Michigan State’s season has hit the point where the numbers are starting to tell the whole story.
After Saturday’s 31-3 loss at Wisconsin, the Spartans sit at 2-3 overall and 0-2 in Big Ten play, and they’ve now dropped three straight by at least three possessions. Through five games, the picture across all three phases is pretty clear: the offense has sunk to the bottom of the Power Four, the defense has held up better than the record suggests, and special teams has been the most dependable part of the operation.
The offense is in rough shape, and that’s putting it mildly. Michigan State is averaging just 305.6 yards per game, which ranks 126th in the FBS and makes it the lowest-ranked offense among the 68 Power Four teams. The Spartans are also putting up only 4.52 yards per play, again the worst mark among Power Four teams and fifth-worst in the entire FBS.
The scoring numbers are even uglier. Against Power Four competition, including Notre Dame, MSU has managed only 26 points in three games, a rate of 8.7 points per contest.
That’s the worst pace in the Power Four. In conference play, the Spartans have scored 16 points across two Big Ten games, which is 10 fewer than the next-closest team in the league, Maryland.
With seven games left, it’s hard to see an obvious fix. Michigan State no longer has a clear game-breaking weapon after star running back Cam Edwards was lost for the year, and quarterback Alessio Milivojevic’s limited mobility and average arm have narrowed the offense’s options. On top of that, it’s rare to see a receiver create much separation downfield.
That showed up again at Wisconsin. The Spartans had to grind for everything, and while they did avoid negative plays, it looked more like survival than progress. Milivojevic’s throws came out fast, with an average time to throw of 2.45 seconds - the quickest of his nine starts - but his 6.8-yard average depth of target was also the lowest of his time as a starter.
There wasn’t much juice anywhere in the passing game. Michigan State’s longest play against Wisconsin went for just 13 yards, and the season-long big-play count is just 11 plays of 20 yards or more. That ties the Spartans for the second-fewest in the FBS and leaves them with the fewest such plays among Power Four teams.
There’s no real debate about the grade here: it’s an F.
The defense has at least been more complicated. Injuries have taken a real toll, and Michigan State was missing three of its top five corners against Wisconsin.
It could have been four if Tre Bell hadn’t made it back from the injury he suffered during pregame warmups against Nebraska. Star linebacker Jordan Hall, the defense’s own quarterback, also missed the game.
Even with those absences, the defense has been serviceable by the numbers. Michigan State is giving up 23.2 points per game, which ranks 66th nationally, and 325.8 yards per game, which puts it 52nd in total defense. That’s far from dominant, but it’s nowhere near the level of collapse the offense has reached.
There have been some real positives too. Eli Coenen, the former Illinois transfer, has been a welcome addition at defensive tackle, and Ben Roberts has held up well next to him. Tyran Chappell, brought in from the FCS level this offseason, has been Michigan State’s best corner when available, and he looks like a must-keep player heading into the offseason.
Special teams has probably been the strongest phase of the bunch, even if it hasn’t been flawless. First-year special teams coordinator LeVar Woods may not have inherited an elite unit, but Michigan State has gotten solid work from kicker Liam Boyd and strong leg power from punter Rhys Dakin, who is averaging 49.5 yards per punt.
There have been issues, though. The Spartans have given up a few blocked kicks, and kick returner Kenneth Williams hasn’t been as productive as he was last year at Nebraska. He’s averaging 11.9 fewer yards per return this season, and while his average there was helped by a touchdown return a year ago, only one of his 11 returns this year has gone for more than 30 yards.
In Other News...
Michigan State Volleyball Just Passed A Big Early Big Ten Test
Michigan State volleyball kept its early Big Ten momentum rolling with a five-set win over USC at the Galen Center, a result that showed just how steady this group has been through the opening stretch of conference play. The Spartans improved to 13-1 overall and 3-1 in the league, and they did it with a balanced effort that included a .333 hitting percentage, a lead in kills and digs, and key production from senior standouts Karolina Staniszewska, Zora Hardison and Alanna Bankston.
For a team trying to establish itself in a deep conference, wins like this matter because they travel. Michigan State had to grind through a tight match on the road and came away with a victory over a USC team that entered at 7-7 overall and 1-3 in Big Ten play. It is still early, but the Spartans already look like a group that can win in different ways, and this one served as an important proof point before the schedule gets any tougher. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State Suddenly Has An Offense Problem It Can't Ignore
Michigan States trip to Wisconsin laid bare a growing issue the Spartans can no longer treat as a temporary slump. The 31-3 loss dropped them to 2-3 and exposed an offense that never found a rhythm, even as Dion Crawford tried to keep the defense active by leading the team in tackles. On the other side of the ball, the Spartans simply never threatened enough to make the game feel competitive.
Alessio Milivojevics struggles at quarterback have put more pressure on Nick Sheridans offense to find answers quickly, and the situation got even more complicated with backup Cam Fancher dealing with an injury. Joe Rossis defense has had to shoulder too much already, and the imbalance is forcing Michigan State to confront how much needs to change if it wants to stabilize the season before the margin for error disappears entirely. [Read more 🡒]
Kenneth Walker III Is Giving Michigan State Fans A New NFL Brag
Kenneth Walker IIIs first month in the NFL has given Michigan State fans a fresh reason to keep one eye on Sundays. Through the opening four games, the former Spartan has surged to the top of the league in rushing yards and yards per carry, turning himself into one of the early stories of the season and putting his name in some rare company.
His start has been so explosive that Pro Football Focus says it is the best rushing opening over the past 15 years, and he also owns a Chiefs franchise mark for production through four games. The bigger question now is how long he can keep this pace going, with a touchdown total that is already trending toward something eye-catching if the workload and efficiency hold up. [Read more 🡒]