Michigan Still Has One Unsettling Question After Oregon Loss

In a game marred by quarterback struggles, Michigan's head coach Kyle Whittingham sheds light on the decision-making behind playing both Tommy Carr and Bryce Underwood against Oregon.

Michigan’s quarterback plan against Oregon didn’t last long, and the reason for the switch was pretty straightforward: Kyle Whittingham said Bryce Underwood got another shot because he had earned one, while Tommy Carr was running into the same problems that had gotten Underwood benched in the first place.

Carr opened the game after taking over the starting job from Underwood, but the Wolverines quickly went back to the freshman. After Carr started 1-for-5, Michigan turned to Underwood, and neither quarterback found much success in the loss to Oregon.

Whittingham laid out the thinking after the game.

"Well, you saw Tommy's play last week," Whittingham said after the game. "It was really very similar to what Bryce's was when we pulled Bryce several weeks ago.

But Bryce deserved another opportunity. And so that was the sole reason.

It was giving Bryce another opportunity, with Tommy's game - kinda went south on him the previous week."

The numbers told the story. Carr finished 4-for-12 for 45 yards, while Underwood went 2-for-8 for 26 yards.

Carr also added 43 rushing yards, but the passing game never got on track. Michigan finished with just 71 passing yards on 6-for-20 throwing, and Underwood was charged with around five turnover-worthy throws.

The Wolverines did run the ball well enough to post a season-high 215 rushing yards, but that ground production couldn’t cover for the issues through the air.

Whittingham said Michigan had a specific plan for when Underwood would enter, unless Carr came out and immediately took control.

"We had planned for the third series unless - you have a tentative plan - that we would have two fabulous 80-yard drives, we wouldn't have made the switch," said Whittingham. "But the plan was that, you know, barring something that was out of the ordinary, we would play Bryce in that third series. And then decide that from that point forward, just to focus the best chance that we could."

What happens next is still unclear. Whittingham said the Wolverines will go back to the film and sort out where things stand with two games left, both ranked matchups against UCLA and Ohio State.

In Other News...

Michigan's Slump Just Turned Into A Bigger Kyle Whittingham Problem

Michigans recent rough stretch has done more than raise questions about the on-field product. It has also opened the door to louder criticism from people who know the program well, with former Wolverines Taylor Lewan, Jake Butt and Devin Gardner all publicly taking aim at head coach Kyle Whittinghams leadership after the latest poor performances. When former players start speaking that bluntly, it usually means the frustration around a program has moved well beyond a bad week or two.

The outside noise has only added to the unease. Analyst Joel Klatt has said he is unsure what the future holds for Whittingham at Michigan, and Josh Pate has painted a bleak picture of where the program could be headed under him. For a fan base that already wants answers, the bigger issue now is not just the slump itself but whether the current direction can hold up under this much scrutiny. [Read more 🡒]

Michigan Fans Suddenly Have A Very Real Kyle Whittingham Question

A rough season has put Kyle Whittingham in an uncomfortable spotlight, and Michigan fans are suddenly having to think through a question that felt far-fetched not long ago. After a recent loss and the firing of offensive coordinator Jason Beck, the pressure around the program has only grown, especially with a five-year contract and a buyout clause that would make any change a major decision for the school.

Whittinghams future now feels tied to how the rest of the season unfolds, with a losing finish opening the door to a coaching move that would have seemed unlikely before this stretch. If Michigan does decide to go in a different direction, the search would not be short on possibilities, and the list of potential replacements is already part of the conversation around a program trying to steady itself. [Read more 🡒]

Desmond Howard Just Sparked Another Michigan-Ohio State Flashpoint

Desmond Howard has never been shy about the Michigan-Ohio State rivalry, but his latest comments on Jeremiah Smith pushed the conversation well beyond the usual pregame needle. Howard questioned whether Smith had done enough in the biggest moments over the past two seasons to justify Heisman Trophy talk, a critique that immediately drew attention because of both the player involved and the voice delivering it.

Robert Griffin III quickly jumped in during a broadcast and suggested Howards Michigan ties were shaping the take, turning a Heisman debate into another familiar flashpoint between the rivals. Smith, meanwhile, has kept producing despite quarterback issues around him and still sits among the favorites for the award, which only makes the scrutiny around him feel more pointed as the season moves on. [Read more 🡒]