The latest College Football Playoff rankings delivered a familiar kind of twist: Notre Dame sits at No. 6, Miami at No. 7, and this time the committee is leaning on the head-to-head result that decided their meeting on the field.
The Fighting Irish are 9-1, the Hurricanes are 9-1, and Notre Dame’s 31-24 win in South Bend on Nov. 7 is the cleanest separator between them. That part is straightforward. What makes the placement amusing is the committee’s history with this exact matchup.
Last year, the order went the other way on the field but not in the rankings. Miami beat Notre Dame 27-24 in the season opener on Aug. 31, yet the Irish stayed ahead of the Hurricanes through the first five CFP releases. Miami opened at No. 18 on Nov. 4, eight spots behind Notre Dame, and kept climbing without ever moving in front of the Irish until the final rankings.
Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek kept pointing to the same explanation: the head-to-head result did not carry enough weight because the teams had not been placed in the same comparative group during earlier evaluations. Even on Dec.
2, Notre Dame was No. 10, BYU was No. 11 and Miami was No.
That changed after BYU lost 34-7 to Texas Tech in the Big 12 championship game. Miami moved up to No. 10 in the final rankings, Notre Dame slid to No. 11 and BYU fell to No.
- Neither Miami nor Notre Dame played that weekend.
When ESPN’s Rece Davis pushed Yurachek on the decision, the chairman said the teams had finally been in the same evaluation group before the final rankings. His reasoning was that the committee had Notre Dame above BYU and BYU above Miami, which left Miami’s win over Notre Dame without enough force to alter the order.
This year’s setup is different in a few important ways. Notre Dame’s win over Miami came just 10 days before the latest rankings, and the Irish were already ahead of the Hurricanes in the Nov. 10 release, when Notre Dame was No.
5, Miami was No. 7 and Texas sat between them at No. 6.
Texas then moved up to No. 5 after beating LSU, clearing the path for Notre Dame to rise directly above Miami.
There’s also the new CFP rule this season that guarantees Notre Dame a playoff berth if it finishes in the committee’s top 12.
So no, the committee is not out of line for putting Notre Dame ahead of Miami. Head-to-head is a perfectly sensible tiebreaker here, and the committee does weigh more than one factor. Still, after last year’s Miami-Notre Dame mess, the timing makes the whole thing hard not to laugh at.
In Other News...
Cam Vaughns Miami Fallout Just Took Another Turn
Cam Vaughns Miami run ended long before this season, but the fallout from his dismissal has kept moving through the system. The former Hurricanes wide receiver filed a lawsuit against the university and the NCAA after his scholarship was canceled, turning what was already a messy separation into a broader dispute over his future in college football.
Now the next chapter appears to be a delayed one. The universitys response led to a legislative relief waiver request, Vaughn has not been on a roster this season, and he is reportedly aiming for the 2027 spring transfer portal as he looks for a fresh start somewhere else. [Read more 🡒]
Malachi Toney Update Carries Major Weight For Miamis Playoff Push
Malachi Toneys recovery has become one of the quieter but more important storylines around Miami as the Hurricanes keep pushing toward the postseason. The wide receiver is coming back from tightrope surgery for a high ankle injury, and there has been a notable step forward with Toney now seen walking without a boot. He has also remained around the program, attending practices and treatments while working his way back.
Cooper Barkate said Toney is making progress both mentally and physically, a useful sign for a Miami team that could use every bit of depth it can get down the stretch. The earliest Toney might be available is the ACC championship game, which gives the Hurricanes at least a sliver of hope for a late-season boost at a moment when the College Football Playoff picture is very much in play. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Is One Home Win From A Much Bigger Prize
No. 7 Miami heads back to Hard Rock Stadium on Saturday with more than a routine home date on the line. At 9-1, the Hurricanes are still in the College Football Playoff conversation after their latest win, and a victory over Virginia Tech would lock up a trip to the ACC Championship Game, turning one more home test into a chance at something much bigger.
Virginia Tech arrives on a two-game skid under coach James Franklin, trying to steady itself against a Miami team that has handled the seasons pressure well enough to stay in the rankings. The matchup also comes with the usual late-November details fans will want, from injury updates to broadcast information, but the larger picture is simple: Miami is one win away from making the next step official. [Read more 🡒]
