Jeremiah Smith is back where he started: sitting on top of the Heisman Trophy odds board.
A week after briefly losing the lead, the Ohio State wide receiver has reclaimed favorite status, and this time he’s not just the favorite - he’s a minus-odds favorite. DraftKings has Smith at -144, while FanDuel lists him at -140, numbers that point to roughly a 58-to-59 percent chance of winning the award.
Smith kept his case rolling Saturday in Ohio State’s 28-19 win over Northwestern, finishing with 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown. In the process, he became the Big Ten’s career receiving yards leader and also claimed the FBS record for career receiving yards by a player in his first three college seasons.
That production has held up even with quarterback Julian Sayin injured, though the Buckeyes’ overall struggles have made the path bumpier than it looked earlier in the season. Smith’s Heisman run has already gone through several turns.
He entered the year as a contender, but quarterbacks were ahead of him in the betting picture. The logic was simple: “He’s an awesome receiver, but quarterbacks usually win.”
Then the quarterbacks started dropping away. Dante Moore and Sayin were hurt, while Arch Manning and Josh Hoover were uneven. The conversation shifted to something closer to: “Wow, this guy is really awesome, and none of the quarterbacks are special this year.”
When Sayin got hurt, the concern changed again. Suddenly the question was whether Smith could keep producing without his starting quarterback.
He stayed near the top, but the race tightened. Then Ohio State’s team struggles pushed him off the favorite spot altogether.
That opened the door for Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr, who moved into the lead after the Fighting Irish beat Miami in a game where he was the headliner. But Carr’s follow-up against Boston College was more efficient than explosive. He went 20-of-28 for 217 yards with two touchdowns and an interception in Notre Dame’s 41-7 win, and the shine from the Miami performance faded a bit.
That leaves the race right back where it was a month ago: “Smith is still really awesome, and none of the quarterbacks are special this year.”
Carr’s slide was notable, especially for Notre Dame fans, because he went from favorite to fourth in the odds after a game in which the Irish handled business without much drama.
Miami quarterback Darian Mensah moved up to second after his big day in a 36-25 win against Duke. Even with receiver Malachi Toney still out, Mensah put together a strong line, completing 30 of 41 passes for 382 yards and a touchdown. He’s now listed at +340 on DraftKings and +350 on FanDuel.
There’s also a late riser worth watching: Utah quarterback Devon Dampier. He’s making a push after a huge performance in the Utes’ 40-39 win at Arizona, one of the weekend’s most entertaining games.
Dampier’s passing line was solid rather than eye-popping - 13-of-25 for 204 yards with two passing touchdowns and an interception - but he added 100 rushing yards and two more scores on 14 carries. He was a constant problem for Arizona, and with Utah still one of the last two undefeated teams in college football, his candidacy has real momentum.
If the Utes finish 13-0, Dampier looks like a strong bet to at least reach New York as a finalist.
The odds reflect that rise. Dampier is +550 on FanDuel and +700 on DraftKings, while Carr sits at +1000 on DraftKings and +1100 on FanDuel.
For the moment, Smith, Mensah, Carr and Dampier stand apart from the rest of the field. Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker fell back after the Cowboys were blown out at home by Texas Tech.
Georgia’s Gunner Stockton, Alabama’s Keelon Russell and Wake Forest’s Gio Lopez remain long shots with workable routes to the trophy. Lopez is the newest name in that group after Wake Forest crushed SMU 42-0 at halftime and improved to 9-1.
In Other News...
Miami Just Landed A National Spotlight Fans Have Wanted Back
College GameDay is headed back to Coral Gables in 2026, giving Miami a national stage for its matchup with Virginia Tech at the University of Miami. The setup is the kind of spotlight Hurricanes fans have been waiting to reclaim, with both teams expected to bring similar records into a game that fits right in with the kind of competitive, early-season showcase ESPN likes to feature.
For Miami, the timing matters beyond the atmosphere. The broadcast gives the Hurricanes a chance to put Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney in front of a national audience at a moment when Heisman buzz can start to take shape, and it adds another layer of meaning to a game that already carries plenty of attention. A return visit from College GameDay does not decide a season, but it does signal that Miami is once again part of the conversation on a bigger stage. [Read more 🡒]
Carson Becks First NFL Start Was A Brutal Warning For Miami Fans
Carson Becks first NFL start was the kind of debut that can linger with Miami fans because it came with all the reminders of how quickly a quarterback can be overwhelmed at the next level. Starting for the Arizona Cardinals against the Los Angeles Rams, Beck finished 11 of 18 for 108 yards with two interceptions and a fumble as the offense never found its footing in a 34-6 loss.
Arizona managed only 123 total yards and spent much of the afternoon trying to survive without key offensive pieces, while the Rams controlled the game behind Matthew Stafford and Blake Corum. For Miami, the bigger takeaway is less about one ugly box score than the familiar concern it raises: even talented quarterbacks can look very different when the protection breaks down and the margin for error disappears. [Read more 🡒]
Miami Just Got A Huge Spotlight With Everything Suddenly At Stake
College GameDay is headed back to Coral Gables, and the timing could not be much bigger for Miami. ESPN will broadcast from the University of Miami campus on Saturday for the Hurricanes game against Virginia Tech, with the set up at Lakeside Patio from 9 a.m. to noon ET. For a team sitting at 9-1, it is the kind of national stage that comes with real consequences attached, not just a spotlight for the sake of one.
A win would clinch Miami a spot in the ACC championship game, turning a marquee broadcast into a game with direct postseason stakes. It will be the Hurricanes 27th College GameDay appearance and their 10th as the host site, another reminder that this program has long been part of the sports biggest Saturday scenes. This one, though, carries a little more weight than most. [Read more 🡒]
