Derek Carr Comeback? Veteran QB Reportedly Open to NFL Return Under Right Circumstances
Just when we thought the quarterback carousel was slowing down, a familiar name might be jumping back into the mix. According to multiple NFL Network insiders, Derek Carr-who retired last year following a shoulder injury that required surgery-could be eyeing a return to the league.
Now, let’s be clear: Carr isn’t actively campaigning for a comeback. But if the right opportunity presents itself-think the right coaching staff, the right system-he’s reportedly open to suiting up again.
And here’s the kicker: he’s healthy. Fully recovered.
No limitations. That alone makes him one of the more intriguing names in what’s shaping up to be a fascinating offseason for quarterbacks.
What About the Saints?
Carr is still under contract with the New Orleans Saints, but a return to the Bayou seems unlikely. Tyler Shough is now in the picture, and the Saints appear committed to moving forward with their young signal-caller.
That means if Carr wants to play elsewhere, New Orleans would have to trade him. The door isn’t just ajar-it’s wide open.
Where Could Carr Land?
Let’s break down a few potential landing spots that have been floated, starting with the most realistic and working our way through the possibilities.
Minnesota Vikings: The Most Logical Fit
The Vikings are expected to add a veteran quarterback this offseason, and Carr checks a lot of boxes. He’s experienced, he’s a proven starter, and he could serve either as a mentor or a legitimate competitor to J.J.
McCarthy. Head coach Kevin O’Connell has a strong reputation for developing quarterbacks, and Minnesota offers Carr a realistic shot at meaningful playing time.
If he’s looking for a situation where he can compete and potentially lead a playoff-caliber team, this might be it.
Kansas City Chiefs: A Strategic Insurance Policy
This one’s a little more nuanced. Patrick Mahomes is the guy in Kansas City-no question there.
But after tearing his ACL in December, his Week 1 status is still up in the air. If the Chiefs want to play it safe and avoid rushing Mahomes back, bringing in a reliable veteran like Carr makes a lot of sense.
He wouldn’t be the long-term answer, but he could keep the ship steady in the early weeks and provide valuable depth for a team with Super Bowl aspirations. For Carr, it’s a chance to contribute to a contender and potentially rewrite the final chapter of his career with a ring in sight.
Las Vegas Raiders: Don’t Count on It
Yes, Carr and the Raiders have history. And yes, there’s a new regime in place, including Tom Brady as part of the ownership group.
But with Las Vegas locked in on drafting Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza with the No. 1 pick, it’s hard to see a reunion making sense for either side. Mendoza is expected to start right away, and Carr likely wants to go somewhere he can compete for a starting job-not serve as a placeholder.
A feel-good story? Sure.
A realistic option? Not so much.
What’s Next?
Carr’s potential return adds a compelling layer to an already unpredictable offseason. He’s a four-time Pro Bowler with over a decade of starting experience, and now that he’s healthy, he’s a name to watch-especially for teams looking for stability under center. Whether it’s a mentorship role, a bridge starter, or even a short-term insurance policy for a contender, Carr brings value.
Don’t expect a bidding war just yet. But if the right situation emerges-and it very well could-Derek Carr could be back in an NFL huddle sooner than anyone expected.