The Marlins are asking Agustín Ramírez to grow into a new kind of utility role, and they’re starting at first base.
After moving Liam Hicks in a trade with the Rays, Miami recalled Ramírez to fill the open roster spot. But the plan goes beyond simply plugging in a catcher. President of baseball operations Peter Bendix said the club wants Ramírez getting reps at first while still keeping him in the mix behind the plate.
“We’re not taking away the catching,” Bendix said. “We’re trying to add versatility, really put him into a similar type of role that Liam held, except as a right-handed bat, maybe somebody that complements the rest of our lineup.
Having the presence of Gus in addition to Joe Mack was another important fact we considered when trading away Liam. To be able to bring up Gus from Triple-A, slide him into a similar type of role as Liam.
We need right-handed hitters. We know Gus is somebody that can hit.
We know that the catching has gotten better.”
Ramírez does have some first-base experience, but it’s a tiny sample and it’s old. While in the Yankees’ system, he played one game there in the Complex League in 2021, then 19 Double-A games across 2023-24 and seven Triple-A games in 2024. Since Miami acquired him in the Jazz Chisholm Jr. trade in the summer of 2024, he has only worked as a catcher for the Marlins.
The organization has kept him there despite limited praise for his defense. He opened this season in the majors and shared catching duties with Hicks before Joe Mack forced his way into the picture and pushed Ramírez back to the minors.
Mack has only been in the big leagues for a few months, but he has looked like the catcher of the future, with 11 home runs and strong defensive grades through 69 games. Before his promotion, he was viewed as one of the top catching prospects in the sport.
That confidence in Mack helped make Hicks movable. Miami sent him to Tampa Bay for a three-prospect return: third baseman Brayden Taylor, shortstop Adrian Santana and right-hander Jacob Kisting. Now the Marlins want to see whether Ramírez can take on Hicks’ old job description - some catching, some first base and some designated hitter work.
Offensively, the gap is real right now. Hicks was hitting .282/.363/.432 with a 119 wRC+ before the deal.
Ramírez owns a .230/.293/.399 line and an 89 wRC+ in 721 major league plate appearances. In Triple-A this year, he has hit .254/.332/.427 with a 101 wRC+.
He has shown more in the minors before, including a .267/.358/.487 line and a 134 wRC+ in 2024.
If that version of Ramírez shows up, it could help Miami balance out a lineup that already leans left-handed, with Kyle Stowers, Owen Caissie, Griffin Conine, Jakob Marsee and Mack among that group. Stowers has recently been handling first base on a regular basis, and his numbers against lefties have made the platoon picture pretty clear: a career .208/.289/.330 line versus southpaws, and .169/.244/.286 this year.
Hicks had been covering some of those matchups, though he was not especially strong against lefties either. Mack, meanwhile, has hit .175/.233/.275 without the platoon edge.
In theory, Ramírez could split time with Mack, but his glove may keep that from becoming the main setup. Brian Navarreto is also a right-handed bat and a steadier defender, which makes him a cleaner option in that spot. If Ramírez can handle first base well enough, though, he could still carve out at-bats on the short side of a platoon with Stowers.
That part is not happening right away. Manager Clayton McCullough said the club is still easing into the idea and won’t force a timetable.
“What that looks like and when he may play, we’re not sure,” McCullough said. “Or even if he will.
We’ve come to that point now where we think it’ll be a good time to go explore that for him and for us. So he’s up for that, and we’ll see how the transition goes.
There won’t be any type of an artificial timeline on if and when Gus gets into a game at first base. I think we’ll let it organically just happen, and until then, he is certainly someone who will help strengthen our bench on days he’s not starting as left-handed pitchers come in.”
For Miami, it’s a move with a clear upside if it clicks. Ramírez could end up filling the same general role Hicks had, only with a right-handed bat that better fits the roster. He still has work to do at the plate and at first base, but if he settles in, the Marlins could come out of the trade with a cleaner lineup fit and a stronger farm system.
In Other News...
Marlins Suddenly Face A Tough Owen Caissie Decision
After dropping the opener of their series against the Los Angeles Angels, the Marlins are still sorting through the kind of midseason lineup question that can quickly turn into a bigger issue. Owen Caissie has been part of that conversation after a difficult stretch at the plate in August, a slump that has left the team looking for a way to get him back on track without letting the skid linger too long.
Manager Clayton McCullough has reasons to be patient, but the clock on an offensive reset is always moving in a place like Miami, where every at-bat can shape the next decision. A breather may be part of the answer, and a more drastic move is at least on the table, but the larger concern is straightforward: Caissie needs to find his swing again before this starts to affect more than one roster spot. [Read more 🡒]
Marlins Keep Paying For One Costly Habit In Close Games
The Marlins had the kind of night that has become too familiar in tight games: plenty of traffic on the bases, more hits than the opponent, and not enough to show for it when the final chance arrived. They out-hit the Angels, but leaving 13 runners on base made the missed opportunities hard to ignore, especially with the game still in reach deep into the ninth.
Miami has been one of the major league leaders in outs made on the bases this season, and this one fit the same frustrating pattern. Manager Clayton McCullough still endorsed the aggressive approach, even with the late out at the plate, which leaves the Marlins balancing the value of pressure with the cost of coming up empty in a game they could have stolen. [Read more 🡒]