The Marlins still haven’t opened extension talks with Sandy Alcantara, even though the fit is obvious and the interest appears to run both ways.
According to the Miami Herald’s Barry Jackson, Miami has not yet approached Alcantara about a new deal. That comes after the club picked up his $21MM option at the end of last month and made clear it has no intention of trading him. Alcantara is 31, coming off a strong rebound season, and the sides are aligned on the bigger picture even if the formal negotiations haven’t begun.
The timing matters. Once the current CBA expires on December 1, a lockout is expected, and that would freeze offseason business until MLB and the Players Association hammer out a new agreement.
If that lockout stretches like the one five years ago, Spring Training could get pushed back and possibly shortened. Most players also don’t want extension talks hanging over them once the regular season starts, which leaves only about a week and a half before the shutdown and whatever time comes after Spring Training to get something done before the unofficial deadline.
Alcantara’s track record gives Miami plenty of reason to move quickly. He owns a 3.69 ERA across 1,289 1/3 career innings, with all but 8 1/3 of those frames coming in a Marlins uniform.
From 2019-22, he was the definition of a workhorse, leading all qualified starters with 673 2/3 innings pitched. He also ranked 13th among qualified starters in both ERA, at 3.07, and ground ball rate, at 50.4%, during that stretch.
His peak came over the 2021-22 seasons, when he piled up 10.2 fWAR. In 2022, he posted a 2.28 ERA and struck out 207 batters in 32 starts on the way to a unanimous NL Cy Young award.
The road got bumpier after that. Alcantara’s ERA jumped to 4.14 in 2023, though he still logged more than 180 innings and kept the ground balls coming.
He finished that season on the injured list with a flexor strain, which eventually led to Tommy John surgery and cost him the entire 2024 season. He returned healthy in 2025, but the rust showed in a 5.36 ERA.
This year looked much more like the version Miami has been waiting for. Alcantara threw 214 innings and finished with a 3.86 ERA, a 41.9% ground ball rate, a 17.1% strikeout rate, and a 6.6% walk rate.
The ground ball and strikeout numbers were career lows over a full season, but the walk rate stood out, ranking in the 81st percentile according to Statcast. His sinker and cutter each carried a +12 Run Value.
He led all qualified starters in innings and also made three relief appearances, collecting three saves for Miami in the stretch run.
Owner Bruce Sherman has been vocal about wanting Alcantara in Miami for the long haul. “ He means everything, ” Sherman told the Herald’s Jordan McPherson in July.
“ He’s our franchise icon, and for us, I look forward to many years in the future and what this all becomes. ” Alcantara echoed that sentiment two months ago, telling Kevin Barral of Fish on First and others that he wants to remain a Marlin for life.
His current contract, including the club option, is worth $75MM over six years, and the next one figures to go beyond that. In August, MLBTR’s Steve Adams projected an extension in the four- or five-year range with an average annual value of $26-30MM. That would be a bigger investment than anything the Marlins have done for a free-agent pitcher; their largest such deal remains the five-year, $80MM contract they gave Wei-Yin Chen more than a decade ago.
Miami would be paying for more than just innings if it gets this done. Heading into 2027, Alcantara is the veteran anchor of a rotation that also includes Eury Pérez, Max Meyer, Janson Junk, and Ryan Gusto.
Meyer just turned in a breakout season, while Pérez recovered from a rough start to post a 3.21 ERA and 26.0% strikeout rate over his final 19 starts. Those two and Alcantara give the Marlins a solid top three, though the club could still add another arm or two for the back end.
So far, Miami has shown interest in Patrick Sandoval in free agency and was also in on Dustin May before he signed a three-year, $52.5MM deal with the White Sox.
In Other News...
Xavier Edwards Faces One Big Marlins Question After Late Slide
Xavier Edwards season has already taken a sharp turn for the Marlins, and not in the way anyone around the club wanted. The left thumb injury he suffered on Aug. 30 sent him to the 10-day injured list, and although he briefly returned, the setback that followed forced him back into shutdown mode. Since then, he has been working through physical therapy rather than surgery, trying to get his hand right while the year keeps slipping away.
Edwards has also had to process what the 2026 season looked like from start to finish, and the contrast has been clear. He described a strong first half before injury and fatigue made the second half far more difficult, which leaves Miami with one lingering question as it looks ahead: how much of Edwards can it count on once he is fully healthy again? For a player whose value is tied so closely to his speed, rhythm and availability, the answer matters well beyond the final weeks of this season. [Read more 🡒]
Marlins Kept Their Young Core Together Now The Real Test Starts
The Marlins spent the latest roster deadline making a clear statement about continuity, tendering contracts to every arbitration-eligible player for the 2027 season. That group includes Eury Perez, Otto Lopez, Xavier Edwards and several others, a move that keeps Miamis young core intact as the club continues to build around its most controllable pieces. Salaries still have to be worked out later in the offseason, but the important part for now is that the organization avoided any surprises with players it views as part of the next wave.
Miami also reached a one-year agreement with left-hander Andrew Nardi, even with his expected absence after elbow surgery. It is the kind of transaction that reflects both patience and planning, preserving a useful arm for the future while the club navigates the present. For a team trying to turn promise into something more durable, keeping this many names in the fold is the easy part. Figuring out how they fit together once the season starts is where the real test begins. [Read more 🡒]
