Michigan’s quarterback battle has come down to a simple test this week: who can keep the ball safe?
With sophomore Bryce Underwood and freshman Tommy Carr trading the job all season, Michigan is once again using the week to sort out the position for its second-to-last game of the year. The Wolverines haven’t found a quarterback who has done enough to lock down the role, so the evaluation is still open.
Interim offensive coordinator Jim Harding made clear Wednesday that the deciding factor is not about flash. It’s not about who can throw the ball farther or who can create more with his legs. It starts with ball security.
“In this open evaluation, it’s all about who, going back to objective number one, can protect the football,” Wolverines interim offensive coordinator Jim Harding said Wednesday. “Who’s not going to put it in harm’s way in the throw game?
Who’s going to carry it the right way when they’re carrying the football? Are you going to necessarily have an epiphany that in Week 11 the kid can do this particular thing?
I would not say that that’s the case.”
That standard has been a major issue for Michigan all season. The Wolverines have turned it over 19 times, which puts them last in the Big Ten. Those mistakes haven’t just killed drives - they’ve also handed opponents short fields and put Michigan’s defense in tough spots.
Carr got the start against Oregon and made it four straight games in the lineup after entering at halftime against Penn State. Underwood checked in for the third series, and the two quarterbacks split the rest of the game.
“We play the guy (at quarterback) that has the best chance to win,” Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham said after his team’s loss to the Ducks.
Against Oregon, neither quarterback threw an interception, which only happened for the third time this season against a Power 4 opponent. Even then, Michigan flirted with disaster. Late in the second quarter, three of Underwood’s throws were tipped by defenders and nearly picked off.
The turnover that finally arrived came late in the fourth quarter, when Carr had the ball knocked loose on a quarterback keeper. Oregon recovered at Michigan’s 40-yard line and turned that short field into a touchdown in just three plays. By then the game was already decided, but the sequence fit the pattern that has haunted the Wolverines all year.
“We cannot put our defense in position where they’re on short fields, and so who’s going to put us in a position to not?” Harding said.
“And I don’t want to say you don’t want to make plays. I don’t want to come off ultraconservative.
But who’s not going to make an enormous mistake that’s going to swing the game in one play?”
Michigan isn’t demanding perfection from its quarterbacks. But the Wolverines have repeatedly fallen short of even that basic standard, and that’s what this week’s competition is really about.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Already Know Trev Alberts Faces One Brutal Football Decision
Trev Alberts is arriving at Michigan with the kind of immediate pressure that comes with running a blueblood program, and football will be the first thing on his desk. The new athletic director is expected to start evaluating the Wolverines soon, and the timing matters because the program is already under a microscope after a stretch that has left fans and decision-makers looking for answers. Alberts has been through high-stakes football calls before at Nebraska, so this is hardly unfamiliar territory.
Kyle Whittinghams status only sharpens the spotlight around the job. If Michigans performance does not improve, the speculation around a coaching change will only grow louder, leaving Alberts to weigh patience against the demands of a fan base that expects the program to contend. For a new AD, there may be no softer landing here, just a difficult football decision waiting the moment he settles in. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fans Just Got A Telling Joe Update Before Villanova
Joes return to practice after about five weeks away gave Michigan fans a useful checkpoint heading into the Villanova game, and Mike Boynton Jr. offered a fresh look at where things stand. Boynton said the player has been back on the floor, which at least opens the door to a possible role after the layoff, even if the team is still managing the next steps carefully.
Boynton also touched on Lucai Anderson and why he fits the program, pointing to the way he plays and how that meshes with the roster. Beyond the individual names, he laid out the broader reality of college basketball right now, where high school recruiting is harder to project and roster turnover can change plans quickly. Eligibility rules only add another layer, making every update feel a little more important than it might have in the past. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan May Be Without Andrew Marsh At The Worst Possible Time
Michigans receiving room may be dealing with an off-field issue at a particularly awkward moment, with Andrew Marsh now facing a misdemeanor indecent exposure charge tied to an off-campus incident in February. The freshman wideout is scheduled for arraignment on Dec. 2, and the case carries possible penalties that include jail time or fines, adding another layer of uncertainty around a player the Wolverines had hoped to keep available.
For a team trying to navigate the stretch run, the timing is the real concern. It is still unclear whether Marsh will be available for Michigans upcoming game against UCLA, leaving the Wolverines to wait on both the legal process and the roster implications before they know how much they can count on him. [Read more 🡒]
