Michigan’s season has been ugly enough on the field. Now the reporting behind it makes the whole thing look even more fractured.
The clearest takeaway from the first game was that Kyle Whittingham was in over his head as Michigan’s head coach. Western Michigan, a four-touchdown underdog, nearly walked out with the win before the Wolverines escaped on a final-second Hail Mary. Michigan opened the season with a touchdown on its first drive, and that was about as good as it got for the offense.
From there, Jason Beck’s offense never found its footing. The source reporting says Beck leaned too heavily on Rhino, created confusion for his own offensive line, and did little to help either the quarterbacks or the running backs. Whittingham’s response only added to the mess, especially when he later pointed to play calls against Western, Iowa, and Indiana as if he had no control over them.
That backdrop matters even more now that Michigan has moved into a new leadership phase. Two days after the Indiana game, the school announced it would search for a national athletic director, and Trev Alberts was hired this week, according to reports. That has led to speculation that a reset could be coming, though some have floated the idea that Whittingham might get another year.
The reporting doesn’t leave much room for that possibility. A new Athletic piece by Bruce Feldman and Austin Meek paints a bleak picture of the atmosphere around the program, including parents describing players counting down the days until the season ended so they could enter the portal.
“Two Michigan parents described a grim scene before Michigan’s game against Michigan State as players counted down the days until the season ended and they could enter the portal. The next day, Michigan stumbled through a listless loss to a bitter rival that had been winless in the Big Ten under its own first-year coach.”
The Athletic also dug into why the Rhino package was such a poor fit, and why Whittingham’s approval of it became such a problem. Michigan ended up blocking Big Ten edge rushers with a converted defensive tackle or a backup guard instead of the tackles recruited for that role.
The team also had a deep group of versatile tight ends recruited by Harbaugh and Moore, but they were mostly left unused. And if Buchanan and Marsh couldn’t get open, Beck’s offense didn’t have many answers for the quarterbacks.
Not everyone around the league is ready to bury Whittingham, though. One Big Ten coach said he hopes Michigan gives him more time.
“Those guys are underachieving,” said the coach. “I’ve seen those backs running better than they are now.
The O-line has underachieved. I’m hoping they give (Whittingham) another year to make up some ground on them.”
Still, the question hanging over Michigan is simple: can Whittingham save his job?
Saturday’s game should say plenty. Michigan is a 3.5-point underdog against the fourth-ranked Bruins, and Bob Chesney - the UCLA head coach and, as the source notes, maybe the closest thing to Curt Cignetti - will be on the sideline. Chesney has also been mentioned as a top candidate for Michigan.
If Michigan wins Saturday and then beats Ohio State, would that be enough to buy Whittingham another season? Or is this already a one-and-done situation no matter what happens?
If it is, the odd part is that he still hasn’t been shown the door already, though Michigan didn’t have an athletic director, even in waiting, until earlier this week. Alberts can evaluate the situation, but it’s not clear how quickly he can act if he decides a change is needed.
However it plays out, the seniors are the ones who should matter most in the final stretch. They deserved better than this season, and Michigan has to make sure it doesn’t lose sight of the bigger picture while the future of the program gets sorted out.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Already Know Trev Alberts Faces One Brutal Football Decision
Trev Alberts is arriving at Michigan with the kind of immediate pressure that comes with running a blueblood program, and football will be the first thing on his desk. The new athletic director is expected to start evaluating the Wolverines soon, and the timing matters because the program is already under a microscope after a stretch that has left fans and decision-makers looking for answers. Alberts has been through high-stakes football calls before at Nebraska, so this is hardly unfamiliar territory.
Kyle Whittinghams status only sharpens the spotlight around the job. If Michigans performance does not improve, the speculation around a coaching change will only grow louder, leaving Alberts to weigh patience against the demands of a fan base that expects the program to contend. For a new AD, there may be no softer landing here, just a difficult football decision waiting the moment he settles in. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fans Just Got A Telling Joe Update Before Villanova
Joes return to practice after about five weeks away gave Michigan fans a useful checkpoint heading into the Villanova game, and Mike Boynton Jr. offered a fresh look at where things stand. Boynton said the player has been back on the floor, which at least opens the door to a possible role after the layoff, even if the team is still managing the next steps carefully.
Boynton also touched on Lucai Anderson and why he fits the program, pointing to the way he plays and how that meshes with the roster. Beyond the individual names, he laid out the broader reality of college basketball right now, where high school recruiting is harder to project and roster turnover can change plans quickly. Eligibility rules only add another layer, making every update feel a little more important than it might have in the past. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan May Be Without Andrew Marsh At The Worst Possible Time
Michigans receiving room may be dealing with an off-field issue at a particularly awkward moment, with Andrew Marsh now facing a misdemeanor indecent exposure charge tied to an off-campus incident in February. The freshman wideout is scheduled for arraignment on Dec. 2, and the case carries possible penalties that include jail time or fines, adding another layer of uncertainty around a player the Wolverines had hoped to keep available.
For a team trying to navigate the stretch run, the timing is the real concern. It is still unclear whether Marsh will be available for Michigans upcoming game against UCLA, leaving the Wolverines to wait on both the legal process and the roster implications before they know how much they can count on him. [Read more 🡒]
