Michigan State’s loss to Illinois had plenty of frustration built into it, but the moment that really lit the fuse came on a fourth-quarter onside kick that should have swung everything.
Down seven after a huge score, the Spartans put together a nearly perfect onside kick, and Samson Gash dove to come away with it right on the sideline. The officials huddled, though, and ruled the freshman receiver offsides.
The call was flat-out wrong.
This was called offsides by the officials, taking away Michigan State’s recovered onsides kick.
This was the fourth suspicious call (or no-call) going against MSU in this game. Just a stunning day for the refs in this MSU - Illinois game. pic.twitter.com/Mm2OXcYY5B
- Justin Thind (@JustinThind) October 10, 2026
At first glance, there may have been some reason for the confusion because Gash was well ahead of the rest of the kickoff unit, but the replay view told the real story: he was still behind the line of scrimmage when the ball was kicked. There wasn’t a legitimate offsides to be found there.
Pat Fitzgerald had seen enough. After the ruling, he went straight at the officials, jawing with them and firing up the crowd in the process. Then came the moment that caught everyone’s eye: Fitzgerald turned and appeared to flash the middle finger at the referees in a way that was subtle enough to leave room for debate, but not subtle enough to miss.
Pat Fitzgerald pic.twitter.com/0ruYLacI8E
- Ball Ridden Podcast (@BallRiddenPod) October 10, 2026
Some thought the gesture might have been aimed at Bret Bielema or the Illinois sideline, but it was clearly directed at the officials. A fine is coming, no doubt, but in the moment it matched the level of anger on the sideline.
And in the end, the call didn’t even decide the game. Michigan State still forced overtime, only to lose on a badly executed 2-point conversion try.
Pat Fitzgerald has every right to be upset
Michigan State spent the game fighting through a string of bad calls and missed calls, and the offsides penalty on Gash was the one that really pushed things over the edge.
Fitzgerald had every right to be furious. It was one of the worst calls Michigan State has been stuck with all season, and he made sure everyone knew it. He’ll apologize and take the fine, but in that moment, he said what a lot of MSU fans were thinking.
In Other News...
Michigan States Overtime Collapse Exposed A Bigger Problem
After digging out of a late hole to force overtime, Michigan State still left Champaign with a 38-37 loss to Illinois, a result that said as much about the Spartans fight as it did about their flaws. Alessio Milivojevic was better as the game went along, finishing with 196 yards and two touchdowns after a slow start, and the comeback to tie it at 31-31 showed a team willing to keep swinging even when the situation looked bleak.
The bigger issue was what Michigan State could not manufacture when it mattered most. The Spartans never recorded a sack or much meaningful defensive pressure, and even after getting themselves to overtime, they could not finish the job on a failed two-point conversion attempt. It was the kind of loss that leaves a coach encouraged by the response and uneasy about everything that made the comeback necessary in the first place. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State's Brutal Spiral Just Got Even More Frustrating
Michigan States skid deepened in a way that felt all too familiar Saturday, with a 38-37 overtime loss to Illinois extending the Spartans losing streak to four games and leaving them still looking for their first Big Ten win. Even so, the game followed a script that has become maddening for this team: a second-half rally, a chance to seize control late, and enough hope to make the ending sting even more.
The Spartans fought back after falling behind, but the game turned on a failed two-point conversion attempt after they scored in overtime, a missed chance that left them with nothing to show for the comeback. The frustration was compounded by a defense already stretched thin, as Michigan State lost key linebackers and corners during the game, adding another layer of concern to a season that keeps finding new ways to get harder. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State Opened Its No. 3 Season Looking Every Bit The Part
Michigan State wasted little time looking like a team built to handle its lofty expectations, rolling past Northern Michigan 6-2 in its regular-season opener at Munn Ice Arena. Sophomore forward Anthony Romani set the tone with two goals and an assist, and the Spartans power play did its part too, cashing in on half its chances as the home crowd got an early look at a group that seems intent on turning preseason buzz into something more tangible.
Freshman goaltender Joshua Ravensbergern also gave the night some extra polish with 16 saves in his debut win, a promising start for a lineup trying to blend familiar contributors with new faces. Openers rarely tell the whole story, but this one offered a clean snapshot of why Michigan State entered the season with so much attention: depth, special teams and enough firepower to make mistakes costly for the opponent. [Read more 🡒]