Michigan State’s search for a new athletic director has a logical name sitting just down the road in Kalamazoo: Western Michigan AD Dan Bartholomae.
Bartholomae has been floated as a candidate for the Spartans’ opening for good reason. He checks a lot of the boxes Michigan State is likely to care about, from football decisions to fundraising to the ability to run a department with bigger ambitions.
The biggest obstacle would be the price tag. Western Michigan extended Bartholomae through June 2031 last August, and his buyout is reportedly $5 million.
For a Group of Six athletic director, that is a steep number. But Michigan State may have the money to make it work.
The Spartans are set to receive $3.95 million in buyout money from Kentucky after the Wildcats hired J Batt away from MSU. Batt’s original buyout was $5 million, though that figure was set to drop to $2.5 million when president Kevin Guskiewicz originally accepted a job at Clemson.
That clause never actually kicked in, but the two sides still worked toward a middle ground because of the unusual circumstances. If Michigan State used all of the Kentucky money on Bartholomae, it would still need to come up with just $1.05 million more.
That would be a manageable gap, especially after MSU paid a little more than $2 million to Georgia Tech for Batt’s buyout there last year.
On the football side, Bartholomae has already shown he’s willing to make a hard call. Not long after arriving at Western Michigan, he fired Tim Lester following a 5-7 season in 2022 and replaced him with Lance Taylor.
Taylor’s first two years were uneven, going 4-8 and then 6-7, but the Broncos broke through last season with a 10-4 finish and their first MAC title since 2016, when P.J. Fleck was the coach.
That kind of decision matters at Michigan State, where the next AD will be judged heavily on football. Bartholomae has already made a move that changed the direction of a program.
He has also delivered on the money side. Western Michigan announced last week that it brought in a record $21.8 million in donations during FY26, with more than 3,800 unique donors. The school said overall financial support for the athletic department has risen 473% since Bartholomae arrived in 2022, and the number of unique donors has more than doubled.
If Bartholomae were to land at Michigan State, the scale would change dramatically. The expectations would be bigger, but so would the resources. He has already shown he can get a mid-major department moving in the right direction financially, and that makes him an intriguing fit for a Big Ten job.
There’s also a direct connection to Jonathan Smith, the former Michigan State football coach who was fired by Batt the day after the 2025 season finale. Bartholomae served as Oregon State’s executive deputy AD and COO before taking the Western Michigan job, overlapping with Smith’s time with the Beavers.
“Dan was vitally important to Oregon State football and the entire OSU athletic department during his time here,” Smith said about Bartholomae on the NCHC’s profile of Bartholomae. “His ability to understand the big picture and at the same time work closely with so many on the day-to-day makes him more than ready to lead an entire athletic department.”
Bartholomae worked at Oregon State from 2017 to 2022, and Smith’s first season there was 2018. Before Oregon State, Bartholomae spent more than a decade at Pitt, where he worked heavily in compliance and eventually became deputy athletic director for internal affairs.
Taken together, it’s a strong résumé. Western Michigan has had success on the field, success in fundraising and even record results in the NCAA’s Academic Progress Rate metric. Michigan State would be a much bigger stage, but Bartholomae looks like someone who has earned a look.
In Other News...
Michigan AD Search Suddenly Has One Candidate Fans Need To Watch
Michigans nationwide athletic director search is already drawing plenty of attention, and part of the intrigue is how much the hire will say about the programs next chapter. The job comes with obvious pressure, but also with the kind of profile that can attract proven administrators who have spent years navigating big-budget, high-expectation environments.
One reason this search has a built-in layer of interest is the family angle: the current Oregon athletic director has a son on Michigans baseball team, which gives the process a more personal feel than most front-office hunts. Add in a rsum that includes a long run in Eugene and a track record of winning across the Ducks department, and Michigan has a decision that is about more than just filling a vacancy. The school also has to keep its image clean while it looks, because the wrong kind of noise around this hire would only make the next athletic directors first job harder. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Just Added A Staff Hire Fans Will Want To Understand
Michigans latest staff addition brings in a coach with a long track record of building a program from the ground up. Mike Martin spent 14 seasons at Brown, where he became the schools all-time winningest coach and earned Ivy League Coach of the Year honors in 2019, and now he is moving into an assistant role in Ann Arbor with a reputation for player development and program construction.
What makes the hire stand out is the path Martin is taking. Shifting from a head coaching job at Brown to Michigans bench is a notable change in both responsibility and setting, and the Wolverines are counting on him to help oversee the offense as they add another experienced voice to the staff. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Has One Overlooked Problem That Could Define Year One
Kyle Whittinghams arrival in Ann Arbor brought the kind of reset Michigan knew was coming, with Jason Beck taking over the offense and Jay Hill installing a new defense after spring work began. The staff change gives the Wolverines a fresh start on both sides of the ball, but it also means players are learning two new systems at once, which can slow everything from practice tempo to depth-chart clarity.
The biggest pressure point may be Bryce Underwood, who is still working through the usual growing pains of a young quarterback while adjusting to a new offense. His development will matter even more if Beck leans into a more open approach that asks Underwood to distribute the ball and make quick decisions, because Michigan does not have much time to let those pieces come together before the schedule starts demanding answers. [Read more 🡒]