PFF grades are never the whole story, but they do give you a pretty clear picture of who showed up week after week and who Michigan can count on heading into 2026. When you sort through the Wolverines’ returning talent, a few names jump out fast - and the top of the list is loaded with players who could shape both lines of scrimmage and the back end of the defense.
At No. 1, John Henry Daley sits alone with a 92.0 overall grade after an elite season at Utah.
His 93.4 pass-rushing grade was outrageous, and the biggest question around him has been his recovery from an Achilles injury. Even so, the reporting around him points to steady progress.
Michigan does not need him to repeat 11.5 sacks to make a difference; if he’s close to the same player, the Wolverines may have swapped one All-Big Ten edge rusher for another.
Jordan Marshall checks in next, and his 87.8 grade tells the story of a back who did a lot with limited volume. He handled just 38.2 percent of Michigan’s running back carries, yet still piled up 932 rushing yards, forced 33 missed tackles and averaged 6.2 yards per carry.
In a four-game run in the middle of the season, he topped 100 rushing yards every week and scored seven times. A late-season injury cut his year short, but the expectation now is that he becomes the centerpiece of the offense.
Nathaniel Staehling lands at No. 3 with a 79.0 grade, though his case comes with a clear caveat. The North Dakota State transfer was excellent against the run and as a tackler while playing more than 650 snaps, but much of that work came against FCS competition. Still, he brings more than 800 career defensive snaps with him to Ann Arbor, and even with Troy Bowles, Chase Taylor and Nathaniel Owusu-Boateng seemingly ahead entering fall camp, it’s hard to see a veteran like Staehling not finding a role.
Jyaire Hill follows at No. 4 with a 77.6 grade, and he might be the most intriguing player on this list. The production was there: strong marks in run defense, coverage and as a blitzer, plus just 230 receiving yards allowed all season.
But the rough edges showed against Texas, Maryland and USC, especially in tackling, where his season-long grade settled at 45.2. The upside is obvious, though.
Talent has never been the issue, and if Hill tightens things up in the biggest games, he has the tools to become one of the Big Ten’s top cornerbacks.
Mason Curtis comes in at No. 5 with a 76.4 grade, and his numbers were steady across the board. He finished above 74 in tackling, coverage and run defense, and he even posted the highest defensive grade of any safety in Week 10 last season. With Michigan still sorting out the safety spot heading into fall camp, Curtis has a real chance to grab hold of that opening.
Andrew Marsh is next at No. 6 with a 75.8 grade, and his freshman season was eye-opening. Once his role grew around the middle of the year, he became one of the conference’s most productive receivers.
From Week 6 on, only Rutgers’ KJ Duff had more receiving yards among Big Ten receivers. He also finished the season without a drop on 60 targets, which is as clean as it gets for a true freshman.
Trey Pierce sits at No. 7 with a 72.9 grade and was Michigan’s best returning run defender. His 80.5 run-defense grade explains why the Wolverines still feel good about the interior defensive line even after losing Rayshaun Benny, Damon Payne Jr. and Tre Williams. The pass rush is the obvious area to sharpen, but if Pierce becomes more disruptive in the pocket, he could put together the best season of his career.
Andrew Sprague comes in at No. 8 with a 72.6 grade, and Michigan has been high on him for a while. PFF also likes what it sees, recently placing him among the nation’s top returning offensive tackles after he allowed just one sack across 383 pass-blocking snaps in his career.
He also graded above 70 as both a run blocker and pass blocker, something only a few Big Ten tackles managed. As the Wolverines keep searching for the right mix up front, Sprague looks like a real building block.
Dominic Nichols is No. 9 at 72.2, and he remains one of the more under-the-radar defenders on the roster. Even with fewer than 200 defensive snaps in 2025, he still finished among Michigan’s highest-graded defenders.
His 85.2 tackling grade was one of the team’s best, and coaches praised his consistency throughout spring practice. With Derrick Moore and T.J.
Guy gone, Nichols should finally see the bigger workload that has been building toward him.
Jake Guarnera rounds out the top 10 with a 71.3 grade, and he gives Michigan at least one clear answer on an offensive line that still has plenty to sort out. After taking over as the starting right guard last season, he quickly became one of the better interior linemen in the Big Ten.
PFF recently named him the No. 7 returning guard in college football, pointing to his run blocking and overall value metrics. Pass protection still has room to grow, but he looks like one of the safest pieces on the Wolverines’ front.
In Other News...
Michigan Finally Made Its Big Basketball Decision Amid Mounting Pressure
Michigans basketball program has finally settled its biggest offseason question, and the timing matters. Mike Boynton Jr. is now in place on a two-year deal, giving the Wolverines a clear leader after a stretch of uncertainty and pressure around the job. He has already done important work on the roster side by keeping current commitments intact, which helps stabilize a program that could not afford much more drift.
The harder part now is building the bench around him. Michigan still has three coaching staff openings to sort through after departures connected to the Dallas Mavericks and other moves, leaving Boynton with a quick turnaround as he tries to assemble a workable group. Akeem Miskdeen, Kyle Church, KT Harrell and strength coach Matt Aldred remain in the building, but the staff picture is still taking shape as the Wolverines move into the next phase of the transition. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fans Are Bracing For A Massive Recruiting Decision
Michigans next few recruiting cycles are starting to take shape in a way that should matter to fans who like seeing both familiar names and blue-chip talent on the board. Safety Marquis Ray, the son of former Wolverine Marcus Ray, already has a Michigan offer, and there is at least some outside belief that the program will eventually land him. Add in four-star safety LaMarcus Army setting up a game day visit for the 2026 season, and the staff is clearly keeping a wide net out in the secondary.
The bigger immediate swing could come on the defensive front, where Michigan is in the mix for four-star lineman Seth Tillman as his decision approaches. His recruitment has moved quickly enough that the Wolverines have stayed firmly in the conversation, which is exactly the kind of late-stage push that can reshape how a class looks on paper. For a program trying to stack future depth with players who fit its identity, the next few days and weeks could tell a lot about how strong this run on the trail really is. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Just Got The Clarity Fans Were Desperate For
Michigans offseason finally has some direction after a stretch of uncertainty that followed Dusty Mays departure for the Dallas Mavericks. Mike Boynton, who stepped in to steady the program, has now been officially elevated to the head job on a two-year contract, giving the Wolverines a clearer picture of who will be steering the roster into next season.
The timing matters because the group around him is starting to take shape, too, with nearly all of the players from last season expected back. That kind of continuity gives Boynton a real base to work with as he settles into the role, and it also raises the stakes for what Michigan can do with a roster that already looks far more intact than many expected when the coaching change first hit. [Read more 🡒]