Michigan State’s search for a new athletic director has an obvious name sitting just down the road in Kalamazoo: Western Michigan AD Dan Bartholomae.
Bartholomae has been floated as a possible fit for the Spartans for good reason. He has a track record that checks a lot of the boxes MSU is likely to care about, and the move would not be impossible to pull off financially.
The biggest obstacle would be his buyout. Western Michigan extended Bartholomae through June 2031 last August, and his buyout is reportedly $5 million. For an AD coming from a Group of Six school, that is a steep number.
Michigan State, though, is positioned to help cover a chunk of that. The Spartans are set to receive $3.95 million in buyout money from Kentucky after the Wildcats hired J Batt away from MSU.
Batt’s original buyout was $5 million, though that number was supposed to fall to $2.5 million when president Kevin Guskiewicz originally accepted a job at Clemson. That clause never actually kicked in, but the two sides still worked toward the middle because of the unusual circumstances. Batt likely would not have been on the move at all if Guskiewicz had not taken the Clemson job.
If MSU used the full $3.95 million from Kentucky on Bartholomae, it would still need another $1.05 million to get the deal done. That is not a huge ask for a school like Michigan State, especially considering it paid a little more than $2 million to Georgia Tech to cover Batt’s buyout there last year.
Football will be one of the first places MSU looks when evaluating any candidate, and Bartholomae has already shown he is willing to make a decisive move there. Not long after arriving in Kalamazoo, he fired Tim Lester following a 5-7 season in 2022 and replaced him with Lance Taylor.
That hire was not an obvious slam dunk at the time. Western Michigan gave Taylor his first head-coaching job, and the early results were mixed.
He went 4-8 in his first season and 6-7 in Year 2. Last season, though, the Broncos took a major step forward, finishing 10-4 and winning their first MAC title since 2016, when P.J.
Fleck was the coach.
Bartholomae’s appeal is not limited to football decisions. Fundraising has become a major part of the AD job, and that has been another strong point during his run at Western Michigan.
The Broncos announced last week that they brought in a record $21.8 million in donations during FY26, with more than 3,800 unique donors. Western Michigan also says overall financial support for the athletic department has climbed 473% since Bartholomae arrived in 2022, while the number of unique donors has more than doubled.
The scale would change if he landed at Michigan State, but so would the resources. Bartholomae has already shown he can help drive the financial side of a mid-major department, which makes him an intriguing candidate for a Big Ten job.
He also has a direct connection to former MSU football coach Jonathan Smith, who was fired by Batt the day after the 2025 season finale. Bartholomae was the executive deputy AD and COO at Oregon State before moving to Western Michigan, and that stint overlapped with Smith’s time with the Beavers.
“Dan was vitally important to Oregon State football and the entire OSU athletic department during his time here,” Smith said about Bartholomae on the NCHC’s profile of Bartholomae. “His ability to understand the big picture and at the same time work closely with so many on the day-to-day makes him more than ready to lead an entire athletic department.”
Bartholomae worked at Oregon State from 2017 to 2022. Smith’s first season as head coach there was 2018. Before Oregon State, Bartholomae spent more than a decade at Pitt, where he worked heavily in compliance and eventually became deputy athletic director for internal affairs.
It adds up to a strong resume. Western Michigan has seen real success on the field, real growth in fundraising and record-setting results in the NCAA’s Academic Progress Rate metric. Michigan State would be a bigger stage, but Bartholomae has built a case that he could handle it.
In Other News...
Michigan State Just Got An Extra Reason To Dread Arkansas
Michigan States Thanksgiving Day matchup at Little Caesars Arena already had the look of a measuring-stick game, with ranked Arkansas coming in as a serious early-season test. Now the Spartans have one more layer to think about, because the Razorbacks will bring along Davion Thompson, a true freshman whose arrival on campus came sooner than expected after he reclassified from the 2027 class into 2026.
Thompson also adds a familiar recruiting wrinkle for Michigan State. He was once a major target for the Spartans before ultimately choosing Arkansas, and his presence gives this nonconference meeting a little extra edge for a program that knows how often these November games can linger beyond the final buzzer. [Read more 🡒]
Jaxon Kohler Could Force A Major Michigan State Rotation Decision
Jaxon Kohlers offseason has become one of the more interesting variables in Michigan States roster planning, because the Spartans have already moved as if his college career was winding down. Tom Izzo and his staff recruited new pieces with that assumption in mind, adding four freshmen and a transfer to help fill the frontcourt and overall depth chart, while also trying to keep the roster balanced for another run in the Big Ten.
Now Kohlers future is tied to the NCAAs new 5-in-5 rule, and the possibility of another season would give Michigan State a very different look than the one it has been building toward. A return would meaningfully boost the teams returning production and force a real rotation decision in East Lansing, but his playing location remains uncertain for now, leaving the Spartans to prepare for one version of the roster while keeping another in the back of their minds. [Read more 🡒]