the first half against Indiana still gave the Wolverines a look at both Tommy Carr and Bryce Underwood.
Carr got the start Saturday after reports during the week pointed to him as the choice following his work in the second half of the previous week’s win over Penn State. He handled most of the snaps early, but Michigan did not stick exclusively with him under center.
Head coach Kyle Whittingham had already downplayed the idea of using both quarterbacks as a true platoon. On Monday, he was asked whether Carr and Underwood could share the job against Indiana, and he made his stance clear.
"It's something that has worked for some people through the years. I've never been big on it," Whittingham said on Monday.
"I don't know if percentage wise, you hear the old adage, 'If you have two quarterbacks, you don't have one.' Everyone's heard that thing.
So, we'll see what happens. But as far as teams I've coached, it's never been a real prevalent thing for us."
Even so, Underwood did get into the game in the second quarter. Michigan put him in at quarterback with Carr split out wide as a pass-eligible receiver, and Jason Beck dialed up a designed run for Underwood that netted minus-1 yard.
"They told us they'd have packages for him," Fox Sports play-by-play commentator Gus Johnson said when Underwood took the field, suggesting the plan had already been mapped out before kickoff.
Carr’s first-half performance did not offer a strong case for keeping the offense entirely in his hands, either. He made several costly errors, including an ill-advised pitch on an option play that led to a Michigan turnover.
By halftime, Carr had gone 9 of 14 for 65 yards with no touchdowns and one interception. He also ran seven times, sacks included, for 15 net yards, and he lost a fumble.
In Other News...
Michigan May Have A Costly Kyle Whittingham Decision Coming
Kyle Whittinghams first year in Ann Arbor has already put Michigan in a familiar modern college-football bind: the bigger the coaching gamble, the bigger the financial consequences if it does not work out. Whittingham was hired on a five-year, $41 million deal, and the buyout language attached to the contract means Michigan would owe 75% of his remaining salary if it moved on without cause, a figure that currently sits at $25.8 million.
The same concern extends to offensive coordinator Jason Beck, whose three-year, $9 million contract carries its own financial protections if the school decides to change direction before the deal runs out. For Michigan, the issue is no longer just whether the staff is delivering on the field, but how much it would cost to reset if the results never catch up to the investment. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Offense Has Made Jason Beck The Real Story
Michigans offense has become the defining issue in a season where the defense has done enough to keep games within reach. In the 13-6 overtime loss to Indiana, the Wolverines had chances in favorable field position, including multiple drives that started deep in Indiana territory, but came away with only three points. The recent stretch has featured too many punts, too many turnovers and too little yardage on possessions that did not begin after defensive takeaways.
Head coach Kyle Whittingham has acknowledged the offense needs to get better, but he has not offered much clarity on how that happens, and the pressure has settled squarely on offensive coordinator Jason Beck. The results have made the play-calling and overall direction of the unit impossible to ignore, especially for a Michigan program that expects far more when its defense is giving it opportunities. [Read more 🡒]
Indiana Escaped Michigan But A Bigger Problem Is Starting To Show
Indianas 13-6 overtime win in Ann Arbor was the kind of road result that will be remembered in Bloomington for decades, not just because it finally broke a drought stretching back to 1967, but because it came in a game defined by offensive frustration on both sides. Michigan never found a rhythm, managing only three yards per play, while Indiana was hardly any cleaner despite leaving with the win.
For Michigan, the larger concern may be what the performance said about the offense itself, especially with freshman quarterback Tommy Carr making his first career start. Carr got off to a shaky beginning and the Wolverines never fully recovered, letting Indiana hang around long enough to create the opening that decided the game. [Read more 🡒]