J.J. McCarthy is getting another shot, and the Giants are betting it could be the one that finally sticks.
According to Jordan Schultz of the Bleacher Report, the Minnesota Vikings traded the former Michigan quarterback to the New York Giants on Monday. For McCarthy, it’s a clean break from a situation that never really settled into place after Minnesota drafted him 10th overall in the 2024 NFL draft.
He arrived in the league with the idea that he would become the Vikings’ long-term answer under center. That plan unraveled quickly. McCarthy suffered a season-ending injury in the preseason of 2024 and missed his entire rookie year, losing a crucial season of development before he even got started.
Minnesota moved on from Sam Darnold after he helped the Vikings win the NFC North title in 2024, and McCarthy got the first chance to take over. The results were uneven. He went 6-4 in 10 starts, and there were flashes along the way, including a Week 1 comeback win over the Bears in 2025 that earned him NFC Offensive Player of the Week honors after he accounted for three touchdowns.
But the season never fully came together. McCarthy dealt with injuries, the offensive line struggled, and the offense had too many stretches where it just never found a rhythm.
He finished 2025 completing 57.4 percent of his passes, with 11 touchdowns, 12 interceptions and four rushing touchdowns. He also had one game-winning drive and one fourth-quarter comeback.
The move to New York gives him a different kind of opening.
The Giants are without Jaxson Dart for the season, and while Jameis Winston is currently the starter, New York is 2-1 and still has a roster that has been mentioned as a possible playoff contender. That makes McCarthy’s arrival especially interesting: there’s no long wait to find out whether this can work.
There’s also a built-in familiarity here. Giants head coach John Harbaugh knows McCarthy well through his brother, who coached him at Michigan, and that connection could matter as McCarthy tries to reset his career.
For New York, the trade comes with limited downside. If McCarthy figures things out, the Giants gain another option.
If not, they haven’t overcommitted. For McCarthy, though, the stakes are clearer: he’s healthy, he’s got a fresh start, and he’s finally in a spot where he might get the chance to prove what he can be.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Will Be Second Guessing One Late Coaching Choice
Michigans one-point loss to Iowa was the kind of game that leaves a fan base replaying the final minutes over and over. The Wolverines had their chances in a 20-19 defeat, but the closing sequence is likely to be the part that lingers most, especially with the offense leaning on the run game when the game was hanging in the balance.
The biggest talking point is the late decision to run the ball three straight times, a choice the article attributes to head coach Kyle Whittingham. It is the sort of call that can look sensible in the moment and frustrating in hindsight, and for Michigan it now sits at the center of what went wrong in a game that slipped away by the slimmest of margins. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Loss To Iowa Looks Even Worse After One Brutal Reality
Michigans 20-19 loss to Iowa had all the markings of one of those frustrating afternoons that sticks with a fan base long after the final whistle. The Wolverines controlled plenty of the underlying numbers and even posted a higher success rate, but the scoreboard told a far less forgiving story, one shaped by missed chances and a game that slipped away despite the statistical edge.
Iowas special teams helped tilt the night with a kickoff return for a touchdown, and Michigan did not make enough of its own opportunities in the red zone to compensate. An interception and a failed fourth-down try inside scoring range loomed especially large in a one-point game, turning what looked like a solid performance on paper into a loss that feels even harder to explain in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Defense Did Enough To Win Until Two Costly Mistakes
For most of the afternoon against Iowa, Michigans defense did what it had to do. It kept the Wolverines in front, squeezed the Hawkeyes offense and gave the team a chance to ride the lead, with CB Zeke Berry, edge Dom Nichols and S Chris Bracy all drawing strong grades for their work on a unit that generally looked in control.
Still, the game turned on a handful of mistakes that proved too costly to absorb. Michigan finished with seven missed tackles, and a couple of critical penalties and breakdowns helped undercut all the good work that came before them, leaving the defense with the frustrating feeling that it had done enough to win until it didnt. [Read more 🡒]