Michigan didn’t just answer Rutgers on Saturday. Tommy Carr took the game over when it was hanging in the balance.
The Wolverines snapped back into the win column with a 28-21 victory, moving to 5-3 overall and 2-3 in Big Ten play. Carr was the engine all afternoon, piling up a career-high 320 total yards and finishing the job with the go-ahead touchdown in the final minutes.
Michigan set the tone immediately with a 10-play, 92-yard opening march. Carr hit Salesi Moa for a 44-yard gain, then found JJ Buchanan from six yards out to put the Wolverines ahead 7-0. It was Michigan’s second opening-drive touchdown of the season, and Carr was sharp right away, completing 4 of 5 passes on the series while also connecting with Andrew Marsh on back-to-back first downs.
Rutgers answered with a drive of its own, but Michigan’s defense tightened at the right moment. Smith Snowden came up with a clutch tackle to help force a field goal, and the Scarlet Knights settled for three to make it 7-3.
Michigan kept pressing in the second quarter. Carr went back to Buchanan for 30 yards to get the offense into scoring range, and Jordan Marshall finished the drive with a two-yard touchdown run for a 14-3 lead. Rutgers briefly looked stuck again after Benny Patterson III delivered a sack and tackle for loss, but Snowden fell down and the Scarlet Knights cashed in on an 80-yard touchdown pass to cut the margin to 14-10.
The Wolverines had a chance to stretch it back out, but Trey Butkowski missed a 48-yard field goal for the second straight week. Rutgers added a field goal of its own, and Michigan went to halftime up just 14-13.
Michigan opened the third quarter with another long, methodical drive, this one covering 75 yards in 11 plays. Buchanan and Marsh both chipped in with first-down catches, and Carr capped it himself with a 15-yard touchdown run to push the lead to 21-13.
The defense backed that up by keeping Rutgers from building momentum. Enow Etta knocked down a first-down throw, and Troy Bowles made tackles on consecutive snaps to help force a punt. Michigan looked ready to add more after runs by Savion Hiter and Bryson Kuzdzal moved the chains, but Butkowski missed again and the lead stayed at eight.
Then came the fourth-quarter swing. Michigan appeared to recover a muffed punt, but a controversial kick-catch interference call wiped it away and gave Rutgers the ball back. The Scarlet Knights made the most of the break, with Antwan Raymond ripping off a 54-yard run to get into the red zone before Rutgers scored a touchdown and added the two-point conversion to tie it at 21-21 with 11:43 left.
That’s when Carr delivered his best drive of the day.
Michigan answered with an 11-play, 75-yard march. Carr converted third downs by finding Hogan Hansen and Buchanan, Hiter picked up another first down on the ground, and then Carr escaped the pocket and sliced into the end zone from nine yards out. With 4:24 left, Michigan was back in front 28-21.
From there, the defense finished the job. Mason Curtis broke up a pass and added a tackle to help force a punt, and Carr sealed it by pushing the pile for a first down to run out the clock.
Michigan now turns to Michigan State next Saturday, Nov. 7, with a chance to secure a fifth straight win in the rivalry.
In Other News...
Michigan Defense Had One Problem Rutgers Kept Exploiting
Rutgers found a clear opening against Michigans defense, and AJ Surace kept taking what was there. The quarterback completed only three passes, but each one went for more than 10 yards and helped keep scoring drives alive. Jourdin Houstons 80-yard touchdown catch stood out as the kind of explosive play that can flip field position in an instant, and it also became Rutgers longest reception of the season.
For Michigan, the bigger concern was how often the defense helped Rutgers extend possessions with penalties. Those flags gave the Scarlet Knights extra chances to stay on the field and turn modest gains into points. It was the sort of self-inflicted problem that can make an otherwise solid defensive day feel a lot less secure, and it left Michigan with a clear issue to clean up moving forward. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Got Dragged Into Another Brutal Sign Stealing Backlash
The sign-stealing scandal that still shadows Michigan football popped back into the conversation this week, this time through a Halloween costume that turned into its own online pile-on. Annie Agar, the NFL and college football influencer, drew backlash for a 2026 look that mashed together a Bryce Underwood jersey and a Carrie Underwood theme, a pun that some fans said missed the mark and others simply found confusing.
For Michigan, it was another reminder that the programs most painful recent chapter remains easy for outsiders to weaponize and hard for the fan base to shrug off. The school has already absorbed major NCAA punishment tied to the scandal, including fines, probation and show-cause orders for former coaches and a player, and even a costume joke was enough to reopen the wound on social media. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Jason Beck Debate Just Got Much Harder To Ignore
Michigans offense has spent nine weeks under a harsh spotlight, and the scrutiny on offensive coordinator Jason Beck is only getting louder. The numbers have been ugly enough to fuel the frustration, especially with Beck carrying the distinction of being the highest-paid offensive coordinator in college football, which naturally raises expectations for what the unit should look like by now.
The bigger complication is financial, because moving on from Beck would not be simple or cheap. His contract carries a buyout that could reach $9 million if Michigan fires him without cause, and the presence of quarterback Bryce Underwoods substantial NIL deal only adds another layer to any future decision-making. With coaches and donors reportedly reluctant to absorb that kind of cost, the next few games may go a long way toward determining whether the Wolverines keep riding with Beck or are forced into a much tougher conversation. [Read more 🡒]