Notre Dame’s CJ Carr is already drawing plenty of attention as the 2026 season approaches, but his path to South Bend still turns heads for one simple reason: he could have been a Michigan quarterback.
Carr grew up surrounded by Wolverines ties. His father played in Ann Arbor, his mother attended the University of Michigan, and his grandfather, Lloyd Carr, is one of the program’s most recognizable names after coaching there from 1995-2007 and going 122-40.
Still, family history did not push him to the Maize and Blue. Speaking recently on the Rich Eisen Show, Carr laid out how his recruitment unfolded and why Michigan never became the obvious destination some expected.
“Michigan was my first offer coming out of high school,” Carr said. “I played the last game of my freshman year, (and) after that game, played pretty well, Michigan and Michigan State offered me.”
Carr, who was at Saline High School in Michigan, said Jim Harbaugh was the first coach to offer him. He also said his father kept the Michigan offer from him at first so he would stay open-minded during the process.
As his recruitment moved into his sophomore year, Carr visited several Midwest programs, including Michigan State, Penn State and Wisconsin. What stood out to him was how differently Michigan handled things.
“Michigan didn’t really recruit me,” Carr said. “It felt like they thought I was just going to Michigan because of my family.”
That was not the case. Carr said he heard strong things about Marcus Freeman after Freeman was hired, and he also credited former Notre Dame offensive coordinator Tommy Rees for staying persistent in the pursuit.
The contrast matters even more in hindsight. Michigan’s 2024 quarterback class included only Jadyn Davis, and Davis has since transferred to East Tennessee State University.
Carr, meanwhile, has already put together a strong start at Notre Dame, throwing for over 2,000 yards and 24 touchdowns in 2025 and emerging as one of the top freshman quarterbacks in the country. He has also been named a 2026 Phil Steele Preseason All-American.
That leaves the obvious what-if: if Michigan had pushed harder for Carr, would Bryce Underwood still have been the next quarterback added in the 2025 class? And if both had ended up in Ann Arbor, who would be starting now?
Those questions won’t get answered until the 2026 season gets rolling and Carr’s offseason progress becomes clearer.
Michigan did, however, land one Carr brother. Tommy Carr, CJ’s younger brother, is set to be a freshman this season, and reports have said he has impressed early on campus and could even be the backup quarterback. For the Wolverines, that may be the closest thing to a second chance.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Still Cringe At These Recruiting Busts
Michigans recruiting history has plenty of success stories, but the misses are the ones that still linger in fan memory. A recent look back at the last 26 years of Wolverines recruiting pulled together five names that arrived with major hype and left far short of it, including Aubrey Solomon, Kevin Grady, Derrick Green, Marques Slocum and Kelley Baraka. Each came to Ann Arbor with the kind of ranking that can shape expectations for years, yet injuries, transfers and other setbacks kept those careers from ever matching the promise.
What makes this list sting for Michigan followers is how different the paths turned out to be. Some players never settled in, some never got the chance to build momentum, and some simply could not overcome the obstacles that followed them into college. The result is a reminder that recruiting stars do not always become college fixtures, and for Michigan fans, these are the names that still get brought up whenever the conversation turns to what might have been. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Returning Player Rankings Just Changed The 2026 Conversation
Michigans 2026 outlook is getting a fresh reset through the lens of what came before it, with a new ranking of returning players built around 2025 Pro Football Focus grades and playing time. The list puts a spotlight on the kind of contributors who can quietly shape a rosters next step, from pass rushers and blockers to linemen whose value shows up in the details rather than the box score, and it gives a clearer sense of which returning names are most likely to matter when next season arrives.
Andrew Marsh is part of that conversation after emerging as the teams best wide receiver with a 78.1 receiving grade, a sign that the Wolverines may already have a dependable piece in place on the perimeter. The broader ranking also tracks players such as Lugard Edokpayi, Bryson Kuzdzal, Jake Guarnera, Dominic Nichols, Andrew Sprague and Trey Pierce, but the order still leaves one key question hanging at the top, which is exactly the kind of offseason debate that tends to linger around Ann Arbor. [Read more 🡒]