The edge that used to define Michigan State and Michigan feels harder to find these days.
Not because the game matters less. Not because the history disappeared. But because both programs have spent the last few years churning through coaches, players and expectations so fast that the rivalry has lost some of the personal heat that once made it combustible.
Five years ago, the matchup looked like it was headed for another stretch of real bite. Michigan State had finished 11-2 and won the Peach Bowl, while Michigan was 12-2, had taken the Big Ten title and reached the College Football Playoff semifinal. Mel Tucker had the Spartans moving in the right direction, and Jim Harbaugh had finally gotten Michigan over the Ohio State hump.
That version of the rivalry feels distant now.
The instability has been constant, and the transfer portal has only accelerated it. Both schools are on their third full-time head coach in four seasons, and the current leaders are still getting their bearings in a series they didn’t grow up inside. Jonathan Smith’s first brush with it in East Lansing made the point quickly.
“After experiencing that sucker, I will not forget that thing,” Smith said at his press conference the Monday after the 2024 game.
Michigan’s Kyle Whittingham is in a similar spot, a West Coast coach with no Big Ten background who spent two decades at Utah before taking the job.
“I don’t want to paint or come across as that rivalries aren’t important. They are,” Whittingham said at his Monday press conference.
“We don’t want to downplay it at all. I’m not trying to downplay it.
But still, when all said and done, you got to keep everything in perspective.”
That’s a very different tone from the old Mark Dantonio years, when his dislike for Michigan poured straight into the rivalry and gave it extra bite. Back then, the animosity had time to build. Now, the revolving door has made that kind of hatred almost impossible to sustain.
Roster turnover has only widened the gap. At Michigan State, senior linebacker Jordan Hall is one of the few players who has been in the program long enough to know what this game means across multiple seasons, and the Spartans have 62 new players on the roster this year.
Michigan has 44 newcomers. Altogether, that’s 106 new players between the two teams.
That kind of churn changes everything. It used to be that the rivalry could be handed down from class to class, with veterans teaching freshmen exactly what the game meant. Now, the learning curve is much steeper.
MSU senior defensive edge Kenny Soares Jr. described that process on Wednesday.
“There’s been a lot of guys who haven’t been around it, obviously, with the transfer portal here, so they’ve been giving us backstories and just learning how it all works out,” Soares said at Wednesday’s press conference. “Guys who’ve been here, people who’ve come back, and just looking forward to the game as alums, and just having us really realize that it’s not just about us.”
The old personal stakes are easier to spot in the memories than in the present. Kirk Cousins, then Michigan State’s quarterback, captured that feeling after beating Michigan in 2011 with Dantonio’s line about the winner and loser walking different streets. Cousins took it even further.
“For the rest of our life, we will walk the streets of this state,” Cousins said after beating Michigan in 2011. “This is why this rivalry is personal.
We’ve won four straight against them. I’ll walk the streets the rest of my life.”
That sort of language is rare now. And it’s hard for any rivalry to feel especially charged when both teams are fighting just to get back to relevance.
Michigan State has not had a winning season since 2021, and the conversation in East Lansing has shifted to bowl eligibility instead of anything bigger. Michigan still draws national attention, but even the 2023 national championship hasn’t carried them back to the playoff, despite the 12-team format.
This year has pushed that reality even harder. Michigan enters the rivalry game at 5-3 and closes with three straight ranked opponents. A 6-6 finish is in play, which would make this its worst regular season since 2014, not counting the six-game COVID-19 season in 2020.
The 119th meeting between Michigan State (2-6, 0-5 Big Ten) and Michigan (5-3, 2-3 Big Ten) kicks off at 7:30 p.m. Saturday at Michigan Stadium. The game will air on Peacock.
In Other News...
Michigan State Just Gave Pat Fitzgerald His First Defining Win
Michigan States 15-6 win over Michigan gave Pat Fitzgerald a signature moment early in his tenure, and it came in the kind of game that can tell you a lot about a programs direction. The Spartans had to piece things together through injuries and roster challenges, but they still found enough from Tommy Carr, Brandon Tullis, Chrishon McCray and a steady special teams effort to grind out a result that felt bigger than a single rivalry game.
For Fitzgerald, the value of the victory goes beyond the scoreboard. Michigan State did not just survive a difficult afternoon, it showed the sort of toughness and structure that coaches spend months trying to build, especially when the roster is stretched thin. A win like this can become a reference point for a new era, and the Spartans now have one to point to as they keep shaping what this team is supposed to look like. [Read more 🡒]
Mark Dantonio Had The Perfect Reaction To Michigan State's Rivalry Win
Michigan States rivalry win over Michigan landed as one of those results that instantly travels beyond the box score, especially with the Spartans pulling it off as a double-digit underdog. The game had the kind of defensive edge that tends to define this matchup, and for a program still measuring itself against its biggest in-state rival, it carried the sort of weight that goes well beyond one afternoon.
Mark Dantonio noticed. The former Michigan State coach took to social media to celebrate the upset, nodding back to his famous line about the rivalry and reminding everyone how deeply these games can resonate around East Lansing. Under current coach Pat Fitzgerald, the Spartans now have a victory that fits squarely into the programs larger culture, even if the conversation around it is still very much alive. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan Just Exposed A Bigger Problem Than Losing To Michigan State
Michigans 15-6 loss to Michigan State did more than flip the scoreboard in a rivalry game where the Wolverines were favored by two touchdowns. It put a spotlight on the kind of offensive unraveling that has followed Michigan through stretches of the 2026 season, with just 192 total yards, four turnovers and a ground game that was outperformed by the Spartans.
For Michigan State, the win was the cleanest possible answer to a game the Wolverines were expected to control, but the bigger takeaway for the maize-and-blue side is how many problems surfaced at once. The offense never found rhythm, the coaching decisions came under scrutiny and even special teams became part of the conversation, leaving Michigan with more to sort through than a single bad result. [Read more 🡒]