Malachi Toneys What-If Still Haunts A Heisman Race Miami Owned

As the Heisman race narrows, Jeremiah Smith seems poised for victory amidst the backdrop of an intriguing rivalry cut short by Malachi Toney's untimely injury.

For most of the fall, the Heisman race looked like it might stay wide open. Now, with the calendar flipping into the middle of November, it has tightened fast around Jeremiah Smith.

Smith sits at -220 on FanDuel, and Darian Mensah, listed at +450, has done his part to keep things from getting completely out of hand. But the gap has grown so large that Mensah would likely need back-to-back 500-yard, six-touchdown performances - or some kind of unfortunate break - to make this interesting again.

Smith’s case has only gotten stronger because he has kept producing even with his starting quarterback, Julian Sayin, dealing with injury. Mensah has been asked to carry more of the load too, and he has answered by showing his leadership in the absence of Malachi Toney.

Toney’s injury is the part that really changed the shape of this race. If he had stayed healthy, the Heisman conversation could have been much tighter. His final three games showed the kind of surge that suggested he was headed for a strong finish, and there was also the personal angle: he and Smith attended rival high schools in Broward County.

The two know each other well, respect each other, and have openly enjoyed the competitive edge of that friendship. A Heisman duel between them would have given the college football chatter machine plenty to chew on.

There’s still a tiny chance Smith comes back for another season, since he has the eligibility. But the far more likely path has him heading toward the 2027 NFL Draft, where he projects as a top-five pick. Toney’s rise, meanwhile, is expected to keep going, with a first-round selection in the 2028 NFL Draft on the horizon.

The odds also point toward the expected four players making the trip to New York for the Heisman ceremony. Smith and Mensah look like locks. Dampier should be there too if Utah keeps winning, especially with how central he is to the Utes’ success.

The fourth spot is the one that still has some life to it. If Notre Dame wins out, Carr would seem to have the inside track. But if Russell puts up big numbers against mighty UT-Chattanooga, Auburn, and in the SEC Championship, there would be a real argument for him as well.

A few months ago, this race had room for all kinds of twists. Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss looked like the early front-runner after one month, Mississippi State’s Kamario Taylor was climbing, and Florida’s Jadan Baugh had made a serious move. Now the picture is much clearer: the winner looks close to decided, and the only real question left is who gets to sit in the front row.

In Other News...

Cam Vaughns Miami Fallout Just Took Another Turn

Cam Vaughns Miami run ended long before this season, but the fallout from his dismissal has kept moving through the system. The former Hurricanes wide receiver filed a lawsuit against the university and the NCAA after his scholarship was canceled, turning what was already a messy separation into a broader dispute over his future in college football.

Now the next chapter appears to be a delayed one. The universitys response led to a legislative relief waiver request, Vaughn has not been on a roster this season, and he is reportedly aiming for the 2027 spring transfer portal as he looks for a fresh start somewhere else. [Read more 🡒]

Malachi Toney Update Carries Major Weight For Miamis Playoff Push

Malachi Toneys recovery has become one of the quieter but more important storylines around Miami as the Hurricanes keep pushing toward the postseason. The wide receiver is coming back from tightrope surgery for a high ankle injury, and there has been a notable step forward with Toney now seen walking without a boot. He has also remained around the program, attending practices and treatments while working his way back.

Cooper Barkate said Toney is making progress both mentally and physically, a useful sign for a Miami team that could use every bit of depth it can get down the stretch. The earliest Toney might be available is the ACC championship game, which gives the Hurricanes at least a sliver of hope for a late-season boost at a moment when the College Football Playoff picture is very much in play. [Read more 🡒]

Miami Is One Home Win From A Much Bigger Prize

No. 7 Miami heads back to Hard Rock Stadium on Saturday with more than a routine home date on the line. At 9-1, the Hurricanes are still in the College Football Playoff conversation after their latest win, and a victory over Virginia Tech would lock up a trip to the ACC Championship Game, turning one more home test into a chance at something much bigger.

Virginia Tech arrives on a two-game skid under coach James Franklin, trying to steady itself against a Miami team that has handled the seasons pressure well enough to stay in the rankings. The matchup also comes with the usual late-November details fans will want, from injury updates to broadcast information, but the larger picture is simple: Miami is one win away from making the next step official. [Read more 🡒]