Michigan’s latest offensive reset didn’t produce a fix. It produced more proof that the Wolverines are still searching for answers, and that the quarterback situation is no cleaner after the firing of offensive coordinator Jason Beck.
Beck was the first major move in what now looks like a long list of changes coming to the offense over the next couple of months. It was also the last obvious lever Kyle Whittingham had left to pull.
The quarterback room has already been shuffled. The coaching staff has already been altered.
None of it has changed the fact that Michigan’s offense is “utterly terrible and everyone around the country knows it.”
That reality was on display in the Wolverines’ 31-7 loss on Saturday afternoon in Eugene, a score that doesn’t fully capture how one-sided the game felt. Oregon had chances to make it uglier earlier, including a failed fourth-down try deep in the red zone that kept the halftime margin from ballooning to 28-7 if you include the coverage bust. The Ducks moved the ball with ease against a Michigan defense that has carried the team all season.
When Michigan had the ball, though, everything fell apart.
The quarterback plan was supposed to help. Instead, it became part of the problem.
The old line says if you have two quarterbacks, you have none. There are exceptions - Tim Tebow and Chris Leak at Florida, or Cade McNamera and JJ McCarthy during Michigan’s 2021 run - but Saturday was not one of them.
Tommy Carr opened the game and got the first two series, both of which ended in punts. Michigan then turned back to Bryce Underwood, who was seeing his first extended action since being benched at halftime of the Penn State game on October 17.
Underwood did have one positive moment in the first half: he was on the field for Savion Hiter’s 70-yard touchdown run, and his running threat helped shape the play. That was about as good as it got for the offense.
Oregon had already struck quickly, taking a 7-0 lead after the fourth play of the game when Jyaire Hill was beaten on a 60-yard touchdown. Michigan trailed by two scores at two different points, and somehow finished with just six completions in a game that was supposed to lean on the passing attack.
Carr finished 4-for-12 for 45 yards. Underwood went 2-for-8 for 26 yards and was fortunate not to throw two interceptions. His final pass was a desperation fourth-down throw that should have been lofted toward one of his receivers, but instead sailed out of bounds - the same mistake he made against Minnesota that helped lead to his benching.
Underwood’s benching was supposed to spark the offense. Carr was the popular backup, the guy everyone wanted to believe in.
That’s how backup quarterbacks work: they’re undefeated until they actually get on the field. Carr has shown flashes, including some ability to create outside the structure of the offense, but there still aren’t enough plays being made within it.
His arm strength is part of the issue.
Outside of a game against Rutgers, Carr has led only one touchdown drive as Michigan’s starter, and that came in garbage time against Michigan State after the result was already settled.
The bigger issue is that neither quarterback has looked like the answer. Carr is a true freshman with physical limitations that likely cap his ceiling.
Underwood, meanwhile, has not really progressed since arriving at Michigan, and that trend continued Saturday. The next two weeks feel like the final two for his partnership with the university, and that may be best for both sides.
The usage of both quarterbacks raised questions, too. Carr started, then was basically shelved after two series in the first half.
Why bring him back to open the second half? Why turn back to Underwood only once the game had already slipped away?
There didn’t seem to be much logic behind any of it.
That has been a theme all season. The coaching staff has looked overwhelmed, and Saturday was just another example of a group without a clear plan for what it wants to accomplish.
The offense was bad. The coaching was bad. Everything was bad.
And if the future is going to look different, it won’t include Kyle Whittingham at head coach. It also won’t include either quarterback who played Saturday.
Michigan has two quarterbacks left for the rest of the season. That only confirms the obvious: they don’t have one.
In Other News...
Michigan's Slump Just Turned Into A Bigger Kyle Whittingham Problem
Michigans recent rough stretch has done more than raise questions about the on-field product. It has also opened the door to louder criticism from people who know the program well, with former Wolverines Taylor Lewan, Jake Butt and Devin Gardner all publicly taking aim at head coach Kyle Whittinghams leadership after the latest poor performances. When former players start speaking that bluntly, it usually means the frustration around a program has moved well beyond a bad week or two.
The outside noise has only added to the unease. Analyst Joel Klatt has said he is unsure what the future holds for Whittingham at Michigan, and Josh Pate has painted a bleak picture of where the program could be headed under him. For a fan base that already wants answers, the bigger issue now is not just the slump itself but whether the current direction can hold up under this much scrutiny. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fans Suddenly Have A Very Real Kyle Whittingham Question
A rough season has put Kyle Whittingham in an uncomfortable spotlight, and Michigan fans are suddenly having to think through a question that felt far-fetched not long ago. After a recent loss and the firing of offensive coordinator Jason Beck, the pressure around the program has only grown, especially with a five-year contract and a buyout clause that would make any change a major decision for the school.
Whittinghams future now feels tied to how the rest of the season unfolds, with a losing finish opening the door to a coaching move that would have seemed unlikely before this stretch. If Michigan does decide to go in a different direction, the search would not be short on possibilities, and the list of potential replacements is already part of the conversation around a program trying to steady itself. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Still Has One Unsettling Question After Oregon Loss
Tommy Carr got the first crack at quarterback for Michigan, but the start against Oregon quickly turned into a search for answers. Carr struggled early enough to open the door for Bryce Underwood, yet the change did not solve much, as both passers had a rough afternoon through the air and the offense never found a steady rhythm.
Carr finished 4 of 12 for 45 yards, while Underwood went 2 of 8 for 26 yards, leaving the Wolverines with a lingering question at the most important position on the field. Coach Kyle Whittingham said Underwood got another opportunity because of the same turnover issues Carr was dealing with, and Michigan will now go back to the film room before deciding how to handle the quarterback spot moving forward. [Read more 🡒]
