Bryce Underwood is already staring down a tough early test, and the spotlight got a whole lot hotter after Joel Klatt’s blunt assessment of the Michigan quarterback’s opener.
Klatt, who will be on the call Saturday when the Wolverines face No. 11 Oklahoma, didn’t sugarcoat what he saw from Underwood in Michigan’s season-opening win over Western Michigan. On "The Herd with Colin Cowherd," he said the sophomore looked like a step backward from where he was a year ago.
"Bryce Underwood, it looked like he regressed from a year ago," Klatt said. "There were just things he wasn't seeing, whether it was in the run game, the passing game, leverage throws, decision-making, that have to improve, and they have to improve drastically."
That’s a sharp critique for a player who arrived with massive expectations. Underwood was the No. 1 overall recruit in the 2025 class, brought in to steady the quarterback position for his home-state Wolverines.
As a true freshman, he flashed enough to keep the hype alive, finishing with 60.3% completions, 2,428 passing yards, 11 touchdowns and nine interceptions. He also added 392 rushing yards and six touchdowns.
But the first game of 2026 didn’t exactly calm the noise. Against Western Michigan, Underwood went 12-of-22 for 170 yards with one touchdown and one interception, while also rushing for 47 yards and a score. The passing line was uneven, and the lone touchdown came in dramatic fashion.
Michigan trailed 12-7 in the closing seconds when Underwood threw a ball out of the back of the end zone as time expired. After a review, one second was put back on the clock, and Underwood connected with JJ Buchanan on a 47-yard game-winning touchdown.
Now comes the kind of matchup that can change the tone around a quarterback fast. Oklahoma opened with a 51-0 rout of the University of Texas at El Paso Miners, with Brent Venables’ defense allowing just 198 total yards while piling up four sacks and 10 tackles for loss.
The Sooners also already have a file on Underwood. In last year’s meeting, Oklahoma held Michigan to 13 points, and Underwood finished 9-of-24 for 142 yards.
So Saturday isn’t just another game for Michigan’s quarterback. It’s a chance to answer the exact concerns Klatt laid out - the reads, the leverage throws, the decision-making, the ability to function when the pocket gets messy.
If Underwood sharpens those areas against Oklahoma, the Week 1 criticism loses some of its force. If not, the pressure around him is only going to grow.
Michigan and Oklahoma kick off at noon ET on Fox on Saturday.
In Other News...
Urban Meyer Sees A Bigger Michigan QB Problem Than Fans Realize
Urban Meyer spent part of The Triple Option Podcast looking beyond the usual chatter around Michigans quarterback room and zeroing in on what he sees as the real issue. He pointed to the relationship between head coach Kyle Whittingham and Bryce Underwood, but also noted that the young quarterback is still physically underdeveloped, which adds another layer to a situation fans have mostly framed as a simple depth-chart discussion.
Meyer also brought Tommy Carr into the picture as a possible source of competition, and his larger point was clear enough: Whittingham will lean on whoever gives the team the best chance to win. The early schedule only sharpens the pressure, because Meyer suggested a loss to Oklahoma could force significant changes around the team, leaving Michigans quarterback situation even more unsettled than it already looks. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Has A New Pass Rusher Facing His First Real Test
Dom Nichols wasted little time making his presence felt in his first start, setting the tone for Michigans edge rush in the opener against Western Michigan. The production was there, but so was the broader message from coaches and teammates, who have pointed to Nichols as a player whose physical and mental growth has quickly made him a factor in the defense.
Now the challenge gets bigger. Nichols is already looking ahead to Oklahoma and quarterback John Mateer, and he knows the next test will be a better measure of where his game stands against a skilled, experienced opponent. For Michigan, that makes Nichols one of the more interesting pieces to watch as the matchup gets tighter and the pass rush is asked to hold up under real pressure. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Hockey Faces Disturbing Lawsuit Over What The Program Allowed
A federal lawsuit filed in Detroit has put a long shadow over Michigan hockey, with 16 former players accusing the program of tolerating ritualized sexual hazing from 1984 through 2001. The complaint says coaches and staff knew about humiliating and abusive initiation practices and allowed them to continue, naming longtime figures such as Red Berenson and Mel Pearson as part of the environment the plaintiffs say enabled the conduct.
The university has not yet formally responded, and the case now pushes beyond the sport itself into the question of how much a high-profile program can be held accountable for what happened inside it. The former players are seeking financial damages, along with prevention training meant to keep similar behavior from being repeated, leaving Michigan to confront a deeply serious allegation that reaches back across nearly two decades of its hockey history. [Read more 🡒]