Riddle me this, Marlins fans: what do Tim Anderson, Pete Fairbanks, John King, Christopher Morel, Chris Paddack, Cal Quantrill, Austin Slater and Eric Wagaman all have in common?
The answer is simple enough. Every one of them was signed to a one-year deal.
That group tells the whole story of Miami’s free-agent approach since Peter Bendix took over. The Marlins have not handed out a two-year contract to a free agent since Jean Segura in 2023. And if Bruce Sherman still has a sour taste from that one, it’s not hard to see why.
Go back a little further and the picture doesn’t improve much. Of Miami’s last five multi-year free-agent signings, Anthony Bass and Jorge Soler are tied for the best return at 1.8 Marlins WAR apiece.
Corey Dickerson at least gave the club positive value. Segura’s best contribution may have been that he became part of the Josh Bell trade that helped Miami get to the playoffs in 2023, though Bell then exercised his $16.5 million option for 2024, so ownership probably doesn’t look at that sequence quite the same way.
And then there’s Avisail Garcia, whose Marlins tenure has already been written about enough to fill several depressing books.
So yes, the hesitation makes sense. Miami has plenty of reasons to be wary of going beyond a single season.
But that caution has also boxed the team in. One-year offers only reach a certain level of player, and the Marlins have not exactly been striking gold in that lane. The result is a free-agency strategy that narrows the market before negotiations even really begin.
That’s why this offseason feels different. The big question is whether Miami finally gets comfortable going an extra year.
There’s a case for it. Next year’s club is expected to compete, and that alone should matter.
On top of that, there’s the possibility that MLB gets a salary cap, which would force Miami to open up payroll anyway. If the money has to go up, the logic is straightforward: why not use that flexibility to add a second year when it helps get a deal done?
That doesn’t mean the Marlins need to chase the top of the market. It just means they shouldn’t slam the door shut the moment a solid player asks for a second season, or even an option year.
Among active Marlins, only Sandy Alcantara is under guaranteed contract for 2027. Nobody is locked in for 2028. If there was ever a time for Miami to be a little bolder with term, this is it.
The challenge now is not just changing the approach. It’s making the right call on the right player.
In Other News...
Marlins Face A Costly Closer Decision That Could Shape Their Winter
The Marlins are expected to spend part of their offseason trying to stabilize the back end of the bullpen, and the closer market already offers a couple of different paths. Adrian Morejon and Alex Vesia have both surfaced as possible free-agent fits, giving Miami a choice between a more established arm with a bigger price tag and a more modest alternative who could come at a lower cost and shorter commitment.
Morejons profile comes with the added complication of draft pick compensation, which only raises the stakes for a front office trying to balance urgency with flexibility. Vesia looks like the cleaner financial play, but the decision is about more than just dollars, since Miami needs a reliable ninth-inning answer after its 2026 struggles and will have to decide how aggressively it wants to chase one this winter. [Read more 🡒]
Marlins Are Building A Bigger South Florida Impact Than Fans Realize
The Marlins have been working to deepen their footprint in South Florida in ways that go beyond the box score, and their latest effort reached two of the areas most familiar high school programs. Along with the Players Alliance, the club donated more than $62,000 worth of baseball equipment to student-athletes at Booker T. Washington and Miami Senior High, providing bats, gloves, shoes, helmets and training gear as part of a broader community push.
The equipment drop is one piece of an ongoing partnership that already includes a pregame mentorship program for the student-athletes, giving the initiative a longer runway than a one-day gesture. For a team trying to connect with the next generation of baseball players in its own backyard, the real significance is in how those relationships keep building, and in what comes next for the students involved. [Read more 🡒]
