Darian Mensah has played his way into the thick of the Heisman Trophy race, but the NFL draft conversation around him is still strangely split.
The Miami quarterback has been electric through eight games, piling up 25 touchdowns against just one interception while completing more than 80 percent of his passes. That kind of production would usually push a passer toward the top of draft boards. In Mensah’s case, though, the opinions are all over the place.
Some evaluators see a premium prospect. ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. has Mensah fourth among all prospects in 2027.
Others are nowhere near that bullish. Sporting News’ Vinnie Iyer does not have Mensah in the first round of his latest mock draft, and CBS Sports places him 81st among all prospects.
That spread says plenty about where things stand. Mensah looks like the kind of quarterback who could end up going very high if even one team falls in love with him. And with the way he’s producing, it wouldn’t be a shock if he winds up near the top of the first round.
So why the hesitation?
The biggest question mark is arm strength. It’s not a glaring flaw, but it also doesn’t leap off the tape the way it does with some of the top quarterback prospects in the league pipeline. Mensah has compensated for that with excellent ball placement at the college level, but NFL teams will have to decide whether that trait translates when the windows get tighter and the game speeds up.
There’s also the matter of Miami’s schedule. The Hurricanes haven’t faced many elite defenses yet, which makes it harder to fully judge Mensah’s decision-making. That should start to change soon, with Notre Dame on the schedule and at least one major College Football Playoff matchup likely ahead.
If Mensah keeps putting up these numbers against better competition, he could go a long way toward quieting the doubters.
In Other News...
Miamis Notre Dame Plan Hinges On One Massive Malachi Toney Unknown
Notre Dame is still planning as if Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney could be part of the picture, even though the early read has him trending toward the sidelines after a high ankle sprain and surgery. Marcus Freeman said the Irish are preparing for the possibility Toney suits up, which tells you how much respect Notre Dame has for Miamis offense and how much uncertainty still hangs over this matchup.
For the Hurricanes, the bigger issue may be how they adjust if Toney is unavailable again, not just for this game but for the rest of the regular season and potentially the College Football Playoffs. Notre Dame also expects All-American cornerback Leonard Moore back after he missed recent games with a concussion, adding another layer to a game plan that already has to account for one major unknown on Miamis side. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Now Gets A Notre Dame Team With Everything To Lose
Notre Dames playoff positioning already has a strange look to it, sitting 11th in the first College Football Playoff rankings despite being fourth in the AP poll. The reason is pretty clear: the committee has not been sold on the Irishs resume, and the lack of signature wins has left little margin for error as the season tightens. Now the next stop brings a trip to No. 1 Miami, and for a team trying to prove it belongs in the top tier, the timing could hardly be more demanding.
The Hurricanes also know they will see Notre Dame without wide receiver Malachi Toney, who is out after ankle surgery and expected to miss 4 to 6 weeks. Even with that setback, the bigger pressure point is on the Irish, who need a win in Miami to strengthen their playoff case before the schedule offers fewer chances to recover from another loss. For a team already facing scrutiny from the committee, this is the kind of game that can reshape the conversation quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Suddenly Faces A Bigger Problem Than Just Losing Malachi Toney
Malachi Toneys high ankle sprain already put Miami in a difficult spot, but the bigger concern around the Hurricanes now is how quickly the injury list has become a season-altering issue. Toney will miss at least four to six weeks after surgery, and for a Miami team trying to keep its offense on track, losing a player of his importance changes the feel of what comes next.
The concern only grows when you look around the college football landscape and see how injuries have hit the other faces of the EA Sports College Football 27 cover. Dante Moore is out for the season after a concussion, while Kewan Lacy is sidelined after dislocating his shoulder, a reminder that the sport can turn fast and leave even marquee names scrambling. For Miami, the immediate challenge is no longer just replacing one playmaker, but managing the ripple effect of losing him for a significant stretch. [Read more 🡒]