Michigan State’s quarterback situation was supposed to give the offense a jolt. Instead, it keeps getting in the way.
Against Notre Dame, the Spartans leaned on a two-QB setup and still came away with a 27-10 loss. Sophomore Alessio Milivojevic handled most of the snaps, but the package for dual-threat quarterback Fancher was built to create a spark - and for one brief stretch, it did.
Fancher accounted for MSU’s only touchdown with a 15-yard run in the second quarter, pulling the Spartans within 17-10 at halftime. He also came close to throwing a touchdown pass, but his target dropped a wide-open ball in the end zone.
That’s the upside. The problem is what’s followed.
In last week’s 31-13 loss to Nebraska, MSU was already down 14-3 early in the second quarter and needed a clean response. The staff turned to Fancher to open the drive, and two plays later he threw an interception that gave Nebraska the ball at the MSU 15-yard line. He did not return to the game.
A similar sequence unfolded against Wisconsin, and it may have been the clearest example yet of how the rotation can disrupt the offense. Milivojevic was in rhythm, getting the snap, reading the defense and finding open receivers quickly.
MSU marched 43 yards in eight plays to the Wisconsin 32-yard line. Then Fancher came in.
That kind of switch is hard to justify when the offense is finally moving. Milivojevic loses his rhythm, and Fancher is asked to operate cold.
Designed quarterback runs have a place, but four straight plays with Milivojevic driving the offense is a different kind of gamble. That possession was arguably MSU’s sharpest of the day, and it might have ended in points if Milivojevic had stayed on the field.
The Spartans did get one red-zone trip before halftime, but that came mostly off two Wisconsin penalties that combined for 30 yards.
The bigger issue is whether the shuffling is helping Milivojevic grow or holding him back.
The raw numbers point in an uncomfortable direction. Milivojevic’s accuracy has ticked up, from 58% in his four starts last season to 62% through five starts this year.
But the rest of the production has gone the other way. He averaged about 247 yards per start last season and about 170 this season.
The touchdowns have dropped even harder: seven last year, three this year, and none since Week 2.
MSU’s quarterback room changed again before the game was over. Fancher left with an apparent right knee injury on the opening drive of the third quarter and did not return.
Later, with 7:50 left in the fourth quarter and the outcome already decided, true freshman Kayd Coffman made his first career appearance and directed the Spartans’ final two drives. Coffman was a four-star recruit out of high school according to 247’s composite rankings.
Afterward, Pat Fitzgerald made it clear there’s no shortcut here.
"Leave it here, walk out and get ready to go back to work on Monday; that's it," Fitzgerald said regarding what he takes away from the game.
"We're not there yet, it's obvious and we just got to keep working," Fitzgerald said. "You don't stop. You keep pounding that rock and eventually it will crack."
MSU is 2-3 and heads back to East Lansing for Homecoming against Illinois, which is 2-2. Kickoff is set for 3:30 p.m. Oct. 10 at Spartan Stadium, and the game will air on FS1.
In Other News...
Michigan State Suddenly Has Bigger Questions Than Just One Ugly Loss
The 31-3 loss to Wisconsin left Michigan State with more to sort through than a bad afternoon on the scoreboard. Joe Rossis defense drew scrutiny for how easily the game got away, but the offensive side may have created even more concern, with the Cam Fancher package not providing the spark the Spartans needed and the entire operation looking stuck far too often.
Cam Fanchers non-contact leg injury only adds another layer to the uncertainty. Michigan State now has to think about reshuffling its approach, and that could mean more touches for younger receivers and a fresh look at the play-calling, because the current formula is not giving the Spartans enough answers. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State Just Became Part Of An Awkward Rankings Story
Wisconsins win over Michigan State did more than tighten the Big Ten picture. It put the Badgers in line to crack the AP Top 25, adding another layer to a weekend that already figures to shake up the national poll and send a few familiar names sliding around the board. For the Spartans, it is another reminder of how one result can ripple well beyond a single box score.
The rankings are also expected to shift near the top, with changes looming among the top seven teams and Mississippi State likely to fall after its loss to Alabama. Add in a handful of other teams that should move based on recent performances, and this feels like one of those poll weeks where the AP voters have plenty to sort through, even before the debate around Michigan States place in the aftermath really starts. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State's Wisconsin Loss Exposed Problems Fans Can't Ignore
Michigan States latest loss to Wisconsin left plenty to sort through, and not much of it was comforting for a team still trying to find its footing. The Spartans had trouble controlling the line of scrimmage, couldnt generate enough from the passing game, and continued to come up short in the kinds of situations that decide close games, especially on third and fourth down.
There were a few encouraging signs to hang onto, including a strong punting effort and cleaner football overall with fewer penalties and no turnovers. Still, the bigger picture is hard to ignore: the defense had too many problems getting off the field, the offense lacked reliable production at wide receiver, and the issues that showed up in Madison are the kind that can linger if they are not fixed quickly. [Read more 🡒]