The question hanging over the Miami Marlins this offseason is the same one that keeps coming back every winter: have they done enough to make players want to come here?
For a long stretch of the franchise’s history, the answer has been no. That’s been easy to understand.
Winning and stability matter, and the Marlins have rarely offered either in a way that would make free agents comfortable. Add an empty ballpark to the mix, and Miami has often been a tough sell.
That’s where the idea of the “Marlins Tax” comes in. It’s the reality that Miami has often had to pay more than market value just to land players who may not even be above-average bets. In other words, the club gets hit twice when it goes shopping in free agency.
The big question now is whether that era is finally over. It may end up defining the entire offseason.
There is at least a real argument that the Marlins have turned a corner. They’ve improved for three straight seasons, and the expectation around baseball is that the trend should keep going in 2027.
The atmosphere around the organization under team president Peter Bendix has been positive, even with Bruce Sherman still owning the club. Sherman has also earned some credit for investing in the spring training facility and the Dominican Academy.
Miami has a young core and a strong farm system, and there’s plenty there to sell.
The bigger question is whether players now view South Florida the way they view St. Petersburg - as a smart organization that wants to win.
Even with that progress, the answer still feels like no for now. The Tax is still in place.
Payroll remains the biggest issue, and the Marlins just finished another season near the bottom in spending. Fair or not, they’re still judged differently than the Rays, and that won’t change until Miami has a real run of playoff appearances to point to.
There’s also the matter of how players see the club’s unusual recent approaches, including calling pitches from the dugout and using starters as relievers on pitch design days. To one person, that looks like innovation.
To another, it looks like penny-pinching.
Still, there are two things that could change the conversation fast.
The first is extensions. One major extension could go a long way toward convincing players that Miami is serious about competing year after year.
Putting real money into the core would send a message that the window is open. A pitcher would like having Joe Mack behind the plate.
A player would like sharing a clubhouse with Sandy Alcantara or a talent like Eury Perez.
The second is the wild card: do players think salary reform is coming to MLB?
If they do, Miami suddenly looks a lot more like the Dolphins, Heat, and Panthers, with sunshine and no income tax to pitch free agents. In that world, the Marlins Tax disappears.
If they don’t, then Miami remains only a maybe - perhaps a better option than Pittsburgh, but not enough to erase the skepticism. Until the Marlins prove they can be counted on to compete, the Tax will stay attached.
In Other News...
Joe Girardi Gave The Marlins Hope They Couldn't Hold Onto
On Nov. 15, 2006, Joe Girardi was recognized as the National League Manager of the Year after steering the Florida Marlins through a season that looked far more promising than the final record suggested. The club finished 78-84, but with a roster built around several rookies and future stars, it stayed in the wild card conversation and managed to recover from a rough start by playing its best baseball down the stretch.
Girardis lone season in Florida ended up feeling like a glimpse of what the Marlins might become rather than a foundation they could keep building on. The teams youthful core gave the franchise reason to believe it had found something sustainable, but the situation around Girardi never settled into the kind of stability that would let that momentum carry forward. [Read more 🡒]
Otto Lopez Just Forced A Bigger Marlins Decision
Otto Lopezs breakout season has turned him from a useful piece into one of the more interesting names on Miamis roster, and it did not take long for other clubs to notice. After a strong 2026 campaign in which he finished third in the National League batting race and led the league in hits, Lopez has become the kind of player who can change the conversation around a front office, especially for a Marlins team still sorting out its long-term direction.
The latest wrinkle is less about whether Lopez can help Miami and more about how long the club can keep him in place. The Marlins are weighing a team-friendly extension that could buy out his arbitration years and potentially push deeper into his future, a sign they value him as more than a short-term asset. For a team that has spent plenty of time balancing present needs against future control, Lopez now sits at the center of a much bigger decision. [Read more 🡒]
Miguel Rojas Got The Miami Farewell Marlins Fans Wont Forget
Miguel Rojas closed out a 21-year professional baseball career over the weekend at loanDepot park, and for Marlins fans, it came in the kind of setting that fit his Miami story. The Choque de Gigantes exhibition series gave the longtime Marlins infielder a final stage in the city where he spent eight seasons, with the ballpark turning the moment into more than just another farewell.
Rojas also leaves the game with a resume that includes back-to-back World Series championships with the Dodgers in 2024 and 2025, but his connection to Miami has always been the thread that mattered most here. The tribute around his final game carried added meaning because of the people and causes tied to it, giving his last night in a uniform a personal weight that went well beyond the box score. [Read more 🡒]
