Michigan walked into Saturday night as a two-touchdown favorite and walked out with one of its ugliest losses in years.
Michigan State, a two-win team entering the game, came into Ann Arbor and beat the Wolverines 15-6, handing Michigan a humbling defeat that ranks among its worst since the 2020 loss to the Spartans. The result fit the kind of game this rivalry can produce, but it also exposed just how far Michigan has fallen.
The simplest way to say it: this can’t happen. Michigan is three years removed from a national title, yet it lost to a Michigan State team that had only two wins coming in and now has three. The Wolverines are surviving almost entirely on defense, because the offense has become one of the weakest units among Four Power teams.
That side of the ball looked broken again on Saturday. Michigan managed only 192 total yards and was beaten badly on the ground, with Michigan State controlling the rushing battle 110-54. The Wolverines also turned it over four times, which made an already bad offensive night even harder to survive.
The first half was especially bleak. Michigan was shut out before halftime for the third straight home game, something Steve Clarke noted had not happened since 1934. The Wolverines produced just 78 yards in the opening half and never found a rhythm.
The quarterback situation didn’t provide a lift either. Tommy Carr had shown signs of life in last week’s 28-21 win over Rutgers, when he threw for 266 yards and ran for 54.
Back in Ann Arbor, though, he looked overwhelmed. He threw an interception on his second pass attempt, had several throws sail high, and nearly got picked off late in the second quarter after Michigan State had gone ahead 3-0 on a field goal.
The Spartans also did a good job of spying him, which kept him from using his legs the way he had in the previous two games.
The bigger issue is that the offense has not changed much at all through nine games. It doesn’t scare defenses, and it made Michigan State look far better than a two-win team should.
The Wolverines’ struggles have now reached the point where the offense is drawing comparisons to Michigan’s 2008 unit under Rich Rodriguez, a three-win team. The difference this time is that the 2026 defense has bailed Michigan out in most of its victories.
Special teams added another layer to the mess. After transfer Trey Butkowski had missed four of his last six kicks, Michigan made a change and turned to freshman Jacob Baggett.
His first try, a 26-yarder, hit the left upright and bounced away. Punter Cameron Brown is still struggling as well, and the unit remains a problem after coming into the season with expectations that Kerry Coombs would make a major impact.
There was some improvement in the bowl game against Texas, but 2026 has been a disappointment across the board.
And then there’s the coaching situation. Kyle Whittingham is likely on the brink of being one-and-done at Michigan, and Saturday’s result won’t help his case.
If he is going to get more time, he’ll need to make the “difficult decisions” he has talked about before. Jason Beck’s offensive game plan is also under fire, and the 28 points against Rutgers now looks like an outlier rather than a turning point.
With Oregon, UCLA and Ohio State still ahead, the schedule isn’t offering much relief.
For Michigan, the loss wasn’t just bad. It was revealing.
In Other News...
Michigan Just Got A Needed Recruiting Win At The Right Time
Michigan picked up a timely boost on the recruiting trail when Xavier Muhammad, one of the more highly regarded defensive line prospects in the 2027 cycle, reaffirmed his commitment to the Wolverines and shut down plans to take official visits elsewhere, including to Texas. For a program that always has to protect its future pipeline, keeping a player of Muhammads caliber in the fold matters, especially as the season winds down and recruiting attention starts to sharpen.
Muhammad is still expected in Ann Arbor for Michigans final home game, giving the staff another chance to reinforce the relationship in person. His continued pledge also helps the Wolverines 2027 class standing, which is exactly the kind of early momentum programs want when the calendar turns and the recruiting race starts to harden. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan May Be Turning To A Freshman In A Huge QB Shift
Tommy Carr has already gone from intriguing freshman name to real part of Michigans season, and now he is set for an even bigger stage. The true freshman quarterback, grandson of former Wolverines coach Lloyd Carr and brother of Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr, has started two games this year and helped Michigan secure key wins, giving the staff a reason to trust him in meaningful moments.
Now comes the next test, and it carries plenty of weight in a rivalry game. Carr has been named the starter for Michigans upcoming matchup with Michigan State, and if he handles it well, the Wolverines may keep rolling with him under center beyond this week. For a team looking for stability at quarterback, this is a chance for a freshman to turn a temporary opportunity into something more lasting. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Rivalry Loss Just Turned Up The Heat On Its Coaches
Michigans loss to Michigan State had the feel of more than just a rivalry setback. The Wolverines had won four straight in the series, but a 15-6 defeat snapped that run and exposed the same offensive issues that have been hanging over the program. Turnovers, stalled drives and shaky quarterback play all played a part in a game Michigan never really controlled.
The bigger concern is what the performance says about the coaching staffs ability to get the offense moving when it matters most. Michigan State also picked up its first Big Ten win under Pat Fitzgerald, which only sharpened the optics of the loss for Michigan. For a team with higher expectations, this was the kind of night that invites hard questions about direction, execution and whether the current approach is getting enough out of the roster. [Read more 🡒]