The Dodgers have spent the better part of three years living with the same question: how long can a veteran-heavy roster keep holding up before age starts to bite?
That’s the backdrop for a hypothetical trade idea from Jim Bowden of The Athletic, who laid out a deal that would send Miami Marlins infielder Xavier Edwards to Los Angeles in exchange for prospects Mike Sirota and Chase Harlan. The fit, at least on paper, is straightforward: the Dodgers get younger and more athletic at second base, while Miami adds two prospects to its system.
“I would like to see the Dodgers upgrade second base this offseason, with the goal of getting younger and more athletic, and a trade for Edwards would accomplish just that,” Bowden wrote. “Edwards is just 27 and has three more years of team control.
He is coming off a 3 WAR season with a .360 on-base percentage and 21 stolen bases. He runs well and controls the strike zone.”
Bowden also explained why the Marlins might listen if a package like that were offered.
“Sirota may be ready to contribute at the major-league level by midseason, while Harlan is likely two years away but would add significantly to the Marlins’ prospect cabinet.”
Edwards would bring speed to the table right away. He ranked in the 76th percentile in sprint speed in 2026, per Baseball Savant, and has averaged about 26 stolen bases over the last three seasons. He also doesn’t give away many at-bats, sitting in the 92nd percentile in squared-up percentage, 89th percentile in strikeout percentage, and 84th percentile in whiff rate.
But the question is whether that profile justifies the kind of prospect haul this deal would require.
Edwards doesn’t bring much power, with just 10 home runs combined over the last three seasons, and his defensive numbers are not especially strong either. He ranks in the 24th percentile in range and the 4th percentile in arm strength.
Sirota, meanwhile, is viewed as one of the Dodgers’ top prospects and one of the better outfield prospects in the sport. Harlan also had a strong year, hitting 14 home runs with a .298 batting average and a .912 OPS.
For that reason, the answer to this proposal is simple: the Dodgers would be hard-pressed to move both players for Edwards.
In Other News...
Xavier Edwards Faces One Big Marlins Question After Late Slide
Xavier Edwards season has already taken a sharp turn for the Marlins, and not in the way anyone around the club wanted. The left thumb injury he suffered on Aug. 30 sent him to the 10-day injured list, and although he briefly returned, the setback that followed forced him back into shutdown mode. Since then, he has been working through physical therapy rather than surgery, trying to get his hand right while the year keeps slipping away.
Edwards has also had to process what the 2026 season looked like from start to finish, and the contrast has been clear. He described a strong first half before injury and fatigue made the second half far more difficult, which leaves Miami with one lingering question as it looks ahead: how much of Edwards can it count on once he is fully healthy again? For a player whose value is tied so closely to his speed, rhythm and availability, the answer matters well beyond the final weeks of this season. [Read more 🡒]
Marlins Kept Their Young Core Together Now The Real Test Starts
The Marlins spent the latest roster deadline making a clear statement about continuity, tendering contracts to every arbitration-eligible player for the 2027 season. That group includes Eury Perez, Otto Lopez, Xavier Edwards and several others, a move that keeps Miamis young core intact as the club continues to build around its most controllable pieces. Salaries still have to be worked out later in the offseason, but the important part for now is that the organization avoided any surprises with players it views as part of the next wave.
Miami also reached a one-year agreement with left-hander Andrew Nardi, even with his expected absence after elbow surgery. It is the kind of transaction that reflects both patience and planning, preserving a useful arm for the future while the club navigates the present. For a team trying to turn promise into something more durable, keeping this many names in the fold is the easy part. Figuring out how they fit together once the season starts is where the real test begins. [Read more 🡒]
Marlins Face Growing Pressure With Sandy Alcantaras Future Unsettled
Sandy Alcantaras future remains one of the more important questions hanging over the Marlins as the club moves through the offseason. Miami already picked up his club option, keeping the right-hander in place for now, but there has still been no movement toward a longer-term deal despite mutual interest from both sides. For a pitcher who has been central to the organizations plans, the lack of extension talks stands out.
Alcantaras comeback from Tommy John surgery has added another layer to the situation, with his return across 2025 and 2026 bringing mixed results as he worked back into form. The timing is tricky, too, with the possibility of an MLB lockout looming and making any negotiation window feel even narrower. For the Marlins, it leaves a key decision unresolved at a moment when clarity would go a long way. [Read more 🡒]
