Bryce Underwood is drawing strong early reviews in Michigan’s fall camp, and Kyle Whittingham didn’t leave much room for interpretation.
Speaking Wednesday during the Big Ten Network’s stop in Ann Arbor for the annual training camp tour, Whittingham said the Michigan quarterback is well beyond where he finished spring and gave him the highest possible grade through the first week of work.
“Much further ahead than he was at the end of spring. ... So far, through six practices, I grade him an A+,” Whittingham said.
That’s a notable jump in tone from the spring game buzz that followed Underwood into the offseason. He had his rough moments then, and it fueled the kind of overreaction that comes with young quarterbacks. But the bigger picture is harder to miss: Underwood was a true freshman starter who was asked to handle a lot, and he still put together stretches that showed why Michigan believes in him.
He accounted for 17 total touchdowns in 13 games last season. That number has to rise, and the expectation is that a dedicated QB coach this year can help him get there in a way Sherrone Moore never did.
Jason Beck’s presence matters, too. He’s been described as one of the best offensive coordinators in college football, and he has a track record of developing quarterbacks, including Devon Dampier.
The early camp clips only add to the optimism. Multiple plays have circulated on social media, and while those snapshots don’t tell the full story, Underwood does appear to be throwing the ball with cleaner mechanics and more confidence.
There’s still a bigger test ahead. It’s one thing to look sharper in camp; it’s another to do it when the pass rush shows up.
But Whittingham’s comments suggest the progress is real, and the timing feels familiar to anyone who remembers J.J. McCarthy’s sophomore rise.
McCarthy reached the point where the turnovers disappeared, earned a starting chance from Jim Harbaugh, and never gave the job back.
Underwood’s path has been different, and tougher. He was pushed into a starting role before he was fully ready, though his talent still showed through in flashes.
The USC, Wisconsin and Maryland games are reminders that the ceiling is there. The challenge has always been consistency.
That’s the part that usually takes time. Experience matters at quarterback, and plenty of highly regarded passers look different once they’re no longer asked to learn on the fly.
Julian Sayin would have looked different as a true freshman starter. Notre Dame held CJ Carr back for a reason.
Dante Moore didn’t even get through a full season starting at UCLA.
For now, the signs around Underwood are trending in the right direction. Talent has never been the question.
Seeing it, processing it and repeating it have been the issues. According to what has been seen and reported so far, those areas are improving.
The real measuring stick comes later, when Michigan lines up against Oklahoma and Brent Venables. That’s when the picture gets clearer.
Until then, Michigan fans have reason to feel better about where their quarterback is headed. Whittingham clearly does.
In Other News...
Michigan Linebacker Battle Just Got More Interesting Than Fans Expected
Michigans linebacker room has been one of the more closely watched parts of camp, and the transfer haul only added to the intrigue. The Wolverines brought in three linebackers through the portal this offseason, giving the position a different look as the staff tries to sort out who can help right away and who can provide dependable depth once the season starts.
One of the more interesting names in the mix has already made a strong early impression. The move has given Michigan another experienced body at a spot where it still needs multiple reliable options, and while a starting job is hardly settled, the competition is at least giving the Wolverines more flexibility than they had entering the offseason. [Read more 🡒]
Tommy Carr Is Reviving A Michigan Quarterback What-If Fans Know Well
Fall camp has been underway for a week at Michigan, and one of the more interesting early position battles has centered on backup quarterback Tommy Carr. Carr made a good impression in the spring game and is now competing with transfer Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi for the QB2 job, a situation that has quietly given the Wolverines another layer of intrigue behind the starter.
What makes it even more notable is the broader family context around the Carr name. Tommys brother, CJ Carr, was once recruited by Michigan before ending up at Notre Dame, and the possibility of both brothers having been in Ann Arbor at the same time has become one of those familiar recruiting what-ifs for fans to revisit as the past and present briefly overlap in camp. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Fall Camp Is Starting To Reveal One Defining Battle
Michigans first week of fall camp has already started to sharpen the picture for the season opener against Western Michigan, and a lot of the early attention is settling on the offensive line. The Wolverines are sorting through several position battles up front, with players such as Evan Link and Blake Frazier in the mix, while a handful of true freshmen are also being pushed into consideration for roles. Elsewhere, the receiver group is still coming together behind Andrew Marsh and JJ Buchanan, and quarterback J.J. Underwood has shown steady improvement under coaching.
On the defensive side, John Henry Daley and Rod Moore are being brought along carefully after opening camp on pitch counts, a reminder that Michigan is trying to balance urgency with long-term health this early in August. Even with that caution, the early read is that both are moving toward being available when the games count, which gives the staff some stability as it continues to evaluate one of the camps most important unresolved jobs up front. [Read more 🡒]