With roughly six weeks left before the 2026 Heisman Trophy is handed out, the race has tilted in a direction that does not happen often. The award has long belonged to quarterbacks and running backs, with the occasional two-way star crashing the party. This year, though, two wide receivers have pushed themselves into the center of the conversation: Ohio State’s Jeremiah Smith and Miami’s Malachi Toney.
That alone makes this a rare kind of Heisman chase. Only four wide receivers have ever won the trophy, and the list is short enough to know by heart: Tim Brown in 1987, Desmond Howard in 1991, DeVonta Smith in 2020 and Travis Hunter in 2024.
Brown and Howard were returners as well as receivers, and DeVonta Smith’s 2020 run ended a 29-year stretch without a wideout taking the award. Hunter, meanwhile, played both defensive back and receiver at Colorado, though he did not contribute on special teams.
The standard for comparison in this race is obvious. DeVonta Smith’s Heisman season remains the clearest blueprint for a receiver winning the sport’s top individual honor, and the numbers from his 2020 campaign give Toney and Jeremiah Smith a meaningful measuring stick.
Toney has matched that pace in a lot of ways through seven games for undefeated Miami. He has 66 receptions to DeVonta Smith’s 65, has topped him in receiving yards with 952 to 903, and has one more touchdown catch at 11.
Toney has also added 50 rushing yards, along with six punt returns for 69 yards. DeVonta Smith had only two rushing yards and two punt returns for 50 yards in that same comparison.
Jeremiah Smith’s case looks just as strong in a different way. He has also played seven games, but unlike DeVonta Smith and Toney, he has not been as involved on special teams.
Even so, the production jumps off the page: 52 catches for 984 yards and 12 touchdowns, plus seven rushing yards. In the punt return game, he has two returns for minus-6 yards, while DeVonta Smith had two returns for 50 yards.
DeVonta Smith’s full 2020 season still stands as the high bar. He finished with 117 catches for 1,856 yards and 23 touchdowns, averaging 15.9 receptions per game.
His signature Heisman moment came against Florida in the SEC Championship Game, when he turned in a career-best 15 receptions for 184 yards and two touchdowns. That performance set an SEC title game record, and he was named the game’s MVP.
He kept rolling after the Heisman ceremony, too. In Alabama’s College Football Playoff win over Notre Dame, Smith had seven catches for 130 yards and three touchdowns. Then in the national title game against Ohio State, he put up 12 receptions for 215 yards and three more scores.
Both Smith and Toney have also been asked directly about the award. Jeremiah Smith said in early October, "You've just got to [let] the Heisman voters or whoever it is know that I'm the best player in the country. I've got to be there."
Toney has also drawn support from his own locker room. Miami quarterback Darian Mensah made the case for his teammate on Oct. 28, saying, "The biggest thing that sets him apart from everybody else is his eagerness to go out and block for his teammates," Mensah said on Oct.
28." I think if you turn on the tape, he does it at such a high level that it's different.
He's obviously a great person but he wants to see his teammates win. And I think he's just a selfless person.
I think that's why he should win.”
Mensah’s endorsement carries a little extra weight because he is also the Heisman favorite outside of Smith and Toney. DraftKings Sportsbook lists Jeremiah Smith at +122, Mensah at +270, Toney at +360, CJ Carr at +2000, Trinidad Chambliss at +2400, Jesse Legree at +3000, Drew Mestemaker at +4000 and Gunner Stockton at +5000.
In Other News...
Miami Escaped North Carolina But One Problem Just Got Harder To Ignore
Miami survived a Halloween scare in Chapel Hill, edging North Carolina 38-35 to snap a five-game skid in the series and pick up its first win there since 2017. The No. 1 Hurricanes needed plenty of offense to do it, with Darian Mensah throwing for 274 yards and three touchdowns while completing 76% of his passes, and Malachi Toney adding seven catches for 75 yards and two scores.
Still, the bigger takeaway may have been on the other side of the ball, where Miami had to lean on a late defensive stand to finish the job. Marquise Lightfoot came up with two sacks and a forced fumble in the closing stretch, a reminder that even in a win, the Hurricanes are still searching for more consistent answers when games tighten up late. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Escaped North Carolina But One Problem Should Worry Hurricanes Fans
Miami left Chapel Hill with a 38-35 win, but it was the kind of victory that still gives a fan base plenty to chew on afterward. Darian Mensah threw for 274 yards and three touchdowns, and Mark Fletcher, Jr. found the end zone both on the ground and through the air, giving the Hurricanes enough offense to survive a night when the game never felt fully under control.
Miamis late key plays were enough to close it out, yet the defensive issues that showed up against North Carolina are hard to ignore. The Hurricanes did enough to protect the win, but the way they had to do it will linger as the bigger concern, especially with tougher tests still ahead. [Read more 🡒]
Mark Fletcher Jr. Just Reached A Miami Milestone Few Ever Touch
Mark Fletcher Jr. keeps adding to a Miami rsum that already looked sturdy, and his latest score against North Carolina pushed him into a place few Hurricanes have ever reached. The senior running back found the end zone on a 31-yard receiving play, a fitting way to claim the programs all-time lead in total touchdowns and move past a standard that had been shared by Stephen McGuire and Edgerrin James.
For a player who has been a steady part of Miamis offense across four seasons, the milestone says as much about durability and consistency as it does about one big play. Fletcher has been one of the offenses most reliable pieces, and now his name sits alone atop a list that carries real weight in Hurricanes history, with the rest of his final season still offering chances to add to it. [Read more 🡒]