Jim Harbaugh’s run at Michigan was defined by the kind of recruiting wins that change a program’s ceiling. He landed J.J. McCarthy, Blake Corum, Mason Graham, Kenneth Grant and Colston Loveland, and Graham and Grant in particular outplayed their rankings in a way that helped fuel a national championship season.
But every great recruiting stretch comes with a few misses, and Michigan’s Harbaugh era had plenty of those too. Some of them still linger because of how differently things might have looked if the Wolverines had closed on the right name at the right time.
C.J. Stroud is the obvious place to start.
Michigan and Ohio State fought over him late in the 2020 class after U-M’s four-star commit JD Johnson suffered a career-ending injury. Stroud, ranked 42nd overall in the 2020 class by the 247 Sports composite, chose the Buckeyes instead.
He went on to start two seasons, throw for 734 yards in two games against Michigan with four touchdown passes and two interceptions, and finish his career 0-2 as a starter. He never played in a Big Ten championship game or won any sort of championship.
Aidan Hutchinson’s three-sack performance also shut down his Heisman Trophy chase. If Stroud had ended up in Ann Arbor, Michigan might have had a better shot against Georgia, and maybe even found a different answer at quarterback in 2020 after the Joe Milton diaster.
Najee Harris is the one many Michigan fans still circle first. He was the top-ranked running back in the 2016 class and the No. 2 overall prospect, and Michigan was the first school to offer him.
The Wolverines even drew a crystal ball prediction to flip him from Alabama, but the Crimson Tide held on. Harbaugh did eventually sign Harris with the Chargers, finally getting the 6-foot-2, 225-pound back on his squad.
Isaiah Wilson was another painful miss. The 6-foot-7, 350-pound offensive tackle looked like a Michigan lock, with seven crystal ball predictions pointing to the Wolverines before Georgia landed the five-star lineman.
Wilson later became a first-round pick. Michigan’s offensive line could have used that kind of left tackle during that stretch, and Shea Patterson probably would have appreciated it too.
This one still stings, especially because Harbaugh poured so much into the recruitment early on.
Xavier Worthy might be the most explosive what if on the list. The future first-round pick’s recruitment got tangled up in what the source describes as miscommunication about whether he could enroll early.
Once that didn’t happen, Worthy reopened things, asked out of his letter of intent, and signed with Texas. He became a first-round pick there.
Pairing that kind of home-run threat with McCarthy and Michigan’s run game would have been dangerous, especially since Worthy was in the same class as McCarthy and Donovan Edwards. It’s easy to picture him in that offense - or even imagine Stroud throwing deep balls to him.
Then there’s Dante Moore, a miss tied to Michigan’s early NIL approach. The Wolverines were still talking about being “transformational” not “transactional,” and they didn’t really have the NIL setup to land the No. 5 prospect in the 2023 class.
Still, Moore would have been a massive get. The Detroit King star could have joined the roster in 2023, spent a year behind McCarthy, and entered 2024 ready to take over.
That kind of setup might have changed everything. Bryce Underwood might not have ended up at Michigan if Moore had already been there, but it’s easy to see how Moore plus that defense could have pointed the Wolverines toward a College Football Playoff Appearance.
CJ Carr belongs in the same conversation. The grandson of Lloyd Carr ended up at Notre Dame, even though Michigan was viewed as a leader at one point in his recruitment.
That was back in the 2024 class, before the Wolverines were really invested in NIL. Carr said he felt like U-M didn’t recruit him as hard as Notre Dame, and the Irish also offered a huge NIL deal while Michigan was not in that business.
Carr’s freshman season for Notre Dame was strong - 24 touchdown passes and six interceptions - while Bryce Underwood played one game as a freshman before starting all 13. Underwood’s second season will tell part of the story from here.
If he hits, the pain of missing Moore and Carr won’t cut quite as deep.
Still, the bigger picture is hard to ignore. Michigan probably couldn’t have landed Moore, Carr and Underwood across the 2023, 2024 and 2025 classes anyway.
If Carr had signed, Underwood likely wouldn’t have come. If Michigan had Moore, Carr probably wouldn’t have waited around either.
The Wolverines might have had a real shot at Moore and Underwood, given the spacing between the classes. Missing Carr remains a bummer, but the fact that Moore, Carr and Underwood are all starting for different schools this season shows just how hard it would have been for Michigan to land even two of them and keep them in the fold.
In Other News...
Michigan Fans Wont Love What CJ Carr Said About His Decision
CJ Carrs path to Notre Dame has always carried a Michigan subplot, and he revisited it this week while talking on the Rich Eisen Show. The Irish quarterback said Michigan was his first offer, but the Wolverines never made him feel like a true priority, a feeling that stood out even more because of his family ties to the program. In the end, Notre Dames staff kept coming after him and made the stronger impression, and Carr has since backed up that decision with a strong start to his college career and preseason All-American recognition.
For Michigan fans, the part that stings is not just where Carr ended up, but how he explained the choice. The Wolverines did land his younger brother, Tommy Carr, who has drawn positive reviews on campus and could be in line to back up this season, but that does little to change the bigger picture around the older Carr. It is another reminder that in recruiting, legacy connections only go so far if a staff does not keep pressing, and Carrs comments made clear he felt Notre Dame wanted him more. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fans Still Cringe At These Recruiting Busts
Michigans recruiting history has plenty of success stories, but the misses are the ones that still linger in fan memory. A recent look back at the last 26 years of Wolverines recruiting pulled together five names that arrived with major hype and left far short of it, including Aubrey Solomon, Kevin Grady, Derrick Green, Marques Slocum and Kelley Baraka. Each came to Ann Arbor with the kind of ranking that can shape expectations for years, yet injuries, transfers and other setbacks kept those careers from ever matching the promise.
What makes this list sting for Michigan followers is how different the paths turned out to be. Some players never settled in, some never got the chance to build momentum, and some simply could not overcome the obstacles that followed them into college. The result is a reminder that recruiting stars do not always become college fixtures, and for Michigan fans, these are the names that still get brought up whenever the conversation turns to what might have been. [Read more 🡒]
Michigans Returning Player Rankings Just Changed The 2026 Conversation
Michigans 2026 outlook is getting a fresh reset through the lens of what came before it, with a new ranking of returning players built around 2025 Pro Football Focus grades and playing time. The list puts a spotlight on the kind of contributors who can quietly shape a rosters next step, from pass rushers and blockers to linemen whose value shows up in the details rather than the box score, and it gives a clearer sense of which returning names are most likely to matter when next season arrives.
Andrew Marsh is part of that conversation after emerging as the teams best wide receiver with a 78.1 receiving grade, a sign that the Wolverines may already have a dependable piece in place on the perimeter. The broader ranking also tracks players such as Lugard Edokpayi, Bryson Kuzdzal, Jake Guarnera, Dominic Nichols, Andrew Sprague and Trey Pierce, but the order still leaves one key question hanging at the top, which is exactly the kind of offseason debate that tends to linger around Ann Arbor. [Read more 🡒]