Miami’s wait for the AP top spot could finally be over.
The Hurricanes have not been No. 1 in the AP Top 25 since Dec. 8, 2002, but a wild Saturday across college football put them in prime position to reclaim it. Miami survived Florida State 43-35 in double overtime while five of the top seven teams in the poll lost, leaving the unbeaten Hurricanes as the clearest candidate for the No. 1 ranking.
No. 1 Georgia was knocked off 27-24 by Auburn on Alex McPherson’s 34-yard field goal.
No. 2 Notre Dame fell 28-24 at No.
8 BYU, with quarterback Bear Bachmeier delivering the go-ahead touchdown pass with 1:47 remaining. Miami, ranked No. 3, was the highest-ranked team still unbeaten when the day ended, though BYU made the loudest push to jump the line.
This would be the first time Miami has sat atop the poll since the Larry Coker era, when the Hurricanes were defending the 2001 national championship. Miami spent 21 straight weeks as the AP’s No. 1 team across 2001 and 2002, dropped to No. 2 behind Oklahoma on Nov. 3, 2002, then moved back to the top a week later.
That run ended with a 31-24 double-overtime loss to Ohio State in the Fiesta Bowl on Jan. 3, 2003.
This year’s Hurricanes were pushed just as hard by Florida State, which tied the game 28-28 on Ashton Daniels’ 75-yard touchdown pass to Duce Robinson with 2:39 left. Miami coach Mario Cristobal had already warned against any sense of entitlement, saying this week, “If anyone is assuming that they should win or they’re entitled to winning, they’re out of their minds,”
Miami answered with Darian Mensah throwing for 326 yards and three touchdowns on 23 completions in 34 attempts. Malachi Toney was the biggest weapon in the passing game, catching 11 balls for 154 yards and two touchdowns. He also handled a 2-point conversion pass to Cooper Barkate in the second overtime.
The Hurricanes also got 108 rushing yards and two touchdowns from freshman Javian Mallory, plus a final-play interception by Bryce Fitzgerald to seal it. Miami finished with a 49% success rate, compared with Florida State’s 35%.
BYU’s case is built on the kind of win that gets everyone’s attention. The Cougars have not been No. 1 since their 1984 national title team finished first in the final AP poll, but Saturday’s victory over Notre Dame came in the first top-10 matchup ever held at LaVell Edwards Stadium. College GameDay was also in Provo for the occasion.
Bachmeier did a little bit of everything. He ran for two touchdowns, caught a 15-yard score on a double pass from Kyler Kasper, and found tight end Walker Lyons on a 6-yard touchdown pass for the winner.
He did it without LJ Martin, the 2025 Big 12 offensive player of the year, who missed his second straight game with a lower-body injury. Bachmeier is now 18-2 as a starter.
Before kickoff, BYU coach Kalani Sitake sounded ready for the spotlight. “ What do we have to lose, man? This is the matchup we wanted from the very beginning,” he said.
Still, the Cougars’ overall resume is lighter than Miami’s. Their best other win came at TCU, 17-10, and their remaining victories are over Arizona, Colorado State, Iowa State and Big Sky member Utah Tech.
Miami entered Week 7 ranked ahead of BYU, and it was the only team in the top three to win on Saturday. Rewarding a team that survived a rivalry battle behind one that started the day five spots lower would be a tough sell.
The Hurricanes also bring a stronger full-season profile. Their 41-13 road win at Clemson included six sacks of Tigers quarterback Tait Reynolds, and they also own lopsided victories over Stanford and Central Michigan.
BYU’s upset of No. 2 Notre Dame is the biggest single result of the two, but it is still one game.
Ohio State also has a case after its 19-15 win at Indiana snapped the Hoosiers’ 22-game winning streak, but the Buckeyes’ 24-23 loss to Texas keeps them behind the two unbeaten teams.
The cleanest order looks like Miami at No. 1, BYU at No. 2 and Ohio State at No.
- Miami’s next game is Oct. 24 against Pitt, and its toughest remaining matchup comes Nov. 7 at Notre Dame.
In Other News...
Miami Survived FSU But The Ending Will Fuel Rivalry Debate
Miamis win over Florida State had all the ingredients of a classic rivalry game, from the points to the tension to the kind of late drama that gets replayed for years. The Hurricanes came away with a 43-35 victory, but the closing minutes became the main talking point after a holding penalty on Florida States Xavier Chaplin wiped out what would have been a game-tying touchdown catch by Micahi Danzy.
What followed only added to the frustration in Tallahassee, as the Seminoles Hail Mary on the next play was ruled an interception after review. ESPN rules analyst Steve Shaw backed the decision, but that is unlikely to quiet the debate anytime soon, especially in a rivalry where every close call tends to linger long after the final whistle. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Escaped Florida State But One Problem Should Worry Hurricanes Fans
Miami survived one of its toughest tests of the season, outlasting Florida State 43-35 in double overtime at Hard Rock Stadium to stay unbeaten at 6-0 and move to 4-0 in the ACC. It was the kind of rivalry game that can tell a team plenty about itself, and Miami got major offensive contributions from Javian Mallory, who ran for 108 yards and two scores, and Malachi Toney, who piled up 154 receiving yards and two touchdowns.
Still, the bigger takeaway for Hurricanes fans might be on the other side of the ball. A defense that had carried a top-ranked reputation gave up 35 points and 443 yards, including a late 75-yard touchdown that forced overtime in the first place. Miami eventually finished the job on a two-point conversion in the second overtime, but after a night like this, the standard on defense suddenly feels a little less secure. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Beat FSU But One Trouble Spot Just Got Harder To Ignore
The comeback win over Florida State gave Miami plenty to feel good about, especially after a double-overtime battle that ended 43-35 and showcased just how dangerous the offense can be when it finds rhythm. Malachi Toney was a constant problem for the Seminoles with 11 catches for 154 yards and two touchdowns, while Javian Mallory added 108 rushing yards and two more scores to help carry the Hurricanes through a game that demanded every bit of their depth and composure.
Still, the victory came with another concern that has been building in plain sight: the secondary. Miami dealt with multiple injuries in the defensive backfield, including Bryce Fitzgerald and Zechariah Poyser, and that kind of attrition makes an already important part of the defense even more fragile. The Hurricanes escaped with one of their biggest wins of the season, but the health of that group is shaping up as a storyline worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]