The 2026 Heisman Trophy race is coming into focus around two receivers from South Florida, and both have made a strong case in very different ways.
Malachi Toney and Jeremiah Smith have each been central to the success of two of the nation’s best teams. Toney, the 5-foot-10, 190-pound slot receiver, has built his season on quickness, precision route running and hands that do not give defenses any breathing room.
He has 66 catches for 952 yards and 11 touchdowns. Smith, the 6-foot-4, 222-pound outside target, brings a different kind of stress to a defense with size, speed and power.
Through seven games, he has 984 yards and 12 touchdowns.
If the argument starts with pure reliability, Toney has the edge.
He has an 89.2 percent catch rate, zero drops on 74 targets, zero interceptions on balls thrown his way and a perfect 158.3 passer rating when targeted. His 0.68 EPA per target leads the country. For the quarterback, throwing to Toney is about as close to a sure thing as it gets.
That trust shows up after the catch too. Toney has piled up 463 yards after the catch and forced 17 missed tackles, which ranks second nationally.
Eight of those missed tackles came on screens and swing passes behind the line, where he turned 17 catches into 171 yards after the catch. In other words, the short game is not just safe with him - it becomes a weapon.
The intermediate game is where Toney really separates himself.
On targets between 10 and 19 yards, he has caught 19 of 21 passes for 382 yards, 20.1 yards per catch, 133 yards after the catch and four touchdowns. His 158.3 NFL quarterback rating in that range is perfect. That production also tops Smith’s at the same depth, where Smith has 296 yards, a 75 percent catch rate and two interceptions when targeted, despite fewer targets.
Toney’s impact does not stop there. In the red zone, he has been the most productive pass catcher in the country, with 12 receptions and eight touchdowns in that area.
His 109 receiving yards and eight touchdowns in the red zone both lead the nation. Even as a smaller target, he has also shown he can win deep, having been targeted only nine times on deep passes but catching seven for 245 yards and three touchdowns with a 158.3 rating.
He also gets a small edge in the run game. Toney owns a 74.3 PFF run-block grade compared with Smith’s 66.4, and that comes on nearly identical blocking snap counts, 152 for Toney and 149 for Smith.
Smith’s case is built on explosiveness.
He is not as efficient as Toney, but his big-play profile is unmatched. His 4.78 yards per route run leads the country, even with a 15.4-yard average depth of target and 22 contested targets, which is twice Toney’s total. His numbers have to be viewed in the context of the routes he is running: 42 go routes and 23 posts into boundary coverage.
When Smith wins, it usually turns into something big. He has been targeted 22 times on deep shots and turned them into 421 yards and six touchdowns, with a long of 72 yards. Half of his touchdowns have come from 20-plus yards out, and no one with a similar target load is close to that level of production.
That explosiveness shows up in the way the ball keeps moving after the catch too. Smith is averaging 18.9 yards per catch, and 84.6 percent of his catches have gone for either a first down or a touchdown, compared with 68.2 percent for Toney. Ohio State also uses him all over the field, which makes it harder for defenses to isolate him with one coverage adjustment.
The contrast is pretty clean. Toney is the slot receiver who keeps drives alive with elite hands and yards after the catch.
Smith is the boundary receiver who can flip a game with one snap. If the question is who is more likely to catch the ball and extend the drive, it is Toney.
If the question is who can turn one route into 20 yards and six points, it is Smith.
Smith’s volatility comes with some cost. He has three interceptions on his targets this season, his 71 percent catch rate trails Toney’s 89.2 percent mark, and he has dropped two catchable passes. Still, he is running one of the toughest route trees in the country and remains No. 1 in the most context-adjusted efficiency stat there is.
Toney, though, wins more categories overall, including targeted EPA, where he holds a 74.25 to 67.11 advantage, and targeted NFL passer rating, where he leads 158.3 to 136.0. On a per-down basis, and on a per-target basis, the numbers say he is the more valuable player.
That does not end the race. Big games down the stretch will matter most.
Smith had eight catches for 164 yards and a touchdown in a week two win over then-No. 4 Texas, and later added 11 receptions for 206 yards and two touchdowns against then-No.
14 Iowa. Toney answered in a rivalry game against Florida State with 11 catches for 154 yards and two touchdowns, plus 31 rushing yards and a two-point conversion that helped win the game.
The problem for Toney is that Florida State does not carry much national respect.
His Notre Dame performance will shape plenty of Heisman chatter. If he delivers on that stage, he could enter the final month of the regular season as the favorite.
In Other News...
Miami Heads To UNC With One Injury Concern Still Lingering
Miami heads to North Carolina with the usual late-week injury report bringing more questions than comfort, even before the trip north gets underway. Six Hurricanes are already ruled out, including wide receiver Joshua Moore and running back CharMar Brown, thinning out depth at two spots Miami would prefer to keep stocked for a road game with real ACC weight.
Milan Parris, the freshman who had been worth monitoring, is not listed, but the lingering concern around veteran cornerback Xavier Lucas keeps at least one part of Miamis preparation under a bit of a cloud. UNC has its own defensive uncertainty with several starters either out or questionable, so the matchup carries the feel of a game where availability could matter as much as scheme once the teams finally take the field. [Read more 🡒]
Notre Dame Could Be Miamis Biggest Unbeaten Test Yet
Miami heads into Halloween weekend as one of just three unbeaten FBS teams left standing, and the attention now shifts from preserving the perfect record to surviving what comes next. The Hurricanes have paired a strong offense with a defense that has kept opposing teams under control, which has made their start look sustainable rather than lucky, but the calendar only gets less forgiving from here.
Notre Dame looms as the kind of matchup that can tell everyone whether Miamis unbeaten run is a statement or just a fast start. Other unbeaten teams like Utah and UCLA have their own tricky paths ahead, and projections still point to all three landing in the same neighborhood by seasons end, but for Miami the next test could be the one that defines how serious this season really is. [Read more 🡒]
Belichick Faces A Brutal North Carolina Test At No. 1 Miami
Miami has climbed to No. 1 in the AP Top 25 for the first time since 2002, and the timing only sharpens the spotlight on what comes next. A strong start has pushed the Hurricanes into rarefied territory, backed by a 14-1 run over their last 15 games and powered by a roster that can make almost any Saturday feel like a showcase.
North Carolina arrives with its own history in this matchup, having won the last five meetings, including two against Miami coach Mario Cristobal. The Tar Heels will have to deal with two Heisman Trophy contenders in quarterback Darian Mensah and wide receiver Malachi Toney, both of whom sit near the top of the national statistical picture, which is exactly why this game feels less like a checkpoint and more like a measuring stick. [Read more 🡒]