The Heisman picture has all but narrowed to Jeremiah Smith, and the latest odds only underline it. The Ohio State wide receiver sits at -110 on FanDuel, making him the clear front-runner as long as he stays healthy and on the field.
That leaves the real intrigue elsewhere: who joins him in New York. Darian Mensah is still in the mix and remains second in the odds, though he has slipped to +700.
Alabama quarterback Keelon Russell is also at +700, followed by Notre Dame’s CJ Carr at +750. Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss is next at +1500, with Texas quarterback Arch Manning, Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney and Georgia quarterback Gunner Stockton all at +3000.
Mississippi State quarterback Kamario Taylor and Ohio State quarterback Julian Sayin are both at +3500.
Mensah’s Heisman case is interesting because it comes with another major honor attached to it. He also looks like the favorite for the Davey O’Brien Award, and if he wins it, he’d become the fourth Miami Hurricane to take home the prize, joining Vinny Testaverde in 1986, Gino Torretta in 1992 and Cam Ward in 2024.
Carr’s placement near the top of the board is tougher to explain. He has not thrown for more than 253 yards in any of his five games this season, and while he’s a solid quarterback, the odds seem generous compared to Chambliss. Taylor and Florida’s Jadan Baugh were both brief favorites at one point too, but their numbers have tumbled sharply - Taylor from +750 to +3500 and Baugh from +1500 to +8000.
Once the conversation moves beyond Mensah, Russell and Chambliss, the quarterback field gets thin in a hurry. Manning is not being viewed as a real Heisman threat, Stockton’s production is hard to project because of how Georgia’s offense is built, and Sayin benefits from the simple fact that he’s the one throwing to Smith.
So what would it take for Mensah to make this a real race? The source of hope is the Notre Dame game, and it would need to be huge - something like 450-plus passing yards and five touchdowns. Even then, Smith would likely need to come back to earth, and that does not look likely given the way he has been producing.
There’s also the problem of split votes. If Mensah turns in a big performance, Toney could easily post numbers that look just as good, which would dilute Mensah’s case. Smith doesn’t face that same issue, because no one sees Sayin as a quarterback who will soak up serious Heisman support.
Mensah may not care much about the award itself anyway. His focus, as described in the source, is winning, and the Heisman is secondary to that.
He should still end up in New York as a finalist, which is its own achievement. But if he had to choose, he’d gladly hand over the trophy for a CFP Championship.
In Other News...
Miami Bye Week Put One Defensive Problem Under The Spotlight
The bye week gave Miami a chance to step back and look hard at a defense that has been good enough in stretches, but not clean enough in one of the most basic areas of the game. Through five games of the 2026 season, the Hurricanes sit 115th nationally in tackling grade according to Pro Football Focus, and the number fits the eye test for a unit that has at times let routine stops turn into extra yardage.
The encouraging part for Miami is that the problem does not appear to be universal. Chase Smith and Justin Scott have been among the defenders showing strong tackling consistency, while several others have missed at rates above 15 percent, a level that stands out compared with recent National Championship teams. As the season moves on, the Hurricanes will be judged not just by how often they get to the ball, but by how reliably they finish the play once they are there. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Just Sent A Clear ACC Message Before Florida State
The ACC race is tightening in a hurry, and Miami has put itself squarely in the thick of it with a decisive win over Clemson. Around the league, Florida State answered with a dominant showing against Virginia, Pittsburgh held off Virginia Tech despite losing starting quarterback Mason Heintschel to a torn ACL, Louisville has now dropped back-to-back games, and Wake Forest keeps hanging around as one of the conferences steadier teams.
What makes Miamis statement so important is the timing. With only three teams still unbeaten in ACC play, every week now feels like a separator, and the Hurricanes have given themselves a chance to shape the conversation before the Florida State matchup. The leagues depth is showing up in the standings and on the field, which means Miamis margin for error is getting smaller even as its own momentum keeps growing. [Read more 🡒]
Miami's Unbeaten Start Just Made The Canes' Road Far More Dangerous
Miamis 5-0 start and No. 4 ranking have made the Hurricanes impossible to ignore, but the real test is still in front of them. What looked like a manageable early path is giving way to a much tougher finish, and the back half of the schedule now carries the kind of stakes that can reshape a playoff case in a hurry.
Notre Dame looms on November 7 as the headline matchup, with Pitt, Virginia Tech and Duke also waiting in conference play. The case for Miami is stronger than it was in September, but the margin for error is shrinking because the remaining opponents have combined for a strong record, including three unbeaten teams, and the schedule debate is only going to get louder from here. [Read more 🡒]