Michigan has not cycled through a one-and-done football coach since 1900, when Biff Lea went 7-2-1 before leaving for Princeton and opening the door for Fielding Yost. More than a century later, that kind of quick exit is back on the table in Ann Arbor.
Kyle Whittingham’s first season has gone sideways fast, and the latest blow came in a 15-6 loss to Michigan State, a game in which the Wolverines didn’t score a touchdown against the Big Ten’s last-place scoring offense. Michigan is 5-4, ranked 116th nationally in scoring at 19.6 points per game, and now heads into a brutal stretch with No. 16 Oregon on Saturday, followed by UCLA and Ohio State.
“It doesn’t get any easier, we’ve got three tough games in a row,” Whittingham said after the Michigan State loss. “We’ve got Oregon, UCLA and the guys in Ohio.
So, we’re 5-4. Very disappointing.
On the other hand, I thought the defense played pretty good.”
That line fits the season, even if it barely scratches the surface. The defense has held up enough to keep Michigan afloat at times. The offense has dragged everything else down.
Whittingham arrived in Ann Arbor with a strong reputation and a résumé that made the hire look like a clean solution after Sherrone Moore was fired on Dec. 10 following another Michigan scandal. At the time, it was easy to see why the move earned praise. Whittingham came in with a 177-88 record in 21 seasons at Utah, including three 10-win seasons in the previous five years.
The off-field side has stayed relatively quiet. The on-field side has been a mess.
Michigan opened with a 13-12 win over Western Michigan in a game clouded by the “one second” controversy, then beat Oklahoma 17-10 to move to 3-0 and give the impression that the season might steady itself once Big Ten play began. Instead, it started to fall apart.
Iowa handed the Wolverines a 20-19 loss on Sept. 26, Minnesota took the Little Brown Jug the next week in a 20-14 win, and then came a 21-18 victory over Penn State in which five-star quarterback Bryce Underwood was benched for Tommy Carr.
An overtime loss to Indiana followed. So did a close call at Rutgers.
Then Michigan lost the Paul Bunyan Trophy to Michigan State.
“It’s my fault for not getting our guys in the right frame of mind,” Whittingham said. “We never said it’s not important to us.
It’s really important. It’s very important.”
That’s where this gets uncomfortable for Michigan. Whittingham spent years coaching in the “Holy War” against BYU, so he knows rivalry football.
But in Big Ten country, those trophies are not decorative. Harbaugh never lost to Minnesota.
Moore never lost to Michigan State. And now Whittingham has to walk into Ohio Stadium on Nov. 28, where the Wolverines have won the last two meetings.
The Buckeyes may be dealing with their own issues in Columbus, but they are still going to want Michigan’s soul. A win there might be the only thing that buys Whittingham more time.
The offense, meanwhile, is a separate problem entirely. Michigan’s 2023 national title team looks a long way off now, even with several of its stars - JJ McCarthy, Blake Corum and Colston Loveland - thriving in the NFL.
The Wolverines were already struggling offensively under Moore, but they still averaged 27.5 points per game last season with Underwood as a freshman. Under Jason Beck, that number has fallen to 19.6, and to 15.7 in Big Ten play.
The bottom fell out against the Spartans, when Michigan managed only six points. Beck was fired Monday.
“There’s nothing productive about this game,” Whittingham said. “It’s not one step back.
It’s three steps back. … I can’t come up with one positive thing offensively about this game.”
Underwood and Carr have combined for seven touchdowns and nine interceptions. Five-star freshman Savion Hiter leads the team with 336 rushing yards and three touchdowns. Utah transfer JJ Buchanan has been the bright spot at receiver with 646 yards and six touchdowns.
But the larger issue is still sitting in plain sight. Michigan hasn’t had a 1,000-yard receiver since Jeremy Gallon’s 1,373-yard, nine-touchdown season in 2013, and it hasn’t had a first-round pick at receiver since Braylon Edwards in 2005. The quarterback questions matter, but so does this: who is the ball going to?
Underwood could be a transfer candidate after the season, which would leave Carr as the potential long-term answer. Either way, Michigan has to modernize the passing game if it wants Hiter and the rest of the offense to make sense.
Whittingham’s frustration was obvious after the Michigan State loss.
“I’m as disappointed as I’ve ever been as a head coach, and I’m as frustrated as I’ve ever been as a head coach,” he said.
That’s not the kind of quote that usually signals a stable landing spot. It also comes with Utah sitting at No. 2 at 9-0 and on track for the program’s first playoff appearance, which only sharpens the contrast with what Michigan thought it was getting.
This isn’t as bleak as Rich Rodriguez’s first season in 2007, when Michigan went 3-9. If the Wolverines finish 5-7, it would match Brady Hoke’s final season in 2014, the year before Harbaugh arrived and revived the program. Harbaugh’s run was strong for years, aside from the 2-4 COVID season, before the NCAA investigations piled up and reached their peak with Connor Stalions.
Now Michigan is staring at another uncertain stretch. Athletic director Warde Manuel is stepping down at the end of the season, and the school still has not replaced him.
That makes the coaching question even messier. The Wolverines are at a crossroads, with names already floating around, including UCLA coach Bob Chesney, whom Michigan will see on Nov. 21, and Vanderbilt’s Clark Lea, who is 21-14 with the Commodores since 2024.
Chesney is the popular pick right now, but Lea would make sense too if Michigan wants someone who can build in Ann Arbor.
For Whittingham, the margin is shrinking fast. Michigan needs a real response over these last three games, because if this keeps going the way it has been, “one and done” may end up being the cleanest outcome of all.
In Other News...
Michigan Heads Into Oregon With Troubling Questions Up Front
Michigans front has become a concern at the worst possible time, with Dominic Nichols still working back from a lower-leg injury that has been aggravated along the way and Nate Marshall now suspended indefinitely. The Wolverines have leaned on that group for physicality and depth all season, so any disruption there matters even more as they try to steady themselves heading into a difficult stretch.
Lewis Powell has made it clear the issue is about more than availability, stressing accountability and team rules while leaving Marshalls return uncertain. For a team still chasing bowl eligibility in a season that has already brought plenty of challenges, the timing is hardly ideal, and the trip to Oregon only sharpens the pressure on a defensive line that needs answers fast. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Suddenly Has A Depth Problem At The Worst Time
Michigans injury picture did not get any cleaner coming out of the loss to Michigan State, even with one notable defensive back no longer listed on the report. The bigger concern remains up front, where starting tackles Andrew Sprague and Blake Frazier are still dealing with injuries, and Frazier is doubtful heading into the next game.
The Wolverines are also carrying a longer list of banged-up players in John Henry Daley, Dom Nichols, Jalen Hoffman, Hogan Hansen and Channing Goodwin, which leaves the roster thinner at several spots at a bad time. For a team trying to steady itself after a frustrating setback, the issue is not just who is available now, but how much more strain Michigan can put on its depth before it starts showing on the field. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Battered Offense Faces One Last Shot To Keep Season Alive
Michigan heads into its next game with the season hanging in the balance, needing one more win to become bowl eligible. The challenge is a tough one, with Oregon coming in off a strong victory and Michigan still trying to find any kind of rhythm on offense after a stretch defined by injuries up front and at key spots.
The Wolverines may have to lean on younger players and whatever adjustments the new offensive coordinator can squeeze out in a short window. For a unit that has struggled to stay intact, this feels like the kind of week where progress matters almost as much as the result, even if the margin for error has nearly disappeared. [Read more 🡒]