The Michigan quarterback conversation is going to follow Bryce Underwood right up to kickoff against Penn State, but the bigger question is whether the Wolverines finally put him in a spot to look like himself again.
Underwood was at the center of a rough offensive showing against Minnesota, a game that left Michigan with fewer than 200 yards of total offense and two straight second-half turnovers. By the end of it, the quarterback had turned in what was described as his worst outing, with Minnesota’s pressure clearly getting to him and the Wolverines offering little help in sorting it out.
That performance came after what should have already been a gut-check week following the loss to Iowa. Instead, the offense never found a sense of urgency against Minnesota. The running game vanished, the pressure mounted, and Jason Beck’s play-calling came under fire for looking stuck without answers.
Still, there’s reason to think Michigan is looking at the low point rather than the new normal.
Underwood’s season has already shown how quickly things can swing in either direction. He looked far better in the Iowa game, which was framed as a clear step forward, only to take a hard step back a week later.
Quarterback development, as the reporting notes, does not move in a straight line. The mention of Arch Manning and Dante Moore was used to underline that point, even as the warning remained simple: if Underwood keeps playing like he did against Minnesota, Tommy Carr may have to get a turn.
But the bigger issue is whether Michigan is making life too hard on its starter.
The call here is that the coaching staff needs to get back to a more traditional run game that fits the offensive line, while also using Underwood as part of the ground attack. Last season, Michigan rushed for 210 yards without leaning heavily on Underwood as a runner.
With the quarterback run game added in, the expectation is that the Wolverines should be capable of getting over 200 rushing yards a game. If Beck can’t sort that out over the next six games, the criticism in the source is blunt: he should be gone.
The Rhino package has become a problem because it has not been matched with a clear counter, allowing safeties to attack the run game. And when the offense has fallen apart around Underwood, the staff has not adjusted in a meaningful way. That has to change, according to the reporting.
Even so, the case for a rebound rests on Underwood himself. He has been significantly better at home than on the road.
At home, he completes 63 percent of his passes, averages 8.1 yards per attempt, and has 10 touchdown passes against five interceptions. On the road, those numbers dip to a 55 percent completion rate, 6.9 yards per attempt, and four touchdowns with five interceptions - two of those coming last week.
He is still a young quarterback, both as a sophomore and by age, and he has started 18 games while winning 12. The season has included flashes, with Oklahoma, Iowa, and UTEP all cited as signs of what he can be. There’s also a pattern from last season: after sluggish road games at Nebraska, USC, and Oklahoma, Underwood responded by averaging 245 passing yards over the next three home games.
Penn State may be the right setup for that kind of response. The Nittany Lions have shown vulnerability on defense, giving up more than 300 passing yards to USC and more than 400 rushing yards to Northwestern.
That opens the door for Michigan to let Underwood work both as a passer and a runner, if Beck designs the game plan to do it. The belief in the source is clear: a bounce-back is coming, even if the noise around Tommy Carr isn’t going anywhere yet.
In Other News...
Michigans Utah Transfers Are Giving Fans One Bright Spot
Kyle Whittinghams pipeline from Utah to Michigan has given the Wolverines something to feel good about in a season when so much of the conversation has centered elsewhere. The move brought in cornerback Smith Snowden, wide receiver JJ Buchanan and defensive end John Henry Daley, and all three have settled in quickly, giving Michigan dependable production on both sides of the ball.
Buchanan has emerged as the teams top receiving threat in yards and touchdowns, while Snowden has held up well in the secondary and Daley has become a steady force up front, leading the defensive line in tackles and sacks. For a roster still sorting through its bigger-picture issues, the early returns from the Utah transfers have been one of the clearer bright spots. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans First Title Defense Test Answered One Early Concern
Michigans first tuneup for a title defense gave it the kind of clean, mostly reassuring night that coaches usually hope to see in October. The Wolverines handled Eastern Michigan 87-62 in an exhibition game, with Trey McKenney leading the way with 21 points and freshmen Quinn Costello and Joseph Hartman adding encouraging production of their own. For a roster trying to blend returning talent, incoming freshmen and new pieces, the early signs were steady rather than flashy.
Moustapha Thiam also offered an answer to one of the more obvious questions facing Michigan entering the season. The transfer logged 25 minutes, drew seven free throws and gave the Wolverines the rim protection they wanted to see, helping stabilize the interior on a night when the game was never in doubt. For a team with lofty expectations, the bigger test is still ahead, but this was a useful first look at how some of the pieces may fit. [Read more 🡒]
Iowa's Rebound Just Changed How Michigan Fans See That Loss
Iowas quick bounce-back after its earlier loss is the kind of result that changes the way Michigan has to size up the Big Ten race. What looked like a cleaner read on the Hawkeyes now feels a little different, especially with several league games around them shaking out in ways that could matter later for the Wolverines. Nebraska nearly pulled off an upset of Indiana before fading late, and Oregon had its own issues against UCLA, giving the weekend a messy feel across the conference.
For Michigan, the bigger point is that the schedule keeps getting harder to judge by reputation alone. Iowas response to adversity suggests the Hawkeyes may be better than the version Michigan fans were ready to file away after that earlier loss, while the other results only reinforce how quickly the league can shift from one week to the next. With upcoming matchups still ahead, the Wolverines are left watching these developments closely, because the standings and the scouting report are not always telling the same story. [Read more 🡒]