Kyle Whittingham was brought in to steady the program, but 11 months into the job, the fit looks shakier by the week.
Michigan’s 5-3 record is disappointing on its own. The bigger issue is that the season has not even unfolded the way many expected around the schedule.
Oregon has fallen apart, Ohio State will be without its starting quarterback for the rest of the regular season, Indiana has struggled to score, Oklahoma has not lived up to its projection, and Penn State has also unraveled. What looked like a brutal path has opened up, and Michigan still hasn’t taken advantage.
That’s why the season’s best moment, at least in Whittingham’s view, stands out so much. After a 13-6 overtime loss to Indiana, he tried to frame the result as a positive.
“If that’s a number six team in the country, then we’re a pretty good football team even though we’re sitting at 4-3,” Whittingham said.
Then came another eyebrow-raising comment a few weeks later. On his weekly radio show, Whittingham told Jon Jansen that Michigan’s 28-21 escape against Rutgers was actually enjoyable to watch.
"Yeah, I come in early Sunday and watch it all by myself.," Whittingham told Jon Jansen. "The entire game, offense, defense, special teams, back to back to back and it was a pleasurable game to watch on Sunday morning. So yeah, I give myself a couple of hours after that and then on to the next.”
That kind of reaction doesn’t match what Michigan expects from its coach. Beating Rutgers, especially by a single score, is not supposed to be the standard. Michigan was favored by double digits, Rutgers was down to a backup quarterback, and the Scarlet Knights completed only four passes if the two-point conversion to tie the game in the fourth quarter is counted.
Michigan should have handled that game comfortably. Instead, the same issues that have followed the team all season showed up again. Tommy Carr’s heroics ended up being the thing that kept Whittingham from facing even tougher questions afterward.
The comments have piled up: the moral victory talk after Indiana, the remark that Michigan State is not the biggest rivalry during game week, and now the claim that a narrow win over Rutgers was pleasurable. That’s not how the job works in Ann Arbor.
There are different expectations at Michigan than there are at Utah, and that matters. A win over a bottom-feeder might be acceptable elsewhere.
At Michigan, it isn’t supposed to be celebrated. Jim Harbaugh even looked visibly annoyed during a 78-0 blowout of Rutgers in October 2016, and that reaction is much closer to the standard than anything Whittingham has said lately.
Michigan has had coaches who couldn’t handle the job, from Brady Hoke to Rich Rodriguez. Sherrone Moore was a disaster for multiple reasons, and the hope was that Whittingham’s discipline and track record would keep the program closer to the Harbaugh era than the Hoke era.
Right now, it looks much closer to the latter.
Lose on Saturday to Michigan State, and there may be no future left for Whittingham to point toward.
In Other News...
Michigan States Best Upset Hope Looks Brutal Against Michigan
Michigan State heads into its Big Ten rivalry game against Michigan with the kind of profile that usually keeps an underdog alive, even in a hostile setting. Both teams have struggled to find much rhythm on offense this season, which has helped turn this matchup into something closer to a grind than a showcase, and the Spartans can at least point to a defense that has kept them in games.
The challenge is that Michigan brings the better overall form and the betting market reflects it, with the Wolverines installed as a 13.5-point favorite. Under the lights at the Big House, this shapes up as a physical, competitive night where field position and toughness could matter as much as any big-play threat, and Michigan State will need its best version just to make the upset conversation real. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State Heads Into Michigan Week With A Major Roster Concern
Michigan States first Big Ten availability report for Michigan week brought a familiar dose of uncertainty, with quarterback Alessio Milivojevic and safety Devin Vaught both listed as questionable for the rivalry game. The Spartans also ruled out 13 players for the matchup, a list that includes key starters Ben Roberts and Jaziun Patterson, leaving the roster thinner than it would like heading into one of the most demanding weeks on the calendar.
Pat Fitzgerald has already pointed to the significance of the rivalry and the work that goes into preparing for it, and now that preparation has to account for a long injury list as well. For Michigan State, the challenge is not just the emotion of the game, but figuring out how to line up with so many pieces potentially unavailable when the spotlight is at its brightest. [Read more 🡒]
Michigan State Faces Its First Real Test On A Quick Turnaround
Michigan State opened the season with a comfortable 96-59 win over Quinnipiac, but the real rhythm test comes fast. The Spartans have only a two-day window to reset before Thursdays game against Toledo, a matchup that should tell Tom Izzo a lot more about where his team stands early in the year.
Izzo pointed to the short turnaround as part of the challenge, especially with a game that figures to demand more from Michigan State than its opener did. The Spartans also expect Jesse McCulloch back after he missed the first game with a minor concussion, giving the frontcourt another piece as the schedule starts to tighten. [Read more 🡒]