Indiana Is Using One Michigan Result To Fuel Its Playoff Push

Indiana coach Curt Cignetti voices his discontent with the CFP rankings, insisting the Hoosiers deserve recognition for their competitive schedule and top performances, including a heart-stopping clash with Ohio State.

Curt Cignetti isn’t backing off.

With Indiana sitting at 9-1 and still trying to make its case in the College Football Playoff conversation, the Hoosiers’ coach spent Monday making the argument as loudly as possible. He defended the résumé, pushed back on the criticism and took direct aim at the people questioning what Indiana has done on the field.

“Well, you know, we don’t play anybody,” Cignetti told reporters Monday. “We have a soft schedule, right? That’s all I’ve heard around here for three years because people love to discredit us and what we’ve accomplished.”

That was only part of it. Cignetti also said Indiana “ripped the heart out of” Ohio State, a line that came during a long defense of the Hoosiers’ schedule and their place in the rankings debate.

The timing matters. Indiana dropped from fourth to ninth in last Tuesday’s CFP rankings despite not playing the Saturday before, and Cignetti responded on social media with, “Bad losses don’t count anymore? Are first downs still 10 yards?”

A week earlier, he had taken a broader shot at the way teams are viewed nationally, saying the “SEC gets a lot of love from ESPN. … And that’s why you see all these SEC teams up there and some good two-loss teams from the Big Ten not quite as high.”

Indiana’s latest win only added more fuel to Cignetti’s case. The Hoosiers beat USC, which entered the game ranked 19th in the previous CFP rankings, giving Indiana another top-25 win to point to.

Cignetti kept circling back to the same theme: the schedule criticism ignores what has happened to the teams Indiana has beaten, and it ignores what the Hoosiers have done against them.

He referenced Ohio State, Indiana’s only loss, and said the Buckeyes were at full strength when the teams met. Indiana knocked Julian Sayin out of that game with a shoulder injury, and the 2025 Heisman Trophy finalist has not played since.

Ohio State has gone 1-2 without him and is now 7-3 (5-2). Indiana lost that game when receiver Nick Marsh failed to get his foot inbounds for what should have been the game-winning touchdown reception.

“That was the Hoosiers’ only loss in the past 26 games.”

“You saw what happened. We knocked the quarterback out,” Cignetti said.

“We ripped the heart out of that team. They haven’t been the same since without the quarterback.

But all I hear about is how we lost to a three-loss team. That was a team picked to win a national championship that led Texas 95 percent of the game at Texas.

We missed a layup. You know what?

They won; we didn’t. But we missed a layup.

You know, that’s why we’re not 26-0, we’re 25-1.”

Cignetti then worked through the rest of Indiana’s Big Ten schedule, using each game as another example of why the Hoosiers deserve more respect.

He brought up Northwestern, which was a good team when Indiana played it and later reached the top 25 before slipping after an injury to starting quarterback Aidan Chiles. He also pointed to Alabama getting credit for beating Mississippi State when Kamario Taylor was at quarterback, even though the Bulldogs are now 4-6.

“You get tired of the narrative sometimes, you know?” Cignetti said.

“Quality win because Joe Smith was playing at the time. They ain’t won a game since, but it was a quality win back then.”

Nebraska came up next. Indiana beat the Cornhuskers 20-17 after erasing an 11-point fourth-quarter deficit, and Cignetti said that result should be viewed through a coach’s lens.

“They had a hard time rebounding from that, OK? Wasn’t a pretty win in a lot of people’s eyes, but from a coach’s standpoint, showed a lot of competitive character to me and people that know football,” Cignetti said.

He also pointed to Indiana’s overtime win at Michigan, 13-6, in a game he described as difficult from the start because of the setting and the condition of the quarterback Josh Hoover.

“That’s an easy one right up in Ann Arbor: 4-2 Michigan, 112,000 (fans), you know, with a quarterback that’s not 100 percent,” Cignetti said.

Minnesota and USC were part of the same argument. Cignetti noted that Minnesota was 5-2 when Indiana beat the Gophers 23-16 in overtime, and he said USC entered this past Saturday’s game at 7-2.

Now the committee gets another look at Indiana on Tuesday night, and the Hoosiers do not have many chances left to strengthen their case. They play at Washington this weekend, and the Huskies are 6-4 (3-4).

Indiana then closes the regular season against Purdue, which is 3-7 (2-5). The Hoosiers should be favored in both games and appear headed for another trip to the Big Ten title game.

Cignetti, though, made it clear he’s not worried about the noise.

“But, look, it’s all going to play out on the field,” Cignetti said. “You know, good for entertainment.

I’m sure this will get a lot of nice hits and play, but our guys understand that it’ll play out on the field. The good thing about it is I think it feeds into our motivation and our chip.

That’s why I’m not afraid to keep it alive. And you know what?

I’m 65 years old, and I really don’t give a s-.”

In Other News...

Aidan Hutchinson News Just Hit Michigan Fans Where It Hurts

Michigan fans got a rough reminder of how quickly momentum can turn when Aidan Hutchinson went down with a season-ending knee injury while celebrating a sack against the New England Patriots. The former Michigan star has been one of the most visible success stories for the program at the pro level, so seeing him sidelined in that kind of fashion landed hard for a fan base that still tracks every step he takes.

The news arrived during a stretch when the Wolverines could have used a lift, too, with football taking a recruiting hit as four-star defensive back Tavarres Harrington decommitted and flipped to Ole Miss. There was at least some good news elsewhere on campus, as Michigan hockey swept Penn State with an 8-3 win behind Jayden Perrons hat trick and Landon DuPonts four assists, but Hutchinsons injury was the kind of blow that tends to linger far beyond one Sunday. [Read more 🡒]

Michigan Passing Game Just Lost The One Receiver It Could Trust

Michigans passing game took a major hit against Oregon when JJ Buchanan went down with a shoulder injury, and the expectation now is that he will miss the rest of the season. At the time of the injury, Buchanan was the Wolverines leader in both receiving yards and touchdowns, which made him the one target the offense could count on when it needed a play through the air.

Now the burden shifts to a younger group that has to grow up quickly. Andrew Marsh, Salesi Moa and Travis Johnson are the names most likely to see a bigger role, and Michigan will need one or more of them to provide something close to Buchanans production if the passing game is going to stay afloat. [Read more 🡒]

Michigans Quarterback Confusion Is Becoming A Bigger Problem

The loss to Oregon only sharpened the questions around Michigans quarterback plan, because the offense never found a rhythm while the staff kept cycling through Bryce Underwood and Tommy Carr. In a 31-7 defeat, the Wolverines finished with just 6 completions on 20 attempts, 286 total yards and two turnovers, a line that reflected a unit still searching for any kind of stability under center.

What has made the situation harder to ignore is the mixed messaging coming from the sideline, with head coach Kyle Whittingham offering inconsistent public signals about who actually holds the starting job. Both quarterbacks saw the field against Oregon, and the continued rotation left Michigan with more uncertainty than answers at a position that usually demands clarity long before the games get this difficult. [Read more 🡒]