Michigan quarterback Bryce Underwood knows what comes with the spotlight. When you arrive as a five-star, flip from LSU to sign with the Wolverines, and get treated like the next big thing, the noise starts before you ever take a snap.
Underwood added to that buzz himself, saying he was going to be the best freshman college football has ever seen. The reality of his first season looked a lot more like a young quarterback learning on the fly.
He averaged 218 total yards per game and finished with 11 touchdown passes, 17 total touchdowns and nine interceptions. There were moments that showed why the hype followed him, but there were plenty of growing pains, too.
That shouldn’t be surprising when you remember he had just turned 18 last season. A comparison to Dante Moore makes that point pretty clearly. Moore spent a season on the bench before eventually emerging as Oregon’s starter and a top NFL draft prospect.
Underwood doesn’t get that kind of runway. Michigan needs him on the field now, and it also brought in a new offensive coordinator in Jason Beck, who has a reputation as a QB guru. Underwood still has the kind of physical tools that make people believe he can become special.
That’s why USA Today Sports put his 2026 season on the make-or-break list, and it did the same for Beck. Underwood was listed behind Josh Hoover of Indiana and Sam Leavitt of LSU, even though his situation is different from both. He’s only entering his second season as a starter.
There’s no question 2026 matters for him. Michigan’s push for the College Football Playoff likely depends on Underwood making a real leap.
But calling it make-or-break already goes too far. He’s not draft eligible yet, and one uneven season does not decide his future.
Beck’s track record gives Michigan reason to believe the next step is coming. He did a stellar job developing Devon Dampier at Utah and also at New Mexico, though Dampier didn’t really break through until their second season together.
One change that should help is that Underwood is expected to run more in 2026. That should open up the offense and make life easier for him as a passer, too. Last season, Michigan tried to keep him in a box instead of letting him roam and make plays.
Beck will need to unlock that part of his game. The ranking makes sense in that light.
Underwood has to play well if Michigan wants to reach the Playoff. But if he doesn’t make a huge leap right away, that doesn’t mean the story is over.
He could improve a little in 2026, then take a big jump in 2027 as a junior. That kind of arc is hardly impossible. Arch Manning is the example being floated, with the idea that he struggled some in 2025 before looking ready for a breakout in 2026.
That’s the part national media often seems unwilling to sit with: quarterback development doesn’t move in a straight line.
In Other News...
Michigan Freshman Drawing Unexpected Buzz Along The Wolverines Defensive Front
Michigans 2026 recruiting class already looks like one of the more intriguing groups in the country, and the attention around the defensive front has started to shift toward Titan Davis. The freshman lineman arrived with a reputation for disruptive play in high school, and his name has surfaced alongside other highly rated newcomers such as Savion Hiter and Carter Meadows as a player who could factor into the conversation sooner rather than later.
CBS Sports recently singled out Davis as one of the freshmen to watch, a notable nod for a player who may not need long to make his presence felt in Ann Arbor. There is still some uncertainty around how quickly that role settles in, especially with summer enrollment in the mix, but Michigan has every reason to keep a close eye on a defender who could end up carving out a bigger spot on the line than most first-year players do. [Read more 🡒]
Bryce Underwood Hype Meets A Brutal Michigan Reality Check
Bryce Underwoods arrival has given Michigan fans a reason to dream again, but one national projection is a reminder that hype only goes so far when the schedule gets real. CBS Sports analyst Brad Crawford sees the Wolverines finishing 8-4 in 2026, a mark that would still reflect a talented roster but also the growing pains of a program adjusting to Kyle Whittinghams first season in charge.
The early test comes quickly, with Oklahoma looming as a major non-conference challenge that could set the tone for the fall. Even with Underwood headlining a group that looks capable of beating most opponents on paper, the broader view is less forgiving, and it leaves Michigan staring at the same question so many teams face after a coaching change: is the talent good enough to survive the transition and stay in the playoff conversation? [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Push For Elite Corners Suddenly Feels Far More Real
Jernaro Gilford has quickly become one of the more important additions on Michigans staff, and the early returns are showing up where the Wolverines have wanted them most: in the secondary. The new cornerbacks coach, who came over after coaching at BYU, has helped give Michigan real momentum with elite defensive back targets in the 2027 class, and his competitive style plus NFL player-development background has resonated in a way that is already lifting the programs profile on the trail.
Michigans recruiting work in the Big Ten is sitting at No. 11 for now, but the broader takeaway is that the Wolverines no longer look like a team merely hoping to get in the mix for top corners. With a highly rated defensive back class already taking shape, there is a clear path for the group to keep climbing if the next wave of blue-chip commitments breaks the right way. [Read more 🡒]