Michigan State has finally moved into the preseason top five, and the timing makes plenty of sense.
Jon Rothstein’s latest “Rothstein 45” has the Spartans ranked among the nation’s elite heading into the 2026-27 season, a jump that pushes them ahead of Michigan. For much of the offseason, Rothstein had Michigan State sitting just outside that tier, trailing teams like Arizona and Michigan. That changed in his newest rankings.
The shift comes at a moment when the two programs are headed in very different directions. Michigan just promoted Mike Boynton Jr. to replace Dusty May, who left for the Dallas Mavericks after two seasons in Ann Arbor. Michigan State, meanwhile, has kept most of its roster together.
That stability is a big reason Rothstein now has the Spartans in his top five. It’s also why the gap between the two schools looks wider now than it did earlier in the offseason.
Rothstein’s top five is:
Duke
Florida
Michigan State
Illinois
UConn
The Spartans landing at No. 3 lines up closely with the broader preseason conversation, though not everyone will have them in the exact same spot. Illinois has been the popular pick to lead the Big Ten entering the 2026-27 season, but Michigan State’s depth gives it a real case for the top spot in the league. Those two teams should spend most of the year battling for Nos. 1 and 2 in the conference, with Michigan lurking close behind.
There’s also a strong case that Rothstein’s list could have been even a little more aggressive in a few spots. Texas, Arizona, Michigan and Tennessee all sit in the mix behind that top tier, with the rankings around them still taking shape.
The bigger story, though, is Michigan State moving ahead of Michigan. That had been building for a while. Rothstein kept Michigan in the top five for weeks after the season, even as the Spartans appeared to have the better projected starting five and more depth.
Once Dusty May left for the NBA, the picture changed.
At that point, Michigan could no longer lean on reputation alone to stay ahead of a Michigan State team that looks loaded. Boynton is a capable coach, but he does not bring the same buzz as May, and that matters in a preseason ranking like this.
Now the contrast is clear: Tom Izzo has one of the deepest and most talented rosters he’s had in years, while Boynton is trying to get a talented but unfamiliar group to click fast. That kind of chemistry test can go sideways in a hurry.
If it does, Michigan State fans will be more than ready to point back to this ranking.
In Other News...
Michigan State Just Entered A Brutal Fight For An Elite Guard
Michigan State has jumped into the chase for Antonio Pemberton, a four-star point guard in the 2027 class who has quickly become one of the more coveted guards on the board. The Spartans offer adds another major name to a resume that already includes 20 scholarship offers, and it comes with the kind of profile that makes recruiting battles escalate fast: Pemberton is ranked No. 35 overall, sits among the top point guards nationally, and is the top player in Massachusetts.
The timing matters, too, because Michigan State is not entering this one alone. UCLA and Kansas have already shown interest after the Spartans made their move, turning what looked like a strong early offer into a much tougher national pursuit. Pemberton has been standing out in summer showcases with the efficiency and playmaking that have drawn comparisons to established college and pro guards, which means this recruitment figures to stay crowded for a while. [Read more 🡒]
Jeremy Fears Just Raised The Stakes For Michigan States Title Chase
Jeremy Fears Jr. is entering the season with a spotlight that usually follows the sports most polished stars, and the buzz around him says plenty about where Michigan State thinks it can go. The Spartans already know what he brings as a lead guard, but the broader college basketball conversation is starting to treat him as one of the most important returning players in the country, the kind of piece who can shape a title chase before Big Ten play even settles in.
What makes the stakes so interesting is how much of Fears next step still comes down to refinement, not reinvention. He has the kind of all-around game that can put him on major award lists and keep NBA scouts watching closely, but the difference between being a star college guard and a more complete pro prospect may come down to how much his outside shot grows. For Michigan State, that means his development is not just a personal storyline, it is one of the clearest indicators of how high this teams ceiling can rise. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State May Have Finally Found Its Answer At Center
Michigan States search for stability in the middle of its offensive line has led to a veteran with a proven track record. A redshirt senior who started every game for his previous program, he arrives with the kind of experience and consistency the Spartans have been trying to add up front, and his rsum includes major recognition at the FCS level.
The appeal goes beyond just filling a spot. He has been one of the more decorated centers in his league, and his arrival gives Michigan State a legitimate chance to settle a position that has been a concern. The only real question now is how quickly that production and poise translate once he steps into a Power Four huddle. [Read more 🡒]