Florida State left Hard Rock Stadium with the same record it arrived with, but not the same conversation.
The Seminoles’ double-overtime loss to No. 3 Miami hardly changed the standings, yet it may have changed the temperature around Mike Norvell. After a week in which his future looked as shaky as it has all season, FSU played with enough fight on Saturday night to make a coaching change feel less urgent, at least for the moment.
That matters because the noise around Norvell had gotten loud after last week’s loss to Louisville. With Florida State mired in another disappointing season, some were already treating his exit like a formality, even with a buyout that remains a major obstacle.
But against Miami, the Seminoles didn’t look like a team checked out on its coach. They looked invested, energized and stubborn.
They also came heartbreakingly close to flipping the whole story.
Florida State went toe-to-toe with one of the nation’s best teams and pushed the rivalry game into double overtime before falling 43-35. For a program searching for signs of life, that was enough to keep the season from feeling completely flatlined. It may not have saved the year, but it gave Norvell something he badly needed: evidence that his team is still willing to run through a wall for him.
That has been a recurring theme during his tenure. When the pressure builds, his teams have often responded with their best effort, and Saturday fit that pattern.
Few outside the locker room expected FSU to hang with a top-three opponent, much less push it to the wire. Instead, the Seminoles gave themselves a real shot at a season-defining upset.
Still, the criticism isn’t going anywhere.
The biggest frustration remains the same one that surfaced after the Louisville loss: Florida State left points on the field. Twice inside the Miami 5-yard line, the Seminoles came away empty on failed fourth-down tries. The decisions reflected Norvell’s aggressive style and his belief in his play-calling, but they also fed a familiar complaint.
At some point, taking the points matters.
In a game that needed two overtime periods, those six points became impossible to ignore. That’s why the postgame what-ifs kept piling up.
What if Florida State kicked the field goals? What if it forced Miami to chase?
What if one call had changed everything and delivered the biggest win of the Norvell era?
None of those answers exist. What does exist is a 3-4 team heading back to Tallahassee with an ugly road losing streak still in place. But the next stretch does offer a path forward.
FSU has a bye week before Clemson comes to town on Halloween. Then comes a run of games against Pitt, Boston College, NC State and Florida. The Seminoles still have a real shot to climb back toward .500 and keep bowl hopes alive, and Saturday’s showing against Miami suggests they can at least walk into the Clemson game believing they belong on the field.
That’s why a move now would feel premature.
This isn’t a case for giving Norvell a free pass. The results still have to change, and Florida State will be judged by wins and losses just like everyone else. But after watching the Seminoles fight Miami for four quarters and two overtimes, there’s enough reason to let the season keep unfolding before making a final call.
Norvell is still under pressure. One fierce effort doesn’t wash away months of frustration.
But it did show something important: Florida State is still playing for him. Whether that turns into wins over the final stretch is another question entirely.
For now, though, the performance in Miami likely bought him what he needed most - time.
In Other News...
Miami Is 6-0 But One Midseason Concern Won't Go Away
Miami has kept rolling to a 6-0 start and stays firmly in the national conversation, but the unbeaten record has not erased every concern around this team. Even with quarterback Darian Mensah and receiver Malachi Toney delivering standout play, the Hurricanes have had to navigate injuries and uneven stretches that have kept the week-to-week picture from feeling entirely settled.
The biggest issue continues to hover around the offensive front and the running back group, both of which have been affected by injuries and in turn put more pressure on the rest of the offense. On defense, Miami has been sturdy against the run, but the challenge has been clear against mobile quarterbacks and in pass protection, which leaves a real midseason question for a team with bigger goals than just staying undefeated. [Read more 🡒]
Miamis Florida State Win Exposed Who Carried The Canes
Miamis win over Florida State offered a pretty clear snapshot of which Hurricanes players drove the result and which ones left some questions behind. The breakdown leaned on both eye test and Pro Football Focus grades, giving a fuller view of who stacked up in the matchup and who struggled to match the moment in a game that had plenty of physical play and a few injury concerns along the way.
The comparison also surfaced some interesting gaps between what stood out live and what showed up in the grading. A handful of players landed near the top of both lists, while others were viewed much less favorably once the film and the numbers were lined up, leaving a useful if imperfect picture of how Miami got through one of its biggest games and which performances helped carry the Canes. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Can End Notre Dame's Playoff Dream With One More Loss
Miamis rise to No. 1 in the latest AP Top 25 poll has only sharpened the spotlight on what comes next, and Notre Dame is walking into that matchup with plenty on the line. The Irish were already dealing with the sting of a close loss to BYU, a game that ended amid controversy and prompted the Atlantic Coast Conference to announce a review of the officiating at the finish.
Now the schedule has put Notre Dame in a spot where another loss could make its College Football Playoff path far more complicated, even with the expanded 12-team field. For Miami, it is another chance to reinforce its place at the top. For Notre Dame, it is the kind of game that can either steady a season or push the margin for error almost to nothing. [Read more 🡒]