Agustín Ramírez once looked like one of the Marlins’ cleaner answers for the future. Now he’s the kind of player Miami has to stop and really sort through.
The organization spent years piling up young talent, and as more of it reaches the majors, not everyone is going to find an easy lane. Ramírez is running into that reality head-on, even though his profile still carries real upside.
Miami got him from the New York Yankees in the 2024 Jazz Chisholm Jr trade, and for a stretch it looked like he could become a fixture in the rebuild. He showed enough to hint at being an everyday contributor, with offensive upside and the ability to help on defense. But less than two years after his MLB debut, his path with the club is suddenly a lot less clear.
A big reason is Joe Mack.
When Miami promoted Mack in May, it came the same day Ramírez was sent back to Triple-A Jacksonville. That move made sense based on performance.
Ramírez was struggling on both sides of the ball, while Mack immediately gave the team something it badly wanted: steady production behind the plate. He quickly became part of Miami’s present and future, and that created a problem for Ramírez.
Catcher was always Ramírez’s clearest route to playing time, but it was his bat that made him interesting. The issue now is that Miami has a catcher in Mack, and Ramírez is still trying to prove enough offensively to force the issue elsewhere.
When the Marlins brought him back in August, they started looking at other spots. He saw some time at first base and also spent time back at catcher. But changing positions may not be the whole answer.
Miami’s lineup already includes Kyle Stowers, Owen Caissie, and Griffin Conine, and that group limits the number of openings elsewhere. There may be the occasional look at designated hitter, but Ramírez does not appear strong enough there yet to count on it as a regular path.
The bat, then, has to carry more weight.
That’s where the uncertainty deepens. Ramírez flashed real power as a rookie, but 2026 did not bring the same kind of production. In 72 games this season, he hit .235 with five home runs, 24 RBI and a .672 OPS.
If he’s not going to separate himself defensively, then the offense has to climb. So far, the Marlins have seen the raw tools, but not the kind of consistency that locks down a big league job.
That said, Miami does not need to rush into a decision. Ramírez is only 25, and the club still controls him through 2031. There’s no pressure to force a move, and keeping him around as a depth option while he develops is still on the table.
At the same time, the Marlins have to consider whether another team would value him more than Miami can in its current roster picture. If the front office decides another need deserves priority, Ramírez could become a trade piece instead of part of the long-term core.
For now, there’s no sign the Marlins are actively shopping him. But the question is clearly there, and it’s one Miami will likely have to answer this offseason.
In Other News...
Marlins Prospect Max Williams Is Giving Fans A Reason To Watch AFL
Max Williams has already given Marlins fans a reason to keep one eye on the Arizona Fall League this fall. After missing the first few months of his first full professional season with an injury, the 2026 prospect returned on July 9 and wasted no time making noise, launching a home run in his first at-bat back. From there, he climbed through Single-A, High-A and Double-A, turning a short season into a fast-moving introduction to the kind of impact bat Miami has been hoping to develop.
Across 48 games, Williams hit .326 with 15 home runs and 10 doubles, production that stands out even before the league context kicks in. Now he is getting another run of valuable reps in the AFL, with offseason work set to continue at the Marlins Jupiter Academy. For a club always looking for the next wave of talent, Williams is becoming one of the more intriguing names worth tracking into the winter. [Read more 🡒]