Michigans Quarterback Choice Says Everything About This Offense Right Now

Michigan puts its faith in Bryce Underwood as the starting quarterback for their crucial match-up against UCLA, signaling a commitment to his potential despite previous setbacks.

Michigan is turning back to Bryce Underwood for Saturday’s home finale against UCLA.

According to Josh Henschke of The Victors Report, the Wolverines have decided to put Underwood back in the starting role.

Underwood has been out of the job since October 17, when he was pulled against Penn State after a rough first half that included two interceptions and no points for Michigan. His season has been uneven since then, and the numbers reflect it: 950 passing yards, five touchdowns and six interceptions.

He also saw action last week against Oregon after Tommy Carr opened the game and guided Michigan to zero points through the first two series. The quarterback usage turned into a split arrangement for much of the afternoon. Underwood came in for Carr and played the rest of the first half, then sat until the game was basically out of reach after halftime.

This week, though, there didn’t seem to be any real sign of another rotation. Kyle Whittingham said last week that both quarterbacks would get a chance to play, but he did not say that this time. Even so, it remains unclear whether Carr will get any snaps.

Carr’s run as the main guy has had its own issues. Michigan’s 21-point second half in the 21-18 win over Penn State made it easy to get carried away with his impact, especially after the offense had looked stuck for the previous six quarters with Underwood at quarterback.

But Carr’s production cooled after that. Outside of a strong outing against Rutgers, Michigan scored just one touchdown in games he started, and that came in garbage time against Michigan State when the result was already decided.

Last week didn’t help his case. With the two quarterbacks sharing the workload, Carr completed only four passes and missed what could have been a touchdown to Andrew Marsh on Michigan’s best drive of the game.

There are also physical questions around Carr. His arm strength still needs to develop as he grows into his body, and that process is ongoing for a true freshman.

Underwood hasn’t exactly seized the job either, but it’s hard to argue Carr is ready to handle high-level football right now. Carr has 686 passing yards, two touchdowns and three interceptions on the season.

At this point, the bigger question for Michigan’s future is probably who the quarterback will be in 2027, and the answer may not be anyone currently on the roster. For now, though, the Wolverines need someone who can give them the best shot to win the rest of the way. That case appears to favor Underwood.

Michigan’s offense is also dealing with a lack of receiving threats without JJ Buchanan, which makes improvisation even more valuable. Underwood has the kind of raw talent that can change a drive on his own. Carr has flashed as a runner too, but he isn’t as physically gifted.

Before last week, Underwood’s 38-yard touchdown run against Oklahoma in a 17-10 win was Michigan’s best run of the season. That kind of burst is part of why the Wolverines are leaning back toward him, even if there are no perfect answers left this year.

In Other News...

Michigans Kyle Whittingham Problem Just Got Bigger Behind The Scenes

Kyle Whittinghams situation at Michigan has only grown more complicated after a run of underwhelming performances, capped by a narrow win against Western Michigan that did little to quiet the noise around the program. The frustration has not been limited to the scoreboard, either. There have been signs of low player morale and unease with the offensive approach, leaving the Wolverines in a spot where every week seems to sharpen the scrutiny instead of easing it.

Now there is a new layer to the discussion with Trev Alberts arriving as the schools new athletic director. His presence gives the program a fresh decision-maker at a moment when Whittinghams future is already being debated, and the question is no longer just about results on the field. Some around the program still hope he gets more time to turn things around, but the behind-the-scenes uncertainty has made the next move feel especially significant. [Read more 🡒]

Michigan Football Could Be Headed For A Much Tougher New Era

Michigans athletic department appears to be on the verge of a significant change, with Trev Alberts reportedly set to take over as athletic director. Alberts brings a notable background to Ann Arbor, including his current role at Texas A&M and prior experience at Nebraska as both a player and an administrator, which gives this move a familiar, big-program feel at a time when the Wolverines are trying to stay steady at the top.

For Michigan football, the hire could carry real weight beyond the administrative shuffle. Any new athletic director brings a fresh set of priorities, and that naturally puts attention on the direction of the program and the people leading it, including coach Kyle Whittingham. The broader question now is how much change Alberts wants to make once he settles in, and how quickly those decisions could ripple through the rest of the athletic department. [Read more 🡒]

Michigan May Finally Be Solving A Frontcourt Problem That Mattered

Michigans frontcourt has been a work in progress early on, and the staff has spent enough time with JP Estrella and Moustapha Thiam to know their original pairing was not giving the group the balance it needed. Head coach Mike Boynton Jr. said the answer so far has been a role tweak, moving Thiam to center and Estrella to power forward, a shift that has helped both ends of the floor look more functional.

The bigger question now is how the rest of the rotation fits around them. Michigan is still sorting through which supporting pieces best complement the two big men in different lineups, and that evaluation matters because the Wolverines need the frontcourt to do more than just survive. If this adjustment holds, it could give the staff a cleaner foundation to build on as the season moves forward. [Read more 🡒]